Switch Dirk Nowitzki and Tim Duncan... Which team would be more successful?

[JohnnyMax]

What do you think about this statement: "I'll take '11 playoffs Dirk over any version of Duncan."

[scanry]

What do you think about this statement: "I'll take '11 playoffs Dirk over any version of Duncan."

2003 Duncan shits on any player since Shaq 2002 tbh. Not only do the mavs win more than 1 championship, they'd also not have to depend on Big Daddy Tyson.

[Johnsyounger]

2003 Duncan shits on any player since Shaq 2002 tbh. Not only do the mavs win more than 1 championship, they'd also not have to depend on Big Daddy Tyson.
You said it. 03 Duncan could caca all over Dirk anytime. And while 02 Shaq was great, Lakersref was in full effect. Kings were robbed, and that is not debatable.

[weebo]

who cares about '11 dirk and the mavs...they've been shit since then

[Arnold Toht]

Put it this way: replace Duncan with Nowitzki in the final minute of game 7 last year, do you guys end up with 5? I think so. I doubt Nowitzki would miss a fuckin' layup over Battier.

[Brazil]

Put it this way: replace Duncan with Nowitzki in the final minute of game 7 last year, do you guys end up with 5? I think so. I doubt Nowitzki would miss a fuckin' layup over Battier.

sure... he would have shot a Jumper

[313]

They would both have two, maybe three rings.

The difference would be the Mavs front office and the Spurs front office.

[Thread]

Put it this way: replace Duncan with Nowitzki in the final minute of game 7 last year, do you guys end up with 5? I think so. I doubt Nowitzki would miss a fuckin' layup over Battier.

Arn, taking the knife, sticking it up under those ribs & twisting it.

Arn

[Arnold Toht]

sure... he would have shot a Jumper

Did you forget about a certain play during the midst of the previous decade? The one that cost you 5-5 and a threepeat?

[Rogue]

who cares about '11 dirk and the mavs...they've been shit since then
no other team outside of the Heat has won the championship since then, spurs could've made a difference last year and they were very close to making it, but we all know what the hell happened in the last 28 seconds of game 6.

[Arnold Toht]

but we all know what the hell happened in the last 28 seconds of game 6.

I came.

[Brazil]

Did you forget about a certain play during the midst of the previous decade? The one that cost you 5-5 and a threepeat?

I did not forget anything, your dirk would have made the lay up is dumb tho

[Venti Quattro]

Dirk's Spurs


I did not forget anything, your dirk would have made the lay up is dumb tho

He made a layup over an outstretched Ginobili in a Game 7. What makes you think that Dirk Diggler's gonna blow a wide-open layup in a Game 7?

[Brazil]

Dirk's Spurs



He made a layup over an outstretched Ginobili in a Game 7. What makes you think that Dirk Diggler's gonna blow a wide-open layup in a Game 7?

nothing... comparaison is dumb... 90% of the big of the league would have made dat lay up... just a hand of bigs in the league could have the Duncan POs run last year... none could have done that at 38 y/o

dude talking shit about Duncan for last year PO or for a missed lay up worth less than a bag of shit

last yeat POs just reinforced Duncan legacy... at the end of the day as much as I like Dirk, Duncan shit on him at his peak and carreer wise twice a day 7 days a week

[irishock]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4oVlERfiOc
:lmao at Duncan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8T4ZUK-NFKc

[Mel_13]

If we're talking about switching them for their entire careers, then the combination of Duncan as a foundational piece and Cuban's money in the pre-2011 CBA NBA would have been pretty awesome. Cuban spared no expense trying to surround Dirk with the right group of players to win a title. Say whatever you want about the relative greatness of the two players, Duncan was the easier player to build around.

