Log in

View Full Version : Grades: Spurs @ Pelicans - Jan. 26, 2019



timvp
01-27-2019, 03:12 AM
https://i.imgur.com/mr0zdkm.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/rv6ca7B.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/qze8zLf.jpg

The Spurs traveled to New Orleans to take on a Pelicans squad missing three of their four best players. San Antonio, who was also shorthanded without DeMar DeRozan (knee, ankle, bumps, bruises) and Davis Bertans (personal), took care of business by leaving the Big Easy with a 126-114 victory.

Coming out of halftime with a three-point lead, the Spurs blew it open with a 13-2 run early in the third quarter. The Pelicans never got within single digits from then on out.

All in all, it was a needed road win for the good guys. They weren't overly impressive but, with the Pelicans being without Anthony Davis, Julius Randle and Nikola Mirotic, the Spurs really needed to get it -- and they did. Plus, with a back-to-back game tomorrow night, San Antonio much preferred an easy win. They did that too.

-------------

LaMarcus Aldridge
https://i.imgur.com/1nluyNF.png
Heading into the affair, LaMarcus Aldridge was questionable with a left wrist injury. After begging Pop to let him play, Aldridge once again exhibited All-Star form -- even though he was doing most everything one-handed. The University of Texas product was physical in the paint, threw his weight around and gave the Spurs a focal point on offense. Aldridge's right-handed touch was good, he made smart passes and took care of the ball. Defensively, he wasn't a world-beater but he was solid. He was effective on the defensive glass and he was deft enough out on the perimeter to deal with the fact that he was almost always matched up with a small forward.
Grade: A
Summary: Aldridge shook off a wrist injury to post another impressive performance.

-------------

Rudy Gay
https://i.imgur.com/vqYr2we.png
With DeRozan out, Rudy Gay stepped into the role of the offense's second option and did so seamlessly. His outstanding efficiency (22 points on 13 shots) was bolstered by a season-high eight free throw attempts. Gay looked comfortable in all facets of the offensive attack: he hit multiple three-pointers for the first time in more than a month, he tenaciously attacked the basket and he was impactful on the post. His defense wasn't anything to write home to Baltimore about but Gay did grab double-digit rebounds for the first time in six weeks. Unfortunately, he twisted his ankle midway through the fourth quarter. Gay says he'll play tomorrow night ... but we'll see.
Grade: A-
Summary: Gay was good until he limped off the court.

-------------

Bryn Forbes
https://i.imgur.com/yXVIEAs.png
I was mostly pleased with Bryn Forbes offensively. He didn't shoot particularly well but I liked his aggressive shot-selection. His passing was better than usual; Forbes had a pair of pretty dishes to Pau Gasol. Defensively, he made a few mistakes and got overwhelmed on multiple occasions but he wasn't too far south of his normal level.
Grade: B
Summary: Forbes was fine.

-------------

Derrick White
https://i.imgur.com/IrTA2dV.png
Derrick White was the conductor of the offense more than usual tonight and he did well. He could have pushed the pace more and called his own number more but he ran the sets with precision, made a number of very good passes and his court vision continues to impress. Defensively, it was tough sledding for stretches as White attempted to deal with the Pelicans only standing star in Jrue Holiday. White took his lumps but competed well and eventually had some success. Despite having his hands full with his one-on-one responsibilities, White managed to offer timely help on defense. He finished with team-highs in steals and blocks. (White has posted three straight games with at least two steals and at least one block.)
Grade: B+
Summary: It wasn't easy but White persisted.

-------------

Pau Gasol
https://i.imgur.com/oF0jVre.png
I mean, there was definite improvement from Pau Gasol. Offensively, he was a weapon the Pelicans couldn't handle with their top three bigs out injured and their hands already full with Aldridge. Gasol was strong around the rim and passed the ball extremely well -- both from the top of the key and in the low block. This was by far the Spaniard's best offensive showing since returning from injury. Defensively, though, Gasol is a, uh, work in progress. He was absolutely hopeless when his man went out on the perimeter; Gasol simply stayed in the lane and observed from a distance. His slowness also hurt his interior defense, as he couldn't guard the paint unless the offensive player came right at him. Overall, Gasol looked better but I'm not sure if he legitimately regained some of his missing mobility or if the Pelicans simply didn't have the weaponry to take advantage of his labored movements.
Grade: B+
Summary: Gasol had his best game since his return.

