PDA

View Full Version : How much do NBA scouts and coaches really know? Lin.



Fabbs
02-11-2012, 10:31 AM
Obviously he was not completely overlooked as he got invited to 8 teams camps. Got signed by Golden, got picked up by Houston then NYK.
However espn reports he was buried on the Knicks bench and about to be waived again.

89 points in his first three career starts, the most by any player since 1976.
Not to mention assists and overall game.
Knicks should trade Marshmellow Anthony.

To the point, how much do NBA coaches and scouts really know?
Here's a guy who was about to be cut. Matt Bonner has averaged 18 minutes a game in the playoffs.

Giuseppe
02-11-2012, 10:41 AM
Frankly? I hope the fuck breaks his life.

Double-Up
02-11-2012, 10:43 AM
He was given a shot and he shined but question should be how long will it last?

Double-Up
02-11-2012, 10:43 AM
Frankly? I hope the fuck breaks his life.

You guys got curb stomped... :lol

Giuseppe
02-11-2012, 10:46 AM
You guys got curb stomped... :lol

Hold on, let me check last night's scores...please stand by.
---
Yeah, yer okay. We got "curb stompled."

Double-Up
02-11-2012, 10:49 AM
Hold on, let me check last night's scores...please stand by.
---
Yeah, yer okay. We got "curb stompled."

When an undrafted asian rookie drops 38 on your team...yea. :lol

Giuseppe
02-11-2012, 10:53 AM
When an undrafted asian rookie drops 38 on your team...yea. :lol

This is true.

Fabbs
02-11-2012, 10:58 AM
He was given a shot and he shined but question should be how long will it last?
True that he dropped his 38 on some weak assed competition.
Tired old no defense bags Kerby and DSwisher.

Still, Lin looked great, has all around game.

Giuseppe
02-11-2012, 11:10 AM
Tired old bags

I'm a trend setter.

I set trends.

Trainwreck2100
02-11-2012, 11:11 AM
He plays in a system that got quinten Richardson and Boris diaw crazy contracts. Anyone remember when the latter was supposed to be the "center of the future?"

Indazone
02-11-2012, 11:19 AM
Laughing at the meltdown at Clutchfans about how Morey was a dumbass for putting Lin on Waivers. :lol

JamStone
02-11-2012, 11:30 AM
To the point, how much do NBA coaches and scouts really know?

Still way more than most. I think Lin is an interesting case of a player who might be a borderline NBA player talent-wise, but when he got his opportunity, he found himself in a perfect situation, in the right system, and has so far made the absolute most of it and has played out of his mind. This is probably the best he's shot the ball in his life, or up there at least. He's in an offensive system that really caters to his strengths. And the injury to Carmelo and the absence of Amare are two things that probably helped him shine immensely where he's been forced to be aggressive in looking to score. Just a really great situation for him to take advantage of, and he has taken full advantage of it.

And as for NBA scouts and GMs, the job of predicting how a player will translate to the NBA and how he will improve and develop certainly isn't a perfect science. There are intangibles Lin has shown that you can't measure. You can't always see or predict work ethic, desire to win, basketball IQ, not always anyway. Same thing happened with Ben Wallace, but it took the right situation and a real opportunity for him to find his niche in the NBA. Probably can say the same thing about Bruce Bowen or guys like Wes Matthews and Reggie Williams.

Just goes to show you, when you do get that one chance, that one opportunity, make the most of it.

Double-Up
02-11-2012, 12:00 PM
Most NBA coaches have IQs in the 80 range. If one of them has an IQ of say, 120, like Phil Jackson, they are referred to as a, "genius".

Kill Bill Pana strikes again. :lol

DMC
02-11-2012, 12:09 PM
A person might have a crazy game one night against a scrub team, but it's not a fluke when a guy has that kind of success for more than one or two games. He's got a good BB IQ for a rookie, and he's fearless. He's got skills and knows how to attack the defense.

I would keep riding him until he proved otherwise, but I think he's the real deal.

DPG21920
02-11-2012, 12:12 PM
They get a lot more right than we as fans do. For every Lin they miss which is pretty rare, there are multiple James white's, Gerald Green's, Spanoulis's that fans like and aren't NBA players.

DMC
02-11-2012, 12:14 PM
He plays in a system that got quinten Richardson and Boris diaw crazy contracts. Anyone remember when the latter was supposed to be the "center of the future?"

That's a double edged sword.

Either of those guys could have been productive on other teams. It's as much the fault of their respective teams' management as anything.

If a player can shine under a different system, he's a good player. It's not the player's fault that the new coaching system doesn't incorporate his strengths. That's for the coaches to figure out.

JamStone
02-11-2012, 12:23 PM
Or triple edged sword?

Most NBA head coaches have a system and have used it pretty much their entire coaching career, which has helped them get to where they are now. It's the GM's job to acquire players that will excel in that system. It's much harder to change a whole coaching philosophy over one player than to acquire another player that fits better. When you're talking about players that are specialists or are system players, and not players that are the type of talent that will succeed in any system, I think it's more on the GM than the coach and coaching system to find those players that fit.

DMC
02-11-2012, 12:29 PM
Or triple edged sword?

Most NBA head coaches have a system and have used it pretty much their entire coaching career, which has helped them get to where they are now. It's the GM's job to acquire players that will excel in that system. It's much harder to change a whole coaching philosophy over one player than to acquire another player that fits better. When you're talking about players that are specialists or are system players, and not players that are the type of talent that will succeed in any system, I think it's more on the GM than the coach and coaching system to find those players that fit.

It could even be a mace.

