PDA

View Full Version : Michigan Not In Compliance



symple19
02-24-2010, 11:15 AM
from ESPN


ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- The NCAA is accusing Michigan Wolverines of five potentially major rules violations under coach Rich Rodriguez, who admitted making "mistakes" but will be back for a third try at putting the Wolverines back into the national title hunt.

Incoming athletic director David Brandon disclosed the NCAA conclusions Tuesday, while expressing full support for his coach, who is just 8-16 in two seasons heading the nation's winningest football program.

"Rich Rodriguez is our football coach, and he will be our football coach next year," Brandon said.


In its notice of allegations -- which Michigan received Monday -- the NCAA said Rodriguez "failed to promote an atmosphere of compliance within the football program." He tracked neither what his staff was doing nor whether his players were following NCAA rules, particularly those limiting the time spent on practice and football-related activities, the report said.

It also said the athletics department failed to make sure its football program was complying with NCAA regulations. Brandon said the department "clearly made mistakes," but "there was no charge of loss of institutional control" -- an allegation that in previous cases has led to severe NCAA sanctions for other schools.

An accompanying letter from the NCAA to university President Mary Sue Coleman said Michigan "should understand that all of the alleged violations set forth in the document" are considered to be "potential major violations of NCAA legislation, unless designated as secondary."

Brandon said he wasn't sure he understood "the difference between 'major' and 'minor' and 'secondary' and 'primary.'"

"They spell it out very specifically in their own language," he said.

Another possible problem for Michigan is that it could be subject to the NCAA's "repeat violator rule" because it was sanctioned in 2003 for wrongdoing within the basketball program.

"We will make all necessary changes," Coleman said. "What we will not do is make excuses."

Michigan has 90 days to respond and will appear at an NCAA hearing on infractions in August. The school will see how its internal investigation matches up with the NCAA findings and will consider implementing self-imposed sanctions, a move that could reduce NCAA penalties.

The NCAA said last October that it was looking into the Wolverine program following a report in the Detroit Free Press citing anonymous football players that said Michigan exceeded NCAA limits regarding practices and workouts in 2008 and 2009.

Rodriguez, who signed a six-year deal worth $2.5 million per season, tearfully defended his program just five days before the season-opener, saying he and his staff have followed the rules. He suggested the complaints were an attempt to "tear up" his rebuilding effort following a 3-9 season.

On Tuesday, the coach said if the football staff misinterpreted NCAA rules, "That's on us."

"We're looking at it to see why we misinterpreted and why we made mistakes," he said.

NCAA regulations allow players to spend eight hours a week on mandatory workouts during the offseason. Players told the Free Press they spent two to three times that amount on required workouts, though the NCAA report released Tuesday said players more often exceeded the limit by two hours per week.

The players also said the amount of time they spent on football activities during the season exceeded the weekly limit of 20 hours and often exceeded the daily limit of four hours. They said football staff often watched offseason scrimmages that are supposed to be voluntary.

Near the end of last season, the school released embarrassing details of an internal audit that discovered Rodriguez's team failed to file forms tracking how much time players spent on football during his first season and the following offseason.

The audit noted "a concern" that the football program failed to file monthly forms created by the school to comply with NCAA rules by tracking how much players work out and practice.

The school report did not find issues of noncompliance -- a key issue for NCAA investigators -- but acknowledged the practice logs for football were not available to be reviewed when the audit was conducted. The forms since had been turned in on a timely basis, according to the school.

"My reading of the situation is we had a breakdown of communication," Brandon said Tuesday. "We found we were not being vigilant in the way those [time records] were being filled and managed."

The time record system that the football staff designed "was too cumbersome to manage" and is being changed.

The decision to hold the infractions hearing in August means Michigan will have a distraction just as

the Wolverines are getting set to kick off a new season in their refurbished stadium.

Brandon, who takes over as athletic director on March 8, called Tuesday "a tough day" and said the univeristy was taking "full responsibility for those events that brought us to this point."

"We will dedicate ourselves to learning from this and doing everything we can to prevent it from happening again in the future," said Brandon, the outgoing chairman and CEO of Domino's Pizza.