-------------

Marco Belinelli
https://i.imgur.com/hP9vIFY.png
This was the first time in eight outings that Marco Belinelli scored less than 12 points. To his credit, Belinelli's lowered output was mostly due to him being more willing to pass than usual, as his four assists were the most he's tallied in a month. Though he was once again a valuable offensive threat, his defense was even worse than usual. Belinelli was slow in man-to-man situations, failed to rotate a handful of times and was basically just going through the motions on that end. It was no coincidence that the Spurs struggled to get stops whenever he was on the court.
Grade: B-
Summary: Offense was a plus. Defense was a minus.

-------------

Patty Mills
https://i.imgur.com/gTa4B5z.png
The good: Patty Mills' passing was really, really good on his way to racking up a team-high five assists. He attempted and completed multiple difficult passes. Mills kept his mistakes to a minimum and his shot-selection was tolerable, which hasn't always been the case of late. The bad: Mills' overall vivacity was a level lower than it needs to be on a nightly basis. His defense wasn't too terrible but it was definitely on the passive side.
Grade: B
Summary: Mills' passing was impressive.

-------------

Dante Cunningham
https://i.imgur.com/W3QWUCI.png
Offensively, Dante Cunningham was fine. He didn't explode like he did the previous two games against his former team (his two highest scoring games of the year, 19 and 15, were versus the Pelicans) but he was helping out by passing well, crashing the offensive boards and scrapping for loose balls. (With his 1-for-1 showing from three-point territory, Cunningham is now 9-for-11 from deep against New Orleans this season.) Defensively, Cunningham was bad. Really bad. He struggled mightily to defend out to the three-point line, his rotations were about two and a half steps slow and, to top it off, he was getting scored over in the paint. I'm still amazed at how bad Cunningham is defensively. He plays hard on that end but he doesn't have the physical skills (too slow to defend smalls, too small to defend bigs) and has no defensive instincts at all.
Grade: C
Summary: Cunningham's D was bad.

-------------

Lonnie Walker IV
https://i.imgur.com/JOLYiew.png
Welcome to the NBA, Lonnie Walker IV. Playing his first meaningful minutes of his career, I thought Walker was impressive. First of all, he passes the eye-test with flying colors: he's really quick even compared to other NBA players, he's an explosive athlete and he's longer than he appears at first glance. Walker's shooting stroke is looking better and better -- tonight he opened with a midrange jumper and later buried a three-pointer. It was good to see him rebounding well as he's been rather anemic in that category while in the G-League. I also liked what I saw from him defensively. He was making tactical mistakes here and there but the energy he brought to the court was palpable. Walker had trouble navigating around screens but was successful in one-on-one situations and stayed mentally-engaged when off the ball. Truth be told, he's been poor defensively in the G-League, so showing flashes of ability on that end was notable. Considering everything, this was a really good debut for Walker. He legitimately looks like a prospect with an excitingly high ceiling.
Grade: A-
Summary: Walker didn't disappoint.

-------------

Quincy Pondexter
https://i.imgur.com/NUKbCEE.png
With the Spurs stuck in mud in the second quarter, Pop called on Quincy Pondexter and he delivered immediate results. Over the proceeding minute, Pondexter scored six consecutive points to spark an 11-2 run. Add in some hard-nosed defense and the coaching staff couldn't have asked for much more in his eight minutes of playing time.
Grade: A-
Summary: Pondexter answered the bell.

-------------

Jakob Poeltl
https://i.imgur.com/FUIlW00.png
With Gasol playing his best game in a long time, Jakob Poeltl was the odd man out. I hope this doesn't become a trend.
Grade: Inc.
Summary: Poeltl's minutes vanished.

-------------

Pop
https://i.imgur.com/x7B1It7.jpg
Going with Gasol as the replacement for DeRozan in the starting lineup worked out well even though the Pelicans started a tiny lineup. Playing Walker and Pondexter when the team needed a boost of energy also worked fantastically. Pop did well to limit everyone's minutes in this first game of a back-to-back ... with one glaring exception. Why was Gay on the court with the Spurs up by 20 points and only six minutes remaining? Pop has done a good job all year of limiting Gay's minutes as much as possible in order to protect his fragile health. Until tonight. Gay twisted his ankle while playing garbage minutes on top of his already team-high 32 minutes. Mistake.
Grade: C+
Summary: Good except for a glaring mistake.

Looking ahead: Got the win. Nice job.

Next up is a back-to-back against the Wizards. The game is at home and Washington is 6-18 on the road so, really, this is another game the Spurs need. No excuses.

Chinook
01-27-2019, 03:52 AM
Eh, I assumed Rudy was going to rest tomorrow, which is why Pop played him so much. You gotta finish the game. I wanted to see Metu get more time (even if he was wonky in what time he ended up getting), but I'll hold my tongue on guys staying in too long for quite some time after that Philly game. I really don't expect to see Rudy play tomorrow, but it's another match the team needs to win, so Pop may well let him get some run if Bertans is out. If DeRozan is also out, Gay has to play, because Aldridge hasn't been as explosive on the second night of most B2Bs this year.

