Super Bowl QBs...Biggest Disparity?

[Duff McCartney]

What would you guys say is the biggest disparity between starting SB QBs? My cousin and I have been debating this and his contention has been Kerry Collins-Trent Dilfer. Arguement is not career wise, but how good they were that year.

I think mine would go to Super Bowl XXIX between Steve Young and Stan Humphries. Young had 35TDs and 10INTS, Humphries had 17TDs and 12 INTS.

Just to post them Collins had 22 TDs and 11 INTs and Dilfer had 12 TDs and 11 INTs.

I still think Young and Humphries is the biggest dispairty between starting SB Qbs.

[vander]

who was that bears QB? was it Grossman or Orton? either one = /thread

[ShoogarBear]

Yeah, Grossman vs. Manning was up there.

Of course, people said that Doug Williams vs. Elway was a mismatch.

[FromWayDowntown]

Kelly v. Hostetler in XXV looked to be a pretty substantial mismatch.

Bradshaw v. Ferragamo in XIV?

Theismann v. Woodley in XVII?

[monosylab1k]

http://thenastyboys.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/rex-grossman-stinks.jpg

Of course, Peyton isn't so awesome that the disparity is all that huge.

[picc84]

Grossman - Manning

Hence, Peytons one superbowl ring.