Rodriguez stumbled to a 3-9 season in his debut at Michigan, the team's first losing season since the late 1960s and his 4-0 Wolverines stumbled down the stretch last season, leading to speculation about his tenure in Ann Arbor.

According to his contract, Rodriguez can be fired for cause if the NCAA, the Big Ten or the school determines he has committed a major violation of NCAA rules or he has intentionally committed any other type of violation of NCAA rules.

symple19
02-24-2010, 11:16 AM
Regardless of whether anything comes of this or not, I feel safe in saying that Rich Rod has been a failure thus far.

Ohio State fans must really be enjoying themselves

Blake
02-24-2010, 11:29 AM
no doubt he's been a failure so far....

He still needs a few more years with players that he has recruited for his system before they should write him off.

symple19
02-24-2010, 11:38 AM
He still needs a few more years with players that he has recruited for his system before they should write him off.

His classes the last couple years were pretty good, but the drop-off in that program has been severe. Michigan had a lot of talent when he arrived, and although some kids defected for schools w/ pro-style offenses, there is no excusing their record the past few seasons.

I'm looking at Nebraska as a similar situation. They changed philosophies and dropped almost completely off the map until Pelini arrived and started rebuilding them into a relevant team in the Big-12. I think this may be a case where the Wolverines will have to run Rich-Rod and find a guy who fits their program better, and unfortunately for fans of the Maize and Blue that may take awhile, as well as a few more coaching changes.

I could be wrong, he may start to win once he gets his type of kids in there like you said

Marklar MM
02-26-2010, 01:33 PM
They didn't have the talent when he got to Michigan...that is a misconception.


Anyways...Michigan has been dealing with this internally. The AD placed little blame on RichRod for the practice logs, and has already fired certain people in Compliance for not doing their jobs(anti-RR people trying to get him fired).

In the end though, this is the make or break year for Rodriguez...win or your gone.

K-State Spur
02-26-2010, 04:24 PM
They didn't have the talent when he got to Michigan...that is a misconception.


Not MNC type talent - but definitely better athletes than a lot of the teams that have been beating him.

JamStone
02-26-2010, 04:46 PM
Rich Rod has definitely had a very poor start to his coaching career in Michigan.

As for what type of talent he had when he came to Michigan, there was some, but not really what he needed for his system. Plus, you're talking about young, inexperienced talent. You're talking about an offense that lost four year starters at QB (Henne) and RB (Hart), an All America, top pick Left Tackle in Jake Long, and I believe their two best WRs (I can't remember for sure at the top of my head). Then you talk about the defections, including the incumbent QB in Ryan Mallett and another very important O-lineman in Justin Boren, who shockingly left for Ohio State. No experience at QB, RB, LT and minimal experience at WR. Plus a completely new offense. Tough road to hoe for any coach in his first season even if there is young talent.

Anyway, the defense wasn't in horrible shape but not all the returning players on defense exactly fit with what Rich Rod was going to do on defense. And all the talent on offense that was returning certainly weren't all the types of players who fit playing in Rich Rod's offense.

So Michigan having talent when Rich Rod came in is quite a bit exaggerated. Lloyd Carr knew he was leaving when he did and did a half ass job in recruiting his last few years. And the recruits he did leave for Rich Rod didn't really fit what Rich Rod was looking for.

Two seasons ago was somewhat understandable. Disappointing, but understandable. What happened last year, especially when they started out something like 5-0 I think was unacceptable. You add the controversies he's had from the West Virginia buyout to these violations really doesn't help his cause. I was all for a change and for Michigan to step into the 21st century of college football. But looking back at it now, they rushed their decision on Rich Rod after Les Miles and Greg Schiano turned Michigan down. It's obvious now that Rich Rod has a lot of baggage that has been a huge negative for this new era of Michigan football.

It's sad. I'd give him this next season and if he doesn't go at the very least 7-5 (preferably at least 8-4) and the team shows some promise for the next couple seasons, then I'd be all for them getting rid of him.

symple19
02-26-2010, 10:51 PM
Nice to see some Michigan folks chiming in. Good info guys. Got no problem with Michigan and would hate to see an epic decline.