Roddy B/Caron Butler for Ginobili

[Amuseddaysleeper]

yay or nay?

[Gutter92]

Mavs say yes, Spurs hang up tbh

[Amuseddaysleeper]

Mavs say yes, Spurs hang up tbh

That's what I was thinking, but some Mav fans say that'd rather keep their future center piece in Roddy.

I think Manu would give them a legit #2 option as well as another closer besides Dirk.


Just curious.

[ElNono]

Right now, Gary Neal > Roddy, tbh

[ALVAREZ6]

Spurs would never do this, wouldn't even consider it.

[Amuseddaysleeper]

Spurs would never do this, wouldn't even consider it.

Oh I know they wouldn't, I was more curious on Mav fan opinion, cuz some hate the idea of this trade.

[tdunk21]

they both suck...manu is proven winner

[Cessation]

Fail. How about Tim duncan for Shawn Marion?

[angelbelow]

Dirk for Matt Bonner?

[ALVAREZ6]

they both suck...manu is proven winner
that's quite a stretch, I'd gladly have either on my team, just not for Manu...doesn't mean they suck.

[BlackSwordsMan]

manu for dirk?

[Ghazi]

I'd do it. French Allah is great, but we're 19-4 w/o him... and Manu is simply better than Caron.

[Agloco]

Dirk for Matt Bonner?

Bonner 3-ball superior tbh

[Roddy Beaubois]

tbh manu doesn't have the killer instinct that we need. pass.

[mavsfan1000]

French Jesus not getting any respect here. lol He is what makes the trade more even.

[Annoying Mav fan]

Take this shit to the Spurs forum :cry, this is the Mavs NBA forum :cry, don't put your filth on here.

[4>0rings]

Spurs don't want Mav garbage.

[tdunk21]

tbh manu doesn't have the killer instinct that we need. pass.

yeah right dirk has it....:lmao

[jestersmash]

yeah right dirk has it....:lmao

How did you fall for such an obvious troll attempt?

[tdunk21]

Take this shit to the Spurs forum :cry, this is the Mavs NBA forum :cry, don't put your filth on here.

or else what...u r gonna complain to ur mommy?

[Annoying Mav fan]

or else what...u r gonna complain to ur mommy?

hahahaha, i trolled him, gimme some props my brother mav fans :toast

[ElNono]

http://imagemacros.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/successful-troll-is-successful.jpg

[4>0rings]

hahahaha, i trolled him, gimme some props my brother mav fans :toast
http://www.siyumhaseinfeld.com/images/chars/bania2.jpg

[ALVAREZ6]

lol i can't distinguish annoying mav fan from any other troll

[angelbelow]

Bonner 3-ball superior tbh

As valuable as Bonner is, I say we trade him for Dirk. Maybe one day it'll pay off.

[Roddy Beaubois]

dirk has it

+1

[Agloco]

tbh manu doesn't have the killer instinct that we need. pass.

lol butler does

[YoungB]

shut up Fagloco

[Tp9gospursgo]

tbh manu doesn't have the killer instinct that we need. pass.

lol

[Roddy Beaubois]

butler does

+1. Tuff Juice tbh.

[DPG21920]

+1. Tuff Juice tbh.

Damn you are butt hurt over this :lol

[Roddy Beaubois]

Damn you are butt hurt over this :lol
:lmao thats great coming from you tbh. I don't see how I've shown any sign of being butthurt about this issue. You on the other hand...

[DPG21920]

You have been posting in here, I have not. You = Butt Hurted.

[Amuseddaysleeper]

I don't see how trading for Ginobili would become a "lateral move" for the Mavs

[SpursDynasty85]

that's quite a stretch, I'd gladly have either on my team, just not for Manu...doesn't mean they suck.


compared to Manu ---- they suck.

[BUMP.]

I don't see how trading for Ginobili would become a "lateral move" for the Mavs

You still don't get it.

Just because the Mavericks don't make the move doesn't mean that they don't think it makes them better. Of course Manu>>>>>Roddy right now but Roddy is 22 and has plenty of basketball left.