I think your grade on Lonnie was optimistic or at least somewhat misleading. I thought it was a great (first real NBA action) game, and I'm a believer in his ceiling. But the grade sort of implies that he was actually putting in good rotation minutes, and I didn't see that. I thought his rebounding was okay. Like it's nice that he got that many, but he didn't attack the glass or anything. The balls just happened to bounce to him. In order to be a really good rebounding guard, one has to be able to get into the paint and tip balls away from the opponent or at least help box out. Not a church thing, but Murray rebounds in a completely different way than Walker did tonight. DeJounte's way of getting boards is just way more consistent, even accounting for the volume difference. With Lonnie's athleticism, such rebounding isn't out of his reach. He should become a very good rebounder for a guard, but that wasn't what was going on. The shots were objectively nice. Hell, the game was nice. I'm more than happy to overlook the short-comings and go straight to the ceiling. But he didn't look ready for rotation minutes.

As I mentioned in the trade thread, Pau played well, but the game showed why he's not all that valuable. It's easier than ever to find a center who can score. Gasol adds a whole bunch of intangibles, but he just can't do enough to play with Aldridge against most teams, and I've yet to see him and Poeltl both play well in the same game. The rotation just doesn't seem big enough for three centers. It's gonna be hard for Pau to get his consistent minutes, on the Spurs or anywhere else. He's not a bad player, but he's an awkward one in today's league, and with that contract, that's not a good thing.

MoSpur02
01-27-2019, 04:19 AM
Happy with the win after the last couple of games. Gasol playing all those minutes should get Pop a F.

playbonner15
01-27-2019, 04:56 AM
Lonnie Walker was getting beat by his man a couple of times so I wouldnt put a grade so high for him

ceperez
01-27-2019, 05:50 AM
Eh, I assumed Rudy was going to rest tomorrow, which is why Pop played him so much. You gotta finish the game. I wanted to see Metu get more time (even if he was wonky in what time he ended up getting), but I'll hold my tongue on guys staying in too long for quite some time after that Philly game. I really don't expect to see Rudy play tomorrow, but it's another match the team needs to win, so Pop may well let him get some run if Bertans is out. If DeRozan is also out, Gay has to play, because Aldridge hasn't been as explosive on the second night of most B2Bs this year.

I think your grade on Lonnie was optimistic or at least somewhat misleading. I thought it was a great (first real NBA action) game, and I'm a believer in his ceiling. But the grade sort of implies that he was actually putting in good rotation minutes, and I didn't see that. I thought his rebounding was okay. Like it's nice that he got that many, but he didn't attack the glass or anything. The balls just happened to bounce to him. In order to be a really good rebounding guard, one has to be able to get into the paint and tip balls away from the opponent or at least help box out. Not a church thing, but Murray rebounds in a completely different way than Walker did tonight. DeJounte's way of getting boards is just way more consistent, even accounting for the volume difference. With Lonnie's athleticism, such rebounding isn't out of his reach. He should become a very good rebounder for a guard, but that wasn't what was going on. The shots were objectively nice. Hell, the game was nice. I'm more than happy to overlook the short-comings and go straight to the ceiling. But he didn't look ready for rotation minutes.

As I mentioned in the trade thread, Pau played well, but the game showed why he's not all that valuable. It's easier than ever to find a center who can score. Gasol adds a whole bunch of intangibles, but he just can't do enough to play with Aldridge against most teams, and I've yet to see him and Poeltl both play well in the same game. The rotation just doesn't seem big enough for three centers. It's gonna be hard for Pau to get his consistent minutes, on the Spurs or anywhere else. He's not a bad player, but he's an awkward one in today's league, and with that contract, that's not a good thing.

Walker needs to get more minutes in the NBA. He can't learn how different it is to play in the big leagues by playing in the small leagues. If we want his to play defense then he's got to know how hard the screens are in the NBA and how to work your way around it. He's is not getting that exposure in G-league. I think White needs a break defending the opponents best player, so Walker has a role to play.

Pau is good for beating up the bad teams. The way most teams are constructed, they are too small against Pau. Against the good teams, Pau is a liability.

duncan2150
01-27-2019, 05:57 AM
I understand the grade for Walker, we talk about a rookie who played a lot of g league. I watched him closely on defense and he was active, fast and that’s Good. Offcourse he made some mistakes and he needs some work.

Overall it was a good game for him.

