This isn't about Durant. This is about comparing players to the GOAT. You cannot be in the GOAT discussion without a ring. Your goalpost move is duly noted however.
Lol. Was durant better than horry without a ring? How about barkely? I win
This isn't about Durant. This is about comparing players to the GOAT. You cannot be in the GOAT discussion without a ring. Your goalpost move is duly noted however.
At the rings argument (in this case, the current one, since the other two have them too), once again provided without context.
If either swapped places with Durant, they'd be the reigning champion right now too. That has no bearing on level of play though, since it was men against boys and they'd have won no matter how he played. By virtually every metric, he was worse than either in the '17 playoffs. He upped his play in the Finals, but has a relatively (for a player of his caliber) minimal offensive load and plays within' pristine and unprecedented spacing.
Last edited by TD 21; 08-06-2017 at 10:53 PM.
He's not considered better than TD, at least, not by me.
Also, I'm not sure if Kawhi can get to Lebron's best (unless he improves his play making), but I do think Kawhi can still be the best player in the league. You don't have to be the best play maker in the NBA to be the best player on the planet.
Jordan certainly wasn't. And
They didn't win a ring in 2017. Context is everything.
They didn't. Go to that parallel universe and send video proof.If either swapped places with Durant, they'd be the reigning champion right now too. That has no bearing on level of play though, since it was men against boys and they'd have won no matter how he played. By virtually every metric, he was worse than either in the '17 playoffs. He upped his play in the Finals, but has a relatively (for a player of his caliber) minimal offensive load and plays within' pristine and unprecedented spacing.
Of course Spurs fans don't consider a Lebron better than Duncan. They don't mind citing 12 from SI and ESPN but scoff when that rating affects their guy.
I doubt any serious NBA pundit would rank Lebron lower than Duncan on the all time list.
Kawhi can become the best player on the planet if the other players get worse or get more help to dilute their contributions.
Context matters in these discussions, as you say... I'm fairly confident that if Kawhi had the la ude Lebron has as far as controlling his minutes, situations, etc, he likely would have more gaudy stats, which are always salient in these kind of discussions...
There's teams like the Dubs where the whole team is helping a guy reach an individual stat (ie: triple double), and that triggers the perception said player is an all-star, gets the media banter going, etc...
If anything, Duncan was so good in his prime, he stood out statistically on an environment that wasn't helping him stand out... although, it was a different game then, and we relied on our star way more...
Great point...
Who is better than Kawhi? Only Lebron IMO. All those other guys, if you want them, you can have them. I'll take Kawhi over all of them. He doesn't need them to get worse or for them to get more help to become the best player in the league - that's ridiculous. I think he will be there at the end of this upcoming season.
I'd take Kawhi because I like him better, win or lose. From a pure basketball standpoint, KD is better.
I like Kawhi's overall game over KD's. KD might be a better offensive player (as of now), but I'd take Kawhi over him because I think Kawhi is just a better overall player.
Because everyone has to get over himself...except Pop.
Kawhi gotta ask Jordan CIJON
Idiot alert
Alert not required, your name was all I needed.
If you think kd is better than kl youre a re . Its that simple.
USA Today lists KL at 4th overall
SI lists him at 6th overall
ESPN has him at 6th overall
All three of these have KD at 2nd overall.
These pundits have Curry and CP3 over Kawhi.
Must be a lot of re ed pundits. If they were only homers they'd see the light.
If anyone says he's the sixth best player........ they are full of crap! Popularity contest is what those clowns are on!!
Yes they are re ed pundits.
I think that list was months ago.. the new list will be released close to the start of the season and I'm very sure that he will be no lower than 4 on every list.
That's why Michael Jordan, someone who few argued wasn't the best in the game in his time, is saying what he's saying about Kawhi. It's like what Pop says why don't the call the MVP the 'MVOP?' Pundits notwithstanding the idea of Kawhi being the 6th best "two way player" is not something many would agree with. Jordan says he's the "best" and he has a wee bit more knowledge about what it takes. Kevin Durant looked great, once he joined a 73 win team.
I wouldn't put him at 6th, but the best I found was 4th. I rank him 3rd which is obviously generous considering. Saying he's 2nd best is just homerism, and fiercely proud of it too...
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)