Peyton or Eli?..

[HarlemHeat37]

If you had to win one big game, which QB would you take?..

Both in their primes..

[Greg Oden]

Tebow

[HarlemHeat37]

He won more playoff games than Peyton, at this point in their careers, tbh:lol..

[BUMP]

tbh good question.

I'd still take Peyton though

[Spursfan092120]

tbh good question.

I'd still take Peyton though

[Greg Oden]

He won more playoff games than Peyton, at this point in their careers, tbh:lol..

Maybe he should've prayed to his lord and savior a little more.

[HarlemHeat37]

Maybe he should've prayed to his lord and savior a little more.

He won a playoff game, the prayers seemed to work..

[Greg Oden]

He won a playoff game, the prayers seemed to work..

Where was his god yesterday when he was throwing some of the worst passes a professional quarterback has ever thrown?

[ducks]

the broncos had the best wide reciever out and others were hurt
he sucked but they by far had less talent then new england

[HarlemHeat37]

Tebow has nothing to do with the OP question, tbh..

Don't know why Oden brought his name up..

[Greg Oden]

the broncos had the best wide reciever out and others were hurt
he sucked but they by far had less talent then new england

Oh. I didn't know injuries happened in football. Thanks.

[TIMMYtoZO]

I love Peyton. For years I have called him the best qb in the NFL, but that all changes when Eli gets his 2nd ring in a few weeks.

[DJ Mbenga]

Peyton never had a defense as good as Eli had

[BlackSwordsMan]

Eli Manning is on his way of winning a second ring proving he's the best manning tbh fwiwi

[Pelicans78]

Peyton never had a defense as good as Eli had

He did in 2005.

[The Gemini Method]

He did in 2005.

That was the exception to the rule--the one year that the defense somehow clicked and was ranked I think 11th in the league/2nd in scoring defense--which is probably the best indicator of how good one's defense is. Eli Manning has had a consistently good to great defense around him and the Giants have always prided themselves on having a strong D going all the way back to the Lawrence Taylor days. I think that you can make an argument over which QB is tops in the Manning family, but overall you'd have to give Peyton the edge because he is the better oreo eater.

Wow just did some research and the Giants' D wasn't statistically great in 2011--but that is attributed to the injuries they did suffer. They are missing their best cover in Terell Thomas...

[4>0rings]

This shouldn't even be an argument, Peyton.

Give Peyton the team Eli has and he would never lose a game.

[ducks]

This shouldn't even be an argument, Peyton.

Give Peyton the team Eli has and he would never lose a game.

like the packers:downspin::downspin:

[monosylab1k]

like the packers:downspin::downspin:

that's a really good point there.

[Pelicans78]

The 2005 Colts were proof that Peyton was a choker. No way that team shouldn't have won the Super Bowl. They actually had a really good defense as well. The Colts offense sputtered against the Steelers in the divisional round less. LOL Peyton blaming his offensive line when he himself couldn't figure out the Steelers blitz.

[Bill_Brasky]

Eli, tbh

[Huey Freeman]

Eli

[jgome21]

I'd have to side with Peyton. Eli may be wrecking right now, but the fact that he has a defense that can help him out, gives him a better shot at winning. The Colts have always had a questionable defense for the past decade. Peyton just bailed them out everytimg and now it's showing.

[Spurtacus]

Peyton Manning.

I'm convinced he would have more than one ring if the Colts didn't have shitty defenses the last decade.

[BUMP]

The 2005 Colts were proof that Peyton was a choker. No way that team shouldn't have won the Super Bowl.

Considering the Steelers won handily against everyone else they played in those playoffs and how good their defense was, it's hard to say the Colts choked that game.

Either way Vanderjagt deserves most of the blame tbh

[DeadlyDynasty]

bump:lol

[DeadlyDynasty]

One game away from having bragging rights over big brother--and he can get that second ring in Peyton's house too

[resistanze]

This SB is Peyton's worst nightmare - who does he root for? :lol

[DAF86]

Untill I see Eli managing all the aspects of the QB position like Peyton does/did I'm going with the bigger brother.

[Nathan89]

2-14 says Peyton has been taking scrubs to the playoffs.

[HarlemHeat37]

So, what's the answer, now?..

[lefty]

Elite !

[Josepatches_]

Peyton.

[dbreiden83080]

Career is Peyton but one game

It's Eli..

[midnightpulp]

Peyton. I don't think rings should define a player in the NFL, considering the NFL season is ostensibly the playoffs. The NFL is a league where "regular season" stats and performances actually matter.

[TIMMYtoZO]

As much as I love Peyton, Elite The Eliminator Manning is ahead of him now. Elite Manning is going to win at least 2 more superbowls in the next 3 years. This is the beginning of a NY Giants dynasty.

[dbreiden83080]

With this win Eli will go down as a legend in NY forever. He is right there with Derek Jeter now.. All time Peyton will probably have him beat but Eli has been so clutch in the big games.. He is a HOF and a legend in his own right..

[stretch]

Eli certainly has an argument for late-game clutch situations, not because Peyton is unclutch, but because Eli tends to just be amazing in the clutch.

But Peyton still > Eli for now. Eli is more naturally gifted and talented IMO, but still doesn't exhibit the consistency that Peyton shows.

[dirk4mvp]

Stretch does it hurt you to know what school Eli went to?

[stretch]

Stretch does it hurt you to know what school Eli went to?

The same one as the greatness we know as Jevan Snead went to?

[dirk4mvp]

Does it?

[stretch]

Does it?

Certainly not. I have nothing against Ole Piss.

I just like to LMAO @ Jevan Snead.

[manufan10]

As of now, I would still take Peyton, but the gap isn't as wide as it once once.

[Blake]

Stretch does it hurt you to know what school Eli went to?

Rofl Eli outgunned by insert Tech QB (and Welker)

[Blake]

Back in October, I'd have easily taken Peyton.

Not today. Eli is easily the calmer, more clutch Manning.

Peyton's happy feet make me nervous just watching him.

[Trill Clinton]

Terrific Tom

[dirk4mvp]

Rofl Eli outgunned by insert Tech QB (and Welker)

Eli: 2 sb mvps


Tech: 0

[Blake]

Rofl insert Tech QB outgunning a two-time Super Bowl MVP.