Best chance of making it back big: TMac or AI

[anonoftheinternets]

Best chance of making it back big: TMac or AI

As the title says.

Assuming AI gets a team. Who can re-kindle their glory days?

[Hops]

McGrady, only b/c its a contract year

[Hornets1]

McGrady easily

[anonoftheinternets]

Both are players who need to be "the man" and might not coexist and coat-tail to a championship. Who has a better chance of relevance? AI is not as injured but is older. Tmac is more injured but younger.

[sook]

iverson, mac just had surgery and is a loser

[IronMexican]

Stephon Marbury

[anonoftheinternets]

Stephon Marbury

he has already made it back ... big ..larger than life, big ...

[in2deep]

AI doesn't even have a team :rolleyes

[anonoftheinternets]

AI doesn't even have a team :rolleyes



Assuming AI gets a team.

[in2deep]

BIG assumption

[The Franchise]

Tmac easily. I saw his resent rehab video and wouldn't be surprised if he is ready to go by the start of training camp.

[45 bank shot]

Tmac is done, A.I has a big heart

[j-money24]

T-mac because he's younger.

[DJB]

I say AI if he goes to the Knicks. TMac will just end up having back spasms 2 weeks in, pretty standard.

[jag]

T Mac's knee can heal...Iverson's age, not so much.

[Samr]

Yao Ming.

[angelbelow]

T-Mac is younger. That's the only reason why I voted for him.

[Allanon]

AI is 6' and 34 years old. He used to be faster than everybody but that isn't the case anymore and it's only going to get worse.

T-Mac even with his problems, is 6'7 and can rely on his length even if he slows down.

I think T-Mac has a good year, AI will probably continue on the decline although still putting up good numbers.

[Cry Havoc]

AI is a career 41% shooter. McGrady's best seasons blow Iverson's away like nobody's business.

[lil_penny]

T mac!!!

[Muser]

Tracy, when healthy (Yeah, not likely) he can be a beast.

[bdictjames]

McGrady. Iverson can even rarely put up 25 points per game these days, and he's just a scorer. T-mac opts for a triple double every now and then.

[23LeBronJames23]

Tracy McGrady.

[Rogue]

Both done, though I would pick AI if I had to choose either of them.

[spursfan1000]

AI, T-mac is just injury prone and there is nothing he can do about it.

[SpurCharger]

Is There Even A Comparison? When TMac Is healthy He is A Beast. but He does need to get out of the 1st Round of the Playoffs!

[Spursfan092120]

I'll be honest...I have a feeling T-Mac is going to be the comeback player of the year this year.

[Unholy Turkey]

They both have a better chance than Arenas.

[SpurCharger]

They both have a better chance than Arenas.
Agreed, How Many times Has Arenas Knees been Operated on???

[Unholy Turkey]

Too many, that's for sure.

Hahaha, he used to be my favorite player in the league. Now look at him.

Anyways, I think some team desperate for scoring will sign AI during the middle of the season. T-Mac will come back for sure too. They both have a lot to prove, and they can disprove these critics.

[R4R]

Not sure how this works, but IF T-mac returns to his 75%-90% of his old self, would he contend for MIP?

[Unholy Turkey]

Nope. He still averaged over 15 points per game last year. His numbers won't sky rocket or anything like that. More like 07-08 T-mac, which is still great.

[peskypesky]

My vote is for Sprewell.

[all_heart]

Manut Bol!!

[eisfeld]

T-Mac's health is an issue. With Yao out and him being in a contract year (assuming he does not get injured again) he will be valuable for the Rockets. He should be fine carrying his team this season and I'm quite sure he will have some very impressive games.

Iversons problem is his attitude. He will not find a team where he can start and be the star (because he does not want to be on a losing team) and he does not want to come off the bench. He would be a perfect fit for a borderline contending team in a Jason Terry type of role. If he is willing to accept it - he gets the edge over T-Mac, but I doubt he does.