Stone Temple Pilots or Pearl Jam

[batman2883]

STP Kicks ass i wish they still performed

[Ishta]

neither...

[batman2883]

STP
Plush
Big Empty
Interstate Love Song
Creep...

all classics

[MaNuMaNiAc]

Guns'N Roses vs. Velvet Revolver? I'm a big Scott Weiland fan as well as Slash, but Velvet Revolver just isn't quite the same as Stone Temple Pilots nor Guns, so I'd have to say Guns

[MiNuS]

Hey manumania

Soda or Enanos?

[Summers]

Pearl Jam. Eddie Vedder makes me drool.

[MannyIsGod]

This is like AC/DC Zeplin. Both are good bands, but only one - Pearl Jam - is a GREAT band.

[ObiwanGinobili]

pearl jam. definatly.

but thats a really close one....it;s like 55/45.

[TheTruth]

pearl jam....fo sho

[KEDA]

S T P

[Jelly]

Pearl Jam. Eddie Vedder makes me drool.

Eddie Vedder?? Isn't he in Metallica?

My vote goes for Pearl Jam.

[MannyIsGod]

Eddie Vedder?? Isn't he in Metallica?

My vote goes for Pearl Jam.
You just made me cry.

[mavsfan1000]

Stone Temple Pilots for me. Pearl Jam=overrated. They are good but got too much attention.

[MaNuMaNiAc]

Hey manumania

Soda or Enanos?mmm... dificil, pero creo que Soda por un pelo

[SWC Bonfire]

STP Kicks ass i wish they still performed

STP hasn't performed well since Richard Petty retired. Do they still make that stuff?

[MaNuMaNiAc]

Eddie Vedder?? Isn't he in Metallica?

My vote goes for Pearl Jam.
http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/36/36_1_25.gifhttp://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/36/36_1_4.gif

[batman2883]

STP hasn't performed well since Richard Petty retired. Do they still make that stuff?


He didnt retire, he's in a group now that has Duff in it now

[T Park]

Peal Jam.

ten
yield
no code

genius music.

Pearl Jam far and away

Ten, is by far and away my favorite album of all time as well.

[ObiwanGinobili]

Eddie Vedder?? Isn't he in Metallica?

My vote goes for Pearl Jam.


:huh ??

manny needs to share his kleenex

[Kip Fanatic]

Pearl Jam is my all-time favorite. They did start something new. Eddie Veder is weird, but can really write great songs. This band will be remembered for a while. STP is a good band no doubt, but they don't come close to what Pearl Jam has done and will continue to do. The album Ten was something else and will be hard to match for a very long time.

[blackbucket]

PJ is one of the greatest rock n roll bands of all time. They shun self promotion by yesterday and today standards and just focus on their music.

[Shelly]

STP

I can't stand Eddie Vedder's voice. And I can't stand to watch him perform.

[midgetonadonkey]

Eddie Vedder is the man. In no way is STP better than Pearl Jam. They are the best group to come out of the 90's. They even top Nirvana.

[exstatic]

STP is badass but Pearl Jam change the music industry.

How can you "change the music industry" when all you did was follow Nirvana out of Seattle? Pearl Jam was the Buzz Aldrin of the Seattle music scene.

[midgetonadonkey]

They were far more talented than Nirvana. The only reason they get the credit they do is because the junkie blew his fucking brains out. It is the only reason they are as highly regarded as they are.

[Jelly]

They were far more talented than Nirvana. The only reason they get the credit they do is because the junkie blew his fucking brains out. It is the only reason they are as highly regarded as they are.

I think Manny may want to set you straight on that :lol

[SpursWoman]

Temple of the Dog. :)

[MannyIsGod]

It isn't fair to say Pearl Jam was more talented than Nirvana. I can't compare the 2 and by making me do so you cause me great great pain. In all honesty, I probably do give the edge to Pearl Jam as a band.

Nirvana was incredible and to say the only reason Kurt was famouse was because he was killed by Courtney Love is foolish. Now, if you want to use his murder as a reason why Courtney Love is still famouse, then by all means feel free to do so.

Whether Kurt intended his songs to be what comes across to many people is debateable as well, but they still kick ass. He was flat out just an awesome song writer and I put him way beyond Eddie Vedder, but Eddie Vedder doesn't write all of Pearl Jams music alone.

That being said, I think if Grohl and Cobain had more time together, it would have been phenomenal. The best ones always go too fast.

[mavsfan1000]

I think the band that is underrated is the Foo Fighters. Dave Grohl proved he can make his own band and had great success doing so. Other than his first cd he has been great. Foo Fighters>Nirvana imo.

[Chris]

I agree with MannyIsGod on not being able to compare any of those bands. They have varying degrees of greatness and only one of those 3 is still making music under the same name. Pearl Jam will probably go into the Rock n' Roll Hall of Fame if the hold on to their core.


ten
yield
no code


You forgot VS. and Vitalogy! The first three including the latter and Ten are what I grew up with. Immortality on Vitalogy and Black on Ten are my favorite Pearl Jam songs.

[MannyIsGod]

Black is flat out phenomenal.

[ZStomp]

Neither. :spin

[SequSpur]

Nirvana is dead. STP is dead. Pearl Jam lives on and on and on.

It's not even close.

Glorified version of a pellet gun.

[David Bowie]

I'm not really into either band, but Im a big fan of Scott Weyland.

[MannyIsGod]

I've been listening to Purple for 2 days now because of this thread. Good shit.

[ALVAREZ6]

Stone Temple Pilots

[mavsfan1000]

I think Purple is a very underrated album. That cd is much better than Core their debut album.

[T Park]

You forgot VS. and Vitalogy

I know, i had someone whip me with a bamboo cane after i remembered I forgot to put those on there.

Vs with the freaky ass Sheep on the front is fantastic.

[Cant_Be_Faded]

STP's first album made me go damn these guys rock

STP's second album made me go, okay, they're still good

when i heard STP's third album i had a blank stare of disbelief for a while then threw that bitch out my car window as soon as possible


-------
that is an actual quote from a guy i used to know, that i pretty much agree with



Pearl Jam owns STP. Vedder is a fucking hard ass, not a flamer that wears leather coochie-cutters. Plus, they've rolled with the times.

Although they do have some bad ones. Personally, I thought Vitalogy sucked and The Better Man was the gayest PJ song of all time. But Yield fucking rocked hard, and the few songs I've heard of their latest 2 or 3 releases have been good.

[TheAdmiral#50]

Pearl Jam

[mavsfan1000]

Pearl Jam and STP have one thing in common. They both sucked after their first 2 albums.

[MannyIsGod]

Ten was fucking amazing, but Yeild is a close second. I agree on Better Man, I don't like it much. Alive, Black, and Do The Evolution are so bad ass though.

[Cant_Be_Faded]

Ten was fucking amazing, but Yeild is a close second. I agree on Better Man, I don't like it much. Alive, Black, and Do The Evolution are so bad ass though.

Alive is a bad ass classic, but for the past few years, I've found that my favorite song on Ten is "Porch"

(if this isn't on ten, then my bad cuz im not positive)


The first time i heard that song was when i was like in 5th grade watching SNL lol. Do The Evolution is probably one of the best songs of all time. And the Video? Damn, that shit was bad.

[MannyIsGod]

Oh dude, that video is probably my favorite of all time. The animation was unreal.

[Cant_Be_Faded]

I wish McFarlane still made the Spawn show and it came out on adult swim or some shit. That show was bad ass too, except they never showed Spawn shooting that green shit from his hands.