Rodney Stuckey vs Aaron Brooks

[Tacker]

Whos better?

Discuss.....

[noob cake]

I'll take Stuckey; I hate Brooks

Lowry 4 Life

[djohn2oo8]

I'll take Stuckey; I hate Brooks

Lowry 4 Life

:lol Nice joke

[Venti Quattro]

Aaron Brooks because he always torches the Lakers.

[noob cake]

Aaron Brooks because he always torches the Lakers.

You guys needs to get off his dick; I can find a point guard in the DLeague who can torch Fisher.

[djohn2oo8]

You guys needs to get off his dick; I can find a point guard in the DLeague who can torch Fisher.

So Brooks with 23 points and 10 assists, makes you choose Stuckey?

[Venti Quattro]

You guys needs to get off his dick; I can find a point guard in the DLeague who can torch Fisher.

THE LAKERS, not only Fisher

[sook]

I'll take Stuckey; I hate Brooks

Lowry 4 Life
AB was ridiculous tonight and the philly game...I lost count of how many ankles he broke! It was like 3 or 4 :toast

[sook]

So Brooks with 23 points and 10 assists, makes you choose Stuckey?

You asked me this last year, i would have said stuck hands down. As of now brooks is better, but Stuckey is 6'5" and has a lot more potential.

[JamStone]

Probably close, but I think Brooks is the better player now. Obviously as a Pistons fan, I'm hoping Stuckey keeps developing and becomes better. Interesting question on the cusp of Stuckey being named Eastern Conference player of the week. But, Brooks is still the better player now. Stuckey has no consistency or range with his jumper. I think he lacks good mechanics and form on it. Plus, he tends to force things a lot at times. He's been getting better as a play-maker but still not good enough if he and the Pistons plan for him to ultimately be a point guard.

Brooks better now. I'm hoping Stuckey in a season or two, it will be Stuckey. Stuckey has a higher ceiling because he's already got developing skills if he can just put it all together, plus his size and strength at the PG position will give him quite an advantage. He doesn't have speed anywhere close to Brooks, but it's sufficient even for the PG position.

[noob cake]

So Brooks with 23 points and 10 assists, makes you choose Stuckey?

Next game, he'll go 2-9 just like Ariza, but at least Ariza knows that he sucks at jacking shots.

Lowry 4 Life

[Lars]

Brooks has ridiculous speed and can be very crafty offensively, tons of ankle breakers.

I havent really seen Stuckey much so can't really make the call.

[djohn2oo8]

Next game, he'll go 2-9 just like Ariza, but at least Ariza knows that he sucks at jacking shots.

Lowry 4 Life

This is his first full season starting, so you might wanna give him some time to develop his game more and become more consistent

[Indazone]

Brooks was ridiculous tonight. Stucky meh!

[Culburn369]

Brooks. He has struck.

Stucky is a ham & egger. Nothing more.

[Many PackYao]

I'll take Brooks over Stookie brothers any day of the week for right now. I love his cat like quickness and ability to create his own shot. Rodney is a better point guard and Brooks is the better shooter. Their strengths and weaknesses are opposites. When they improve and reach their ceilings, it will come down Brooks' speed vs Stuckey's size.

[sook]

I'm as big a brooks fan as they come...got my own bobble head tonight but I'd have to think real hard about tradning him for stuckey. 6'5" for a pg is freaking ridiculous and he has show flashes of brilliance.

[sook]

Next game, he'll go 2-9 just like Ariza, but at least Ariza knows that he sucks at jacking shots.

Lowry 4 Life

Sounds like those Yao fans that spewed their brooks hate last season b.c Yao couldn't catch a lot of the passes :lol

I remember reading posts hoping he would break his leg, get traded, how he was the worst pg in the league, how trading Rafer meant our season was over...

I though you cockroaches crawled back? :greedy

[The Franchise]

Brooks without a second thought. Stuckey has had just as much (if not more) time to develop, and has done a lot less of it. I have seen Aaron's game mature a lot from just the start of the season till now.

[KSeal]

Next game, he'll go 2-9 just like Ariza, but at least Ariza knows that he sucks at jacking shots.

Lowry 4 Life

Just for fun, Artest, 3-14 tonight. Bricked every wide open three he got which was like six of them.

[DaDakota]

With the rules against hand checking, give me speed any day of the week.

Aaron Brooks is the next big thing....or little thing....

DD

[djohn2oo8]

Give me Brooks....Damn Joey Crawford

H08QlVTud24

[Allanon]

Brooks and I don't think it's close.

Brooks looks like he has potential star power and looks like a game changer ala Tyreke Evans, Brandon Jennings.

Stuckey looks like a role player with occasional star type games.

[JamStone]

Brooks reminds me of a better scoring version of Darrell Armstrong. Stuckey is like a point guard version of Corey Maggette, in that he uses his size, strength, and athleticism to get things done with limited use of skill and finesse. I'd like to see Stuckey improve his skill level and basketball IQ so he can play more like Wade, not that he's anywhere as good, just more like that by using skill and IQ as well as his size and strength.

[noob cake]

Brooks and I don't think it's close.

Brooks looks like he has potential star power and looks like a game changer ala Tyreke Evans, Brandon Jennings.

Stuckey looks like a role player with occasional star type games.

:lol:lol:lol

Don't mention Brooks in the same sentence as BJ and Evans.
ha ha

Lowry 4 Life

[djohn2oo8]

:lol:lol:lol

Don't mention Brooks in the same sentence as BJ and Evans.
ha ha

Lowry 4 Life

No Homo?

[ynh]

If I can play Stuckey at the sg instead of pg then I would take him. If I have to play both at point.. I don't know. Both are 3rd maybe 2nd option talent.