Phil Donahue Destroys Bill O'Lilley [Archive]

View Full Version : Phil Donahue Destroys Bill O'Lilley

Nbadan

09-23-2005, 03:46 AM

Phil Donahue is no longer the wimpy talk show host that I remember. Last night he absolutely destroyed O'Reilly. I'm sure if they hadn't been sitting at the same table, Donahue's mike would have been cut.

We need to get this guy on TV more often.

Billy (as Donohue repeatedly called him) started off listing Cindy Sheehan's supposed sins, and Phil was off and running, accusing Billy of participating in the marginalization attempt of Sheehan by the right. Billy proudly claimed that he was "the leader of the pack."

Donohue: Cindy Sheehan is one tough mother and nothing you say or anyone else is going to slow her down.

Bill: That's fine, she's has a right-

Phil:....You can't hurt her, she's already taken the biggest punch in the nose that a woman can take.

Bill, in his infinite wisdom asks: How?

Phil: She's lost a son-

Bill: Oh, OK...

Then Phil plugged the rally in DC on 9/24. Billy wanted to talk about Cindy's radical positions, but Phil went on to attack the war in Iraq.

Billy started pointing his finger at that point and questioned the "cut and run" leftist position.

Donohue then said that O'Reilly wouldn't send his kids to die there, and the frequently masturbating-to-harassing-phone-sex giant head started boiling over, yelling about his "...nephew just joined the army," and, "...he's a patriot, so don't denigrate his service or I'll boot you right off the set!"

Wasn't Cindy's son a patriot, also, Bill?

Phil replied that, "Loud doesn't mean right," and, "you nephew is not your kid."

I could go on, but it's so great to watch and listen to, I encourage everyone to check it out.

Donahue Destroys Bill O'Lilley (http://movies.crooksandliars.com/fox_of_donahue_sheehan_050921a.wmv)

whottt

09-23-2005, 03:58 AM

Yeah...O'Reilly felt so destroyed he replayed the interview on tonights show and he's got it linked on his website. He whipped Donahue's ass and exposed Donahue for the emasculated flake that he is. Donahue even went to the "Rumsfeld met Saddam" card...what a fucking flake.

Wasn't Cindy's son a patriot, also, Bill?

Yes...but what has that got to do with anything? See...that's the stupidest fucking logic I have ever seen. She gets no credit for what her son did....she's doing everything in her power to demean it, and she stands against his Patriotism. In fact...she sympathizes with his killers by calling them Freedom Fighters...

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 06:26 AM

Sorry, Dan...I watched that episode. This is what you got (from a previous post):

"We're sending men & women over there to die!!!"
"They are liars!!!
"We're sending men & women over there to die!!!"
"They are liars!!!
"We're sending men & women over there to die!!!"
"They are liars!!!
"We're sending men & women over there to die!!!"
"They are liars!!!
"We're sending men & women over there to die!!!"

Did he say anything rational or intelligent? No. Did he back any of that up with facts? No. The whole time he was on he didn't really say a damn thing about anything. Dude is getting senile and is in denial...it was painful to watch.

He was totally irrational, had nothing informative to say, and kept yelling OVER O'Reily
when it was his turn to respond. And you call that "destroyed"? I was embarrassed for Phil. Nothing to do with O'Reily at all....Phil was AWFUL. If you truly believe that Phil destroyed him, you have officially fallen off of the left side of the planet.

JoePublic

09-23-2005, 06:31 AM

I thought Phil did a fine job but the right will never see it.

jochhejaam

09-23-2005, 06:38 AM

Phil did a piss poor job of establishing winning talking points and that against someone who I don't consider a good debater. He's an insufferable, incurable liberal and with their ideology shouldn't (and didn't) win debates against someone with a reasonable level of intelligence.

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 06:45 AM

I thought Phil did a fine job but the right will never see it.

All he did was yell louder. How the hell is that a "fine job"? To me, a "fine job" in having any kind of debate would be to 1. express yourself like a rational adult, not some hysterical nutjob and 2. let the other person have their turn to respond and actually listen to what the other person is saying. That has nothing to do with left or right. I have no problem listening to both sides...but when someone starts acting like that it makes me cringe, and not listen to them anymore.

It's like people in this forum that can't have any kind of adult conversation without resorting to childish remarks and insults.

Yonivore

09-23-2005, 06:46 AM

Bill O'Reilly and Phil Donahue? What was the fucking point? They're both idiots.

whottt

09-23-2005, 07:05 AM

I'd be more inclined to believe that the anti-war stance is based on pacifism if they would protest the terrorists too...but like when they were sponsored by the commies in Vietnam...they are only protesting one side.

JohnnyMarzetti

09-23-2005, 07:44 AM

I just can't wait til one day, somebody reaches across the table and slaps the hair out of o'reilly's nose. it will happen. That will be hilarious and long overdue.

whottt

09-23-2005, 07:53 AM

Yeah but it won't be Phil Donahue...

I bet you Phil kissed O'Reilly's ass after that show and thanked him for giving him the opportunity to be seen by audience of more than 2 people.