That's why I said team management. A player doesn't acquire himself.

jag
02-11-2012, 12:29 PM
Still way more than most. I think Lin is an interesting case of a player who might be a borderline NBA player talent-wise, but when he got his opportunity, he found himself in a perfect situation, in the right system, and has so far made the absolute most of it and has played out of his mind. This is probably the best he's shot the ball in his life, or up there at least. He's in an offensive system that really caters to his strengths. And the injury to Carmelo and the absence of Amare are two things that probably helped him shine immensely where he's been forced to be aggressive in looking to score. Just a really great situation for him to take advantage of, and he has taken full advantage of it.

And as for NBA scouts and GMs, the job of predicting how a player will translate to the NBA and how he will improve and develop certainly isn't a perfect science. There are intangibles Lin has shown that you can't measure. You can't always see or predict work ethic, desire to win, basketball IQ, not always anyway. Same thing happened with Ben Wallace, but it took the right situation and a real opportunity for him to find his niche in the NBA. Probably can say the same thing about Bruce Bowen or guys like Wes Matthews and Reggie Williams.

Just goes to show you, when you do get that one chance, that one opportunity, make the most of it.

Good post

Leetonidas
02-11-2012, 12:31 PM
Most NBA coaches have IQs in the 80 range. If one of them has an IQ of say, 120, like Phil Jackson, they are referred to as a, "genius".

:lol Tiago Splitter shitting all over you
:lol dirty goat fucking country
:lol no money
:lol Greek basketball team is fucking awful
:lol living in Greece

Sportcamper
02-11-2012, 12:39 PM
JamStone-Just goes to show you, when you do get that one chance, that one opportunity, make the most of it...

Great Post :tu...Wally Pipp could not have said it better...

Hemotivo
02-11-2012, 01:33 PM
brandon jennings + jjBarea = Lin

pass1st
02-11-2012, 01:43 PM
:lol Tiago Splitter shitting all over you
:lol dirty goat fucking country
:lol no money
:lol Greek basketball team is fucking awful
:lol living in Greece

Lol, lives in Arkansas tbh

Proxy
02-11-2012, 02:01 PM
brandon jennings + jjBarea = Lin
:keda

ChumpDumper
02-11-2012, 03:02 PM
Most NBA coaches have IQs in the 80 range. If one of them has an IQ of say, 120, like Phil Jackson, they are referred to as a, "genius".Where is the list of NBA coach IQs?

Link?

pass1st
02-11-2012, 03:08 PM
Where is the list of NBA coach IQs?

Link?

He's just making shit up again so he can formulate a rebuttal that Euroleague coaches are better than NBA coaches. We only know Potato Head's IQ

BUMP
02-11-2012, 03:30 PM
Still way more than most. I think Lin is an interesting case of a player who might be a borderline NBA player talent-wise, but when he got his opportunity, he found himself in a perfect situation, in the right system, and has so far made the absolute most of it and has played out of his mind. This is probably the best he's shot the ball in his life, or up there at least. He's in an offensive system that really caters to his strengths. And the injury to Carmelo and the absence of Amare are two things that probably helped him shine immensely where he's been forced to be aggressive in looking to score. Just a really great situation for him to take advantage of, and he has taken full advantage of it.

And as for NBA scouts and GMs, the job of predicting how a player will translate to the NBA and how he will improve and develop certainly isn't a perfect science. There are intangibles Lin has shown that you can't measure. You can't always see or predict work ethic, desire to win, basketball IQ, not always anyway. Same thing happened with Ben Wallace, but it took the right situation and a real opportunity for him to find his niche in the NBA. Probably can say the same thing about Bruce Bowen or guys like Wes Matthews and Reggie Williams.

Just goes to show you, when you do get that one chance, that one opportunity, make the most of it.

I think the problem is that most NBA gm's try and strike gold with every single pick even though it isn't always logical. Trying to find the next Kobe Bryant/LeBron is reasonable when you have a lottery pick but after that I think you should go with proven college commodities even if they don't have prototypical size and try and get them to be productive bench players. Then we'd be able to see more guys like Lin.

For example, I thought Lacedarius Dunn from Baylor had a great all around game in college becoming the Big 12's all time leading scorer. I thought he had the chance to be a solid offense off the bench type of player in the NBA. The problem is that GM's would rather look at Mambo Jambo from Senegal because he's much more athletic and can dunk 3 coconuts at once so he technically has the "potential" to be great. But then they send him over to some random country for 5 years and realize he just sucks resulting in a wasted pick.

mavs>spurs
02-11-2012, 03:35 PM
Baylor is jinxed scro, that's why. My friend transerred there after a solid freshman season elsewhere and injured himself for good.

midnightpulp
02-11-2012, 04:09 PM
I think the problem is that most NBA gm's try and strike gold with every single pick even though it isn't always logical. Trying to find the next Kobe Bryant/LeBron is reasonable when you have a lottery pick but after that I think you should go with proven college commodities even if they don't have prototypical size and try and get them to be productive bench players. Then we'd be able to see more guys like Lin.

For example, I thought Lacedarius Dunn from Baylor had a great all around game in college becoming the Big 12's all time leading scorer. I thought he had the chance to be a solid offense off the bench type of player in the NBA. The problem is that GM's would rather look at Mambo Jambo from Senegal because he's much more athletic and can dunk 3 coconuts at once so he technically has the "potential" to be great. But then they send him over to some random country for 5 years and realize he just sucks resulting in a wasted pick.

:lmao

Koolaid_Man
02-11-2012, 06:31 PM
:lmao


fuck Linderalla..we don't want more like him...it's a niggra's league...we want that negro swagga

85Bl3GRdULQ

Trainwreck2100
02-11-2012, 06:47 PM
It could even be a mace.

That's why I said team management. A player doesn't acquire himself.

not a mace but a trebuchet the owners players and coaches and management to to shoot far t get the right players/system/coaches/mascot