Rank these players..

[Malik Hairston]

One list based on peak, another list based on overall career:

- Kevin Garnett
- Dirk Nowitzki
- Charles Barkley
- Karl Malone
- David Robinson
- Patrick Ewing

[m>s]

Dirk
Garnett
Ewing
Robinson
Malone
Barkely

don't care about peak and op you're a fag

[resistanze]

Peak
-Robinson
-Barkley
-Garnett
-Dirk
-Malone
-Ewing

Career
-Dirk
-Robinson
-Garnett
-Barkley
-Malone
-Ewing

[m>s]

Peak
-Robinson
-Barkley
-Garnett
-Dirk
-Malone
-Ewing

Career
-Dirk
-Robinson
-Garnett
-Barkley
-Malone
-Ewing
you have robinson and barkely too high, as a #1 those two never won shit. people joke on here and call dwight "bible kemp" but robinson if anyone was the real bible kemp and the original

[resistanze]

you have robinson and barkely too high, as a #1 those two never won shit. people joke on here and call dwight "bible kemp" but robinson if anyone was the real bible kemp and the original

I ranked both peak years and career tbh

I don't see how you have Ewing 3rd

[m>s]

to piss off spur fan

but seriously robinson is a shit one way player (in b4 lol dirk, no dirk was actually very competent and above average on defense later in his career) and should only be ranked ahead of elbows malone and fatso barkely and monkey nose ewing

[AlexJones]

to piss off spur fan

but seriously robinson is a shit one way player (in b4 lol dirk, no dirk was actually very competent and above average on defense later in his career) and should only be ranked ahead of elbows malone and fatso barkely and monkey nose ewing

Only 10 minutes before gookhead storms in to defend his beloved Robinson.

[m>s]

Bring him on, I'll pop a Viagra and get to work

[spurraider21]

but seriously robinson is a shit one way player
just to be clear, which "one"... the nba's leading scorer one or the DPOY one?

[m>s]

Shawn Marion also had some 20ppg seasons. Robinson was the clean up garbage man on offense.

show me where he took over games offensively and willed his team to victory, what were the go to moves in his repertoire?

pro tip: you can't

[spurraider21]

oh ok :lol

he must have been doing a lot of cleaning up those first 7 seasons

[m>s]

Well just post the proof, we need citations

[m>s]

i just went to youtube and typed in robinson highlights, the first video that popped up:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIkTMOwJsto

literally every play is a dunk off of a pick and roll with a feed from a teammate or a put back dunk. dude was really good defensively, but he's a 7ft shawn marion.

[spurraider21]

you're surprised that a highlight video of an athletic player consists of dunks? how retarded are you?

[m>s]

Well post real life citations and examples of the offense running though Robinson and him willing his team to victory bucket after bucket. What were the go to moves he used? Prove me wrong.

But you can't.

david Robinson is not a tim Duncan, David Robinson needs a tim Duncan.

[spurraider21]

David Robinson was never NOT the leading scorer of his team until Duncan came along. And it's not like he was playing with a Steve Nash that was running the offense. It was with Avery Johnson and Vinny Del Negro, point guards whose ball-handling skills were so terrible that they had to back their guys down just to bring the ball beyond half-court.

[313]

Well just post the proof, we need citationstakeover
z-NRWNX7Z7Y

>one way player
>quadruple double
Forty keks
KkpT0QdUDIY

2/10 for making me respond

[m>s]

What championship game was that? I only remember him winning a ring in 99 and 03

David Robinson was never a take over and create your own offense type player. He won rings when Duncan came along.

[spurraider21]

http://www.johnlocke.org/site-docs/lockerroom/movinggoalpost.gif

[100%duncan]

What championship game was that? I only remember him winning a ring in 99 and 03

David Robinson was never a take over and create your own offense type player. He won rings when Duncan came along.

You are backtracking son. I don't know why you need to shit on David tbh, it's not like he has anything to do with the people's opinion on your beloved Dirk. Main point is you can't call a man who lead his team in points before timmy came a long a 1-way player.

[dirk4mvp]

Dirk is the correct answer to both tbh

[CitizenDwayne]

Obviously C-Webb is superior to them all.

[Sportstudi]

One list based on peak, another list based on overall career:

- Kevin Garnett
- Dirk Nowitzki
- Charles Barkley
- Karl Malone
- David Robinson
- Patrick Ewing

is this now realgm?

[ambchang]

Obvious troll bait is obvious.

[djohn2oo8]

Didn't the Spurs have a couple 60 win seasons with Robinson and his role players?

[RsxPiimp]

One list based on peak, another list based on overall career:

- Kevin Garnett
- Dirk Nowitzki
- Charles Barkley
- Karl Malone
- David Robinson
- Patrick Ewing

Peak

Robinson
Ewing
Barkley
Dirk
Garnett
Malone

Without looking at stats, I'd put Robinson 1st overall. He was a beast. Funny as it may sound I was actually more of a Spurs fan than a Lakers fan during my first 2 years watching basketball and Robinson was one of the reasons why. :lol, real talk. I was maybe 13 or 14 though and wouldn't really pay much attention to all the little things, but looking back now, and I've seen plenty of Ewing too, I'd still pick him over Pat.

I'd take Dirk over any of the following guys (Barkley, Malone and KG) but Barkley's peak was insane though. If he wasn't such a one way player and had better work ethic, he'd probably be the best of the bunch, we've seen that in 92. It's a toss up between Malone and KG but Malone for all his lapses in the Finals (KG didn't fare well either as a 1st option) is a better player for me.