Too bad you guys didn't think Donahue was so great when he went up against O'Reilly on MSNBC....if you had, he'd still have a soapbox upon which to make a public ass of himself.

JohnnyMarzetti

09-23-2005, 08:01 AM

Bill elicits nothing from me except him needing to be bitchslapped. and at least his nose will be hair-free while he's spending his money getting his jaw fixed.

Marcus Bryant

09-23-2005, 08:53 AM

So you had one loudmouthed egoist going up against another loudmouthed egoist.

One thing I do not understand is the argument "You wouldn't send your kids to war." It's the one straw man argument the anti-war crowd loves to use. Of course most parents wouldn't do that. But you know what? It's the choice of the son or daughter.

Society trusts individuals that age to make decisions about sex, love, health and career but we can't have them deciding to join the military? How about we just make them get mommy and daddy's permission for everything else they do in their lives?

Trainwreck2100

09-23-2005, 09:06 AM

Why is sheenan still a talking point? Somebody give her tickets to Aruba please, everyone wins, the media gets their story I don't have to hear about her any more.

Useruser666

09-23-2005, 09:29 AM

That video clip is hosted on crooksandliars.com, seems rather appropriate for a Dan link.

Sec24Row7

09-23-2005, 09:34 AM

I hate O'Reilly But Donahue is a fucking joke.

Useruser666

09-23-2005, 09:37 AM

Why not have Jenny Jones and Springer sit down and debate.

Marcus Bryant

09-23-2005, 09:38 AM

Yeah, her 15 minutes are over. Her mistake seems to be that her handlers or whatever are using her to advance a hard left viewpoint. She's not a threat to Bush anymore. If she had been able to strike a more mainstream cord and not go off the deep end, it might have been a different story.

Steve Perry

09-23-2005, 10:15 AM

Both of them did there jobs.
Sincerly :the WWF and the WCW :lmao

Jelly

09-23-2005, 11:04 AM

haha. Cindy "get US troops out of occupied New Orleans" Sheehan. The woman is a complete joke.

CharlieMac

09-23-2005, 11:24 AM

Did you even watch that interview?

I didn't think it was possible for someone to be a bigger dickhead than Bill, but now I know it's possible.

Here's something trash won't ever get.....

Yelling louder than the other person, doesn't mean you're winning an argument.

Those are words to live by.

nkdlunch

09-23-2005, 11:31 AM

It's impossible to destroy a blabbering dick on viagra. They just keep going... and going... :lol

RandomGuy

09-23-2005, 12:22 PM

Bill O'Reilly and Phil Donahue? What was the fucking point? They're both idiots.

I'll agree with you on that point.

I didn't think either of the "destroyed" the other. They just got a bit testy. Every once in a great while, I have to hand it to O'Reilly for having someone on his show that he disagrees with and who is articulate enough not to be a push-over. He is in that way a far sight better than Limbaugh, but that doesn't say much.

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 12:27 PM

I agree about not letting himself get pushed over, but you really think Phil was articulate? :lol

Nbadan

09-23-2005, 12:33 PM

I'll agree with you on that point.

I didn't think either of the "destroyed" the other. They just got a bit testy. Every once in a great while, I have to hand it to O'Reilly for having someone on his show that he disagrees with and who is articulate enough not to be a push-over. He is in that way a far sight better than Limbaugh, but that doesn't say much.

I think O'Lilley was blindsided by Donahue, I'm mean, common on, Billy most likely expected the timid, push-over Donahue we all remember from his syndicated show, but what they got was a 60-year old version of Tony Roberts of viagra. Billy didn't know what to expect and fumbled his way through the interview. The fact that O'Lilley spent most of his show yesterday putting his 'spin' on the whole Donahue situation just makes it clearer that Billy got spanked.

Nbadan

09-23-2005, 12:37 PM

I agree about not letting himself get pushed over, but you really think Phil was articulate? :lol

The whole point of these talking head show is to try and be as articulate as possible before they start cutting your mic, that's for sure, but you also have to admit there is a 'scream factor' that applies to shows like this.

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 12:42 PM

I don't think he was at all.....and I've never seen that show resort to what it did. Although I've heard about a good one I missed.

Nbadan

09-23-2005, 12:47 PM

I don't think he was at all.....and I've never seen that show resort to what it did. Although I've heard about a good one I missed.

Sheeh...the best shows are when the guests outscream the host. Krugman is a vocal favorite of mine.

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 12:50 PM

Hook Dem

09-23-2005, 12:50 PM

This thread is comedy central. You guys are gonna see what you want to see! :lol

Nbadan

09-23-2005, 01:03 PM

I don't watch much of any of them actually... I just happened to be surfing for Rita news when it was on.

Hannity & Combs is another one I've seldom seen but watched that evening as well. My observation: If Combs wasn't such a pussy, Hannity wouldn't seem like such an over-bearing asshole.

:lol

Combs isn't much of a Progressive. If FAUX really cared about ratings they would match someone like Thom Hartman against Bill O'Lilley.

xrayzebra

09-23-2005, 02:57 PM

Combs isn't much of a Progressive. If FAUX really cared about ratings they would match someone like Thom Hartman against Bill O'Lilley.