Robz4000
01-27-2019, 06:13 AM
Yeah, I'm not sure about the whole Pop critique concerning Gay. The game was still relatively in doubt and it made more sense to keep Gay in than LMA who was already playing a lot of minutes. I like to call out Pop as much as anyone but I can't really blame him for Gay's injury.

vavvi
01-27-2019, 08:06 AM
Just watched the replay. Pretty ugly game. Have to say it looked like a Russian league outing in a half-empty house but without the defense. Anyway, a win is a win.

I wasn't too impressed by Lonnie. The good was his quickness which is special. The bad... I didn't like his bball IQ. Not sure if he's a Spurs type player but who knows what the Spurs will look like when Pop retires.

Harry Callahan
01-27-2019, 09:34 AM
It's pretty interesting that a player's basketball IQ can be determined in a rookie's first NBA game of meaningful minutes.

Honestly, Lonnie seems much more comfortable than a lot of veteran NBA players as it relates to expressing himself and interacting with media people.

If he can stay well physically, he has a lot to offer in the coming years.

Play Boban
01-27-2019, 10:35 AM
Walker was a turnstile defensively.

monty4329
01-27-2019, 10:42 AM
It's pretty interesting that a player's basketball IQ can be determined in a rookie's first NBA game of meaningful minutes.

Honestly, Lonnie seems much more comfortable than a lot of veteran NBA players as it relates to expressing himself and interacting with media people.

If he can stay well physically, he has a lot to offer in the coming years.

Agree. Especially if you compare him to Metu, who honestly has no business being in the NBA

GAustex
01-27-2019, 10:45 AM
When Walker was defending weak side and a big set a screen on him-everytime he got rubbed off on the screen and his man stolled into the paint. LW needs to see that coming and do better-that is really fundamental. Walkers awareness abount what is going on needs improvement. He can run and elevate with that sweet stroke though...

monty4329
01-27-2019, 10:49 AM
Good win, game was tricky, with all the missing players on both sides you really never know...Anyway, I find extremely positive that, once ahead, the game was never in doubt. Which is quite something, considering last game and others in the near past.

Impressed by QP, played well with good energy, a true pro. Proved why he was signed. I also liked Pau start, pretty solid minutes.
Pity for Gay, but with a depleted bench and LMA injured, he had to be on the court. Let's hope he can rest tonigh -if not him then it will be LMA.

Any news about Bertans?

Spurs Homer
01-27-2019, 11:37 AM
Walker is a player. He needs all the time that can be given immediately. He will be wasted if he is not thrown into the rotation immediately.

If Steve Kerr had him on the warriors - the most talented team in the world - Kerr would find minutes for him so that by the playoffs - he would be in a groove already.

C'mon pop - just force feed the kid some minutes and allow him to get his awkwardness and mistakes out of the way.

Do NOT take another 3 years the way you did with Splitter and now Bertans -
heck pop even gave Forbes time - no reason to give a player with a much higher ceiling less time than that.

vavvi
01-27-2019, 12:04 PM
It's pretty interesting that a player's basketball IQ can be determined in a rookie's first NBA game of meaningful minutes.

Honestly, Lonnie seems much more comfortable than a lot of veteran NBA players as it relates to expressing himself and interacting with media people.

If he can stay well physically, he has a lot to offer in the coming years.

Sure It's way too early. And unlike Metu it's easy to see NBA potential there.
Was just saying he seems like... not the type of player Pop prefers to work with, that's all.

vavvi
01-27-2019, 12:07 PM
Good win, game was tricky, with all the missing players on both sides you really never know...Anyway, I find extremely positive that, once ahead, the game was never in doubt. Which is quite something, considering last game and others in the near past.

Impressed by QP, played well with good energy, a true pro. Proved why he was signed. I also liked Pau start, pretty solid minutes.
Pity for Gay, but with a depleted bench and LMA injured, he had to be on the court. Let's hope he can rest tonigh -if not him then it will be LMA.

Any news about Bertans?

Agree I liked that Pop played Pau, QP, Cun extended minutes. Pels had basically one one real player out there, and it was more important to stay pro and play with energy than use some special skill and athleticism. For such games serious vets may be better than moody DeMar.

Kobe'sAchilles
01-27-2019, 12:22 PM
QP looks like a dying deer when he runs. Like I'm always amazed when he does something positive bc he just looks like the most unathletic guy I've ever seen. Just awkward. But I'm glad he did well lol

BlackAndWhite
01-27-2019, 12:26 PM
Maybe QP should get more playing time. I remember him playing pretty well in 2013. His skills couldn't have diminished that much considering he's still only 30

ceperez
01-27