Luck vs. Wilson vs. Newton

[N0 LyF3 ScRuB]

http://cdn.fansided.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/136/files/2015/01/Cam_Luck_Wilson-stats.jpg

I really don't understand all the hype around Andrew Luck.

[Pelicans78]

Luck is good, but he is overhyped. Big time.

[spurraider21]

Luck > Wilson > Newton and it isn't really a difficult evaluation

[N0 LyF3 ScRuB]

Luck > Wilson > Newton and it isn't really a difficult evaluation

Nope

[cantthinkofanything]

Luck > Wilson > Newton and it isn't really a difficult evaluation

http://omu.kuiki.net/class/valuescale.jpg

[SanAntonioSpurs23]

Luck shits on both qbs.

[N0 LyF3 ScRuB]

Luck shits on both qbs.
He doesn't. He takes advantage of a soft schedule with soft division rivals.

[Silver&Black]

He doesn't. He takes advantage of a soft schedule with soft division rivals.

Are you honestly gonna sit there and talk shit about another division. When you (and I for that matter) play in the worst division I've ever seen in my lifetime. Seriously bro?

:lmao NFC South
:lmao Worst Divison Ever

[N0 LyF3 ScRuB]

Are you honestly gonna sit there and talk shit about another division. When you (and I for that matter) play in the worst division I've ever seen in my lifetime. Seriously bro?

:lmao NFC South
:lmao Worst Divison Ever

That literally has nothing to do with my post. The Colts have a far superior team than their division and the NFC South is far more competitive on a yearly basis than his division. That, and the fact that the NFC South has always been one of the toughest divisions and most competitive But you left that gem out of your post.

[Avante]

RW has more wins, beaten more good teams, superior comp%/td/int ratio/passer rating/QBR than those two. And two SB appearances.

[chunticakes]

RW has more wins, beaten more good teams, superior comp%/td/int ratio/passer rating/QBR than those two. And two SB appearances.

And more Super Bowl losing interceptions.

[Avante]

And more Super Bowl losing interceptions.

Then there's...

Russell Wilson has won more Superbpwls than....

Andrew Luck
Cam Newton
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
Archie Manning
RGIII
Johnny Unitas
Dan Marino
Dandy Don Meredith
Jim Kelly
Randall Cunningham
Donovan McNabb
Dan Fouts
Fran Tarkenton
Sonny Jurgenson
Daryl Lamonica
Lynn Dickey
Bert Jones
John Brodie
Colin Kaepernick
Drew Bledsoe
Mark Brunell
Vinny Testerverde
Warren Moon

COMBINED!!!!!!!!!!

It took him all of two seasons, hahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Silver&Black]

That, and the fact that the NFC South has always been one of the toughest divisions and most competitive

You say "most competitive".....I say "awful". Guess this is where we differ.

Name that deep playoff run that Carolina has made in the past decade? Or Atlanta? Or Tampa Bay? Only the Saints have done it....

Listen.....are you really trying to say that the NFC South isn't hot garbage? Because it is.....and I think any true objective fan can see it clearly.

[Infinite_limit]

You say "most competitive".....I say "awful". Guess this is where we differ.

Name that deep playoff run that Carolina has made in the past decade? Or Atlanta? Or Tampa Bay? Only the Saints have done it....

Listen.....are you really trying to say that the NFC South isn't hot garbage? Because it is.....and I think any true objective fan can see it clearly.
Both South divisions are routinely the weakest

[Silver&Black]

Both South divisions are routinely the weakest

I'll agree with that. And I'm not calling the AFC South a good division. But for someone who is a fan of a NFC South team to call another division "weak" is just being unrealistic.

[SanAntonioSpurs23]

Then there's...

Russell Wilson has won more Superbpwls than....

Andrew Luck
Cam Newton
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
Archie Manning
RGIII
Johnny Unitas
Dan Marino
Dandy Don Meredith
Jim Kelly
Randall Cunningham
Donovan McNabb
Dan Fouts
Fran Tarkenton
Sonny Jurgenson
Daryl Lamonica
Lynn Dickey
Bert Jones
John Brodie
Colin Kaepernick
Drew Bledsoe
Mark Brunell
Vinny Testerverde
Warren Moon

COMBINED!!!!!!!!!!

It took him all of two seasons, hahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hey faggot remember when Russell Wilson threw a super bowl losing interception?