[DMC]

Define "successful"

[Venti Quattro]

Define "successful"

Rings and FMVPs

[superjames1992]

Did you forget about a certain play during the midst of the previous decade? The one that cost you 5-5 and a threepeat?
:cry

http://worldonline.media.clients.ellingtoncms.com/img/photos/2006/05/23/MAVERICKS_SPURS__bw_t440.jpg?9e2a24ba44807f8f9b96a ad7c4082bf6ded075dc

[horsielove]

Rings and FMVPs

Duncan's 7 > Kobe's 6

[Thread]

Duncan's 7 > Kobe's 6

Boiled down:::

Kobe: 5

the tired old shit bag Duncan: 4

[Clipper Nation]

Kobe: 5
Those are Daddy & MVPau's ringsPERIOD

[Thread]

Those are MVPau's ringsPERIOD

Though Pau can't win a single playoff game without Kobe holding his hand. You kept that intact last year about this time.

tee, hee.

[Clipper Nation]

Though Pau can't win a single playoff game without Kobe holding his hand. You kept that intact last year about this time.

tee, hee.
Kirby - MVPau = Duncan having the shiniest shoes in the nation

tee, hee.

[Thread]

Kirby - MVPau = Duncan having the shiniest shoes in the nation

tee, hee.

I'm a trend setter.

I set trends.

[Venti Quattro]

Duncan's 7 > Kobe's 6
This debate is between Nowitzki and Duncan and somehow this Spurs fan takes it as a cue to include Kobe in the picture

[SupremeGuy]

These threads are so predictable and boring, tbh. It usually starts off as a decent conversation, but then the trolls come in and start jacking each other off or continue parroting the same broken lines. Yawn. Back in my day, trolling meant something. I feel like you guys are just going through the motions. I get it, most of the trolls' teams are complete shit(or don't even exist anymore lol sonics) and have been for a few years so they don't have anything good to talk about it, but they should at least put more effort into trolling Spursfan.

[Mel_13]

This debate is between Nowitzki and Duncan and somehow this Spurs fan takes it as a cue to include Kobe in the picture

horsielove?

19 posts?

More likely a Mavfan troll.

[Thread]

These threads are so predictable and boring, tbh. It usually starts off as a decent conversation, but then the trolls come in and start jacking each other off or continue parroting the same broken lines. Yawn. Back in my day, trolling meant something. I feel like you guys are just going through the motions. I get it, most of the trolls' teams are complete shit(or don't even exist anymore lol sonics) and have been for a few years so they don't have anything good to talk about it, but they should at least put more effort into trolling Spursfan.

Once you took on water/6 you were fucked.

& we all knew it.

[SupremeGuy]

Once you took on water/6 you were fucked.

& we all knew it.Sure thing. :toast

[scanry]

This debate is between Nowitzki and Duncan and somehow this Spurs fan takes it as a cue to include Kobe in the picture

Son why do you anything less? America lives on kobe, not on Dunkin Donuts.

[Juggity]

What do you think about this statement: "I'll take '11 playoffs Dirk over any version of Duncan."

Is there anybody in the world who would allege that beyond Mark Cuban? Duncan put up a quad-dub in the finals vs. Mutombo / prime KMart. He carried the fourth quarter game 7 of the 2005 series against the Pistons. Dethroned the threepeat lakers. Shut down the forum.

Dirk's had some good playoff runs, but only 1 legendary run. Duncan's had 3-4.

[Splits]

Put it this way: replace Duncan with Nowitzki in the final minute of game 7 last year, do you guys end up with 5? I think so. I doubt Nowitzki would miss a fuckin' layup over Battier.

Hey Zabuza Momochi former member of Kirigakure's Seven Swordsmen of the Mist, put it this way faggot, Nowitzki instead of Duncan last year and there is no game 7 because the Spurs wouldn't have been in the finals.

[The_Coyote]

This is like asking, "what would've happened had the Axis Powers won WWII?"

And I would answer both exactly the same way: "The world would be a much shittier place to live in."

[Horse]

Is this serious we're talking about an all-time great vs. a one way, no defendning. 7 ft non rebounding dipshit.

[Thread]

Is this serious we're talking about an all-time great

Who couldn't make not just 1, but, couldn't make 2 layups over a shrimp because his wife outed his gay ass & left him in the lurch.

HA!

[TDMVPDPOY]

remember the year dirk was out injured in the playoffs? i think it was against the spurs...damn did they miss him, i think they wouldve move on if he wasnt injured

[daslicer]

Duncan would have won somewhere around 4-5 titles with the Mavs. Cuban with his unlimited spending and payroll pre-2011 would surround Duncan with tons of talent.