What happens if we trade for Manu but then we lose in the 1st/2nd round? Then we're left with an aging Jason Kidd and no point guard for the future.

[SpursDynasty85]

You still don't get it.

Just because the Mavericks don't make the move doesn't mean that they don't think it makes them better. Of course Manu>>>>>Roddy right now but Roddy is 22 and has plenty of basketball left.

What happens if we trade for Manu but then we lose in the 1st/2nd round? Then we're left with an aging Jason Kidd and no point guard for the future.


The reason it isn't a lateral move is because Dallas/Cuban would do anythign for the 1st championship. If he had 2-3 ships in the bag, this would be a "NO" bc of Roddy's future. But because Manu's presence makes them better this year and probably next year, Cuban would do it.

[DPG21920]

lol Mav fans.

[jag]

Dajuan Wagner and Caron for Manu?

I don't know...Dajuan has too much potential, so i don't think you make that deal. You can't keep making shortsighted trades, at some point you have to consider a Mavs team without Dirk.

[RoddyBukkake]

do it cuban!

[DPG21920]

Plus Caron's multiple jab steps are hard to stop.

[4>0rings]

Spurs let you have Wilt Mahinmi, what more do you want from San Antonio.

[Roddy Beaubois]

2/10

[TE]

tbh manu doesn't have the killer instinct that we need. pass.

:lmao

[Roger Freemason Jr.]

ROFL @ Manu not having "killer instinct". This coming from a fan of a team who can't close on any piece of ass they face. The Mavericks are an awesome team, Dirk is unstoppable, but it takes more than Dirk and a pretty regular season record to win the Championship. I still firmly believe that The Mavs could have easily defeated the Heat in the finals, but they let the pressure get in their heads, and it spread like a plague, and the Heat capitalized on that.

Manu is EXACTLY what you need. But it wouldn't make sense, considering Manu only has two or three more years left.

[jestersmash]

In all seriousness, this trade would be -

1) Good for Dallas in the very short term, terrible for them in the long term, and therefore bad for them overall.

2) Terrible for San Antonio in the short term, and only possibly beneficial for them in the long run, thus terrible overall.

This would be a bad trade for both teams. Bad in terms of overall prospects. Certainly bad in terms of ruining chemistry.

I was impressed with Roddy B given what I saw from him in a handful of games last season + last playoffs, but that's it. It's not enough.

[MavDynasty]

tbh in all honesty, yes. Caron has been a jumpshooter who is not the "second option" Dallas is looking for. Manu can break down defenses as well as make clutch jumpshots, the perfect person to take pressure off Dirk. Roddy was amazing in flashes we saw last year but if the Mavs got Manu, it would probably make them favorites in the West for at least 2 years.

[100%duncan]

are you kidding me?

[DPG21920]

If Manu was on the mavs they would easily be the favorites. Easily.

[Leetonidas]

It would be an awesome trade for Dallas. They would finally get a #1 option to allow Dirk to play his natural role as second banana. Could you imagine a team featuring Nowitzki and Ginobili dominating the NBA? That'd be the first international duo to win a title at the helm. :wow

[nkdlunch]

Right now, Gary Neal > Roddy, tbh

[Amuseddaysleeper]

:wakeup

[Spur_Fanatic]

Even with Manu injured, I'd still not do it.

The French Jesus got killed by the temple jews, and Caron Butler is no Mav
(and he is terrible anyway)

[Jodelo]

yeah right dirk has it....:lmao

Yep...

[Amuseddaysleeper]

You still don't get it.

Just because the Mavericks don't make the move doesn't mean that they don't think it makes them better. Of course Manu>>>>>Roddy right now but Roddy is 22 and has plenty of basketball left.

What happens if we trade for Manu but then we lose in the 1st/2nd round? Then we're left with an aging Jason Kidd and no point guard for the future.

:rollin

[jeebus]

Right now, Gary Neal > Roddy, tbh