Week 1 College Football Playoff Committee Rankings Thread

[Blake]

I feel like all the worthy teams are in. All the other teams had their chances.

TCU arguably was a top 4-5 team. What hurt them was not winning the Big 12. Baylor was the legitimate Big 12 champs but their strength of schedule hurt them.

I don't like the one loss defending champs being left out. I think they'd beat the out of Clemson.

[Pelicans78]

I don't like the one loss defending champs being left out. I think they'd beat the out of Clemson.

They probably would, but they didn't win their division and having them in would make the loss against Michigan State meaningless, especially if all the games were on a neutral field. I think if they want to go to 6 or 8 teams, they're going to have to make the 1st round on an opponent's homefield to make it fair to the top 4 seeds.

[Blake]

I think if they want to go to 6 or 8 teams, they're going to have to make the 1st round on an opponent's homefield to make it fair to the top 4 seeds.

eh, there's no fair way to objectively determine who should be ranked top four to get home field in the first round. They'd have to keep it neutral. Especially for travel purposes.