Carmelo Vs. Dirk

[#41 Shoot Em Up]

Something I was thinking about today led me to make this thread. Say you were to swap these two All Stars as Dirk is now in Denver and Carmelo in Dallas, same teams on both sides just Dirk and Carmelo switching, Which team would do better in the race for a championship???

Denver:

C. Nene
PF.Dirk
SF.Afflao
SG.Smith
PG.Billups

Dallas:
C.Haywood
PF.Marion
SF.Carmelo
SG.Butler
PG.Kidd

I know some players are out of position, but just the general question, Would Dirk do better w/ Carmelo's supporting cast? Or would Carmelo do better with Dirk's supporting cast?

[FalleNxWiZarDx]

they both would choke in the PLAYOFFS


dont matter unless they have atleast 1 or 2 superstars in there team to win

[#41 Shoot Em Up]

you would know about that.

[FalleNxWiZarDx]

you would know about that.


you more then me

[#41 Shoot Em Up]

lol. not even you believe that