[Thread]

Duncan would have won somewhere around 4-5 titles with the Mavs. Cuban with his unlimited spending and payroll pre-2011 would surround Duncan with tons of talent.

No. Cuban was too busy conspiring door-to-door his entire NBA life against the Lakers to attend his rank & file. That he won one is a testament to the human spirit. That he refused to defend it is borderline criminal.

[Clipper Nation]

No. Cuban was too busy conspiring door-to-door his entire NBA life against the Lakers to attend his rank & file. That he won one is a testament to the human spirit. That he refused to defend it is borderline criminal.
& he has full ownership over your cookie.

ha, ha.

[Brunodf]

At least 8 championships for Timmy D tbh. Don Nelson would be overrated and considered a HOF coach...

[hater]

the Mavs would still be 0 and forever because Duncan would have never played for Cuban

[chief keef]

26/10 in the playoffs, fuck boi.

[Arnold Toht]

Hey Zabuza Momochi former member of Kirigakure's Seven Swordsmen of the Mist, put it this way faggot, Nowitzki instead of Duncan last year and there is no game 7 because the Spurs wouldn't have been in the finals.

Us without Bryant, the Warriors and the Grizzlies. That's a tough ass road to the finals, blanket head.

Too bad your Timmy fell flat on his fucking ass on his road to #5 last year.

[Ghazi]

2011 playoff Dirk has become vastly overrated by many people.

He was great, but over Duncan? wtf.

[The Batman]

Duncan's team, because he plays defense. However, it is Pop's system that have kept the Spurs winning so long, so Dirk would have alot of success too if you switched them.

[scanry]

2011 playoff Dirk has become vastly overrated by many people.

He was great, but over Duncan? wtf.

The Diggler went ape shit against them Lakers and Thunder. Dude single handedly brought the Mavs back in Game 2 in the finals. Dude had one of the all time great post season run. So no, he ain't overrated.

[scanry]

I think his 2011 run also changed his demeanor in the NBA. Dude went from a choke artist to an all time great.

[Rogue]

http://www.spurstalk.com/forums/images/misc/quote_icon.png Originally Posted by Ghazi (http://www.spurstalk.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7228119#post7228119)2011 playoff Dirk has become vastly overrated by many people.

He was great, but over Duncan? wtf.



The Diggler went ape shit against them Lakers and Thunder. Dude single handedly brought the Mavs back in Game 2 in the finals. Dude had one of the all time great post season run. So no, he ain't overrated.

mav fan calling dirk overrated and rebutted by a spurs fan... O ye of little faith :lmao

[dirk4mvp]

Duncan would've had to deal with Nash getting shit on by Bibby, Jet getting shit on by Nash, Smokey having a mental crisis in the middle of a playoff series, Avery starting Dickbreath at C, etc. lol spurfans acting like Cuban's deep pockets would've somehow made the players that money paid for something they weren't. Parker & Manure >>>>>> JET & one year of Big Daddy Tyson. Hell Duncan's gay introverted ass might have even bolted the big city of Dallas to go somewhere smaller so he could play his basement card games in peace like Orlando :lol

[Sybok]

Duncan would've had to deal with Nash getting shit on by Bibby, Jet getting shit on by Nash, Smokey having a mental crisis in the middle of a playoff series, Avery starting Dickbreath at C, etc. lol spurfans acting like Cuban's deep pockets would've somehow made the players that money paid for something they weren't. Parker & Manure >>>>>> JET & one year of Big Daddy Tyson. Hell Duncan's gay introverted ass might have even bolted the big city of Dallas to go somewhere smaller so he could play his basement card games in peace like Orlando :lol

But we'll never know. All we'll ever know is 4>1 tbh.

[dirk4mvp]

4 rings, faggot!

[Thread]

4 rings, faggot!

Hey, fartface!

[dirk4mvp]

You've no room. Your Kobe catches dicks in his face.

[Jodelo]

You've no room. Your Kobe catches dicks in his face.

http://stream1.gifsoup.com/webroot/animatedgifs/589434_o.gif