[SanAntonioSpurs23]

He doesn't. He takes advantage of a soft schedule with soft division rivals.

Below .500 in the worst division in football.....

[Avante]

Hey faggot remember when Russell Wilson threw a super bowl losing interception?

Tell me faggot how many SB's has Andrew Luck played in, oh yeah....NONE~~~~~~~~~

Didn't he throw something like 10 INT's in a couple playoff games? Hell, the last time we him he's throwing two INT's.

[SanAntonioSpurs23]

Tell me faggot how many SB's has Andrew Luck played in, oh yeah....NONE~~~~~~~~~

Didn't he throw something like 10 INT's in a couple playoff games? Hell, the last time we him he's throwing two INT's.

Remember when Russell Wilson cost the Seahawks another ring? Game in his hands and he Fucking blows it like the bitch that he is.

[Avante]

Remember when Russell Wilson cost the Seahawks another ring? Game in his hands and he Fucking blows it like the bitch that he is.

Remember Andrew Lucks last Superbowl appearance? HE'S NEVER BEEEN THERE, hahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Now there's your bitch ya fucking queer.

[Infinite_limit]

Shit after Wilson's performance in the past 2 Playoff games, might as well throw Kaepernick into this discussion

[SanAntonioSpurs23]

Remember Andrew Lucks last Superbowl appearance? HE'S NEVER BEEEN THERE, hahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Now there's your bitch ya fucking queer.

Luck Will get there after all it's only his "3rd year". Something that will never change though is the fact that Struggle Wilson single handedly cost the Seahawks a ring. If he would have done what he does best and hand the ball off this conversation wouldn't be happening.

WilsonCHOKEDPERIOD

[Avante]

Luck Will get there after all it's only his "3rd year". Something that will never change though is the fact that Struggle Wilson single handedly cost the Seahawks a ring. If he would have done what he does best and hand the ball off this conversation wouldn't be happening.

WilsonCHOKEDPERIOD

Yep, 1-1 in SB's, while Andrew Luck can't even get there.

Have you ever seen RW actually play?


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U94nA4Nf3wQ

Handoff???

You're a moron asshole.

[Avante]

Al I can guess is nobody here has ever seen the guy play. RW is the best runner/passer the league has ever seen. The most exciting QB playing today.

[unleashbaynes]

And you're the worst poster on this forum who won't quit spewing shitty takes that literally nobody agrees with.

[Avante]

And you're the worst poster on this forum who won't quit spewing shitty takes that literally nobody agrees with.

I really need those who think the NFL started on 2002 to agree with me, hahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Avante]

Bottom Line....

RW...TWO SB's
Luck...0
Newton...0

[Clipper Nation]

Bottom line:

Struggle = single-handedly blew a Super Bowl despite being on a mega-stacked team, and this was two weeks after trying to single-handedly blow the NFC title game

Luck = dragged a garbage team back from a 28-point deficit to win a playoff game

[Avante]

Bottom line:

Struggle = single-handedly blew a Super Bowl despite being on a mega-stacked team, and this was two weeks after trying to single-handedly blow the NFC title game

Luck = dragged a garbage team back from a 28-point deficit to win a playoff game

Luck has inferior stats, inferior playoff success, less wins.

Oh yeah, RW TWO Superbowls, Andrew Luck...ZERO~~~~~~~~~~~~

RW came within a foot of beating NE, Andrew Luck got totally crushed. And RW has beaten Tom Brady, Brady bitch slaps Andrew Luck.

[NFO]

RW came within a foot of beating NE, Andrew Luck got totally crushed. And RW has beaten Tom Brady, Brady bitch slaps Andrew Luck.

Only because his receiver made a crazy catch 2 plays before to setup RW to blow the game.

RW is a good QB, but there are several QBs in the league that everybody would take before RW's name would enter the conversation.

[N0 LyF3 ScRuB]

This thread will be bumped by me periodically so I can keep up with the comparison

[Avante]

Let me kick start ya...

RW 4-0 vs Cam Newton

Superbowls...RW 2, Cam Newton 0

[NFO]

Let me kick start ya...

RW 4-0 vs Cam Newton

Superbowls...RW 2, Cam Newton 0

RW only has 1 SB win. Counting SB appearances is for losers, which makes sense on why you mention that.

Also NCAA championships Scam 1 RW 0.