You definition of "progressive" please. 60 years of Dimm-o-craptic progressive such as we have seen in NO and La.

MiNuS

09-23-2005, 03:02 PM

O'Reilly got OWND by Donahue!

Bill tried to spin it around that he had ass whipped Donahue but looked pathetic!

Bill did admit today on radio that he got awsome ratings.So he accomplished his purpose.

Fox in my opinion is like "Harriet Oleson" of "Little House on the Praire".
You guys who've seen this classic show know what I mean.

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 03:35 PM

whottt

09-23-2005, 03:46 PM

Dude...ALL HE DID WAS YELL OVER HIM. :lol :lol

That's not true...he also mentioned the Saddam Rumsfeld picture. That's ownership there!

O'Reilly is just lucky that Donahue didn't pull out the, "Bush sat there for 7 minutes after 9/11" Gun...He got off easy.

MiNuS

09-23-2005, 04:16 PM

Dude...ALL HE DID WAS YELL OVER HIM. :lol :lol
Duddette...YOU MEAN O'REILLY,YELLED OVER DONAHUE??RIGHT??? :lol :lol

Thats what I heard. O'reilly was already getting ready to punch Donahue.

On Fox if the Democrats don't raise their voice just a notch the Neocons like Hannity and O'reilly will never let you talk!

whottt

09-23-2005, 04:20 PM

On Fox if the Democrats don't raise their voice just a notch the Neocons like Hannity and O'reilly will never let you talk!

O'Reilly's not a neocon...just ask Yonivore.

MiNuS

09-23-2005, 04:22 PM

O'Reilly's not a neocon...just ask Yonivore.he's not completely but he's on the FOX payroll. On his radioshow he's a moderate republican.

I can live with moderate but not the FAR-RIGHT or FAR-LEFT.Either extreme is too crazy for me.

SpursWoman

09-23-2005, 04:57 PM

but not the FAR-RIGHT or FAR-LEFT.Either extreme is too crazy for me.

That was Phil last night......wwaaaaaaaaay out there.

And that was really weird watching them yell at each other like that. :lol

JohnnyMarzetti

09-24-2005, 09:57 AM

I watched it again this morning, for the third time. I've never seen O'Reilly get his ass handed to him like that. The finger pointing and yelling completely failed him with Donohue. Donohue showed no signs of being intimidated, and stayed consistant with a message that is now POPULAR with the American public.

Note the end of the clip, OReilly looks flustered with defeat when he sais, "Those people deserve freedom". It was like that was his last card, and he was just hoping it would beat a royal flush.

What a job Donohue did with him. Like I said, I think we're going to be seeing Donohue with a high profile job in the press pretty soon here.

SpursWoman

09-24-2005, 10:07 AM

Doesn't surprise me at all that you think that way.

jochhejaam

09-24-2005, 11:50 AM

I think we're going to be seeing Donohue with a high profile job in the press pretty soon here.

He had a high profile job two years ago and lasted 6 months, what's changed? Nothing.
Back then O'Reilly had about 6 times the viewers that Donahue had.
Not many can stomach the liberal ranting from the Donahues of this world.

Looter

09-24-2005, 11:56 AM

see for yourself who won.http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,163815,00.html

So when is the big PPV fight set up?

JohnnyMarzetti

09-24-2005, 01:29 PM

Doesn't surprise me at all that you think that way.

Doesn't surprise me at all the way you think either. :rolleyes

Oh, never mind you don't think for yourself.

Hook Dem

09-24-2005, 01:35 PM

Doesn't surprise me at all the way you think either. :rolleyes

Oh, never mind you don't think for yourself.
See! You're trying to out yell SW. Thats the success pattern in your eyes. Dumb shit! What a puny insult in your last sentence! You are the picture of a true loser! Don't bother replying. I'm not listening...lalalalalalalalalalalalalala! :lol

SpursWoman

09-24-2005, 02:04 PM

Doesn't surprise me at all the way you think either. :rolleyes

Oh, never mind you don't think for yourself.

:lmao

You're right ... that wasn't my own opinion. I honestly do think screaming in an argument and not letting the other person have their turn is the most professional, adult way to get my point across. Maybe next time I disagree with my boss, I should tell her how I really feel. :lol

I guess I should have just posted a cartoon or copy & pasted someone else's article to express myself like you do. Or maybe spew nothing but bitter, hateful remarks. " :rolleyes "

Alice

09-24-2005, 03:08 PM

Who the hell has time for talk shows?

T Park

09-26-2005, 03:24 AM

never mind you don't think for yourself

why is that always the left's favorite saying.

SpursWoman

09-26-2005, 06:30 AM

What's really ironic is you hear that (from both sides) blasted all over TV, newspapers, etc. about the other *side*. So do you think Johnny Marzwhathefuckever thought that up all by himself, or did he let someone do his thinking for him?

:lol

Hook Dem

09-26-2005, 08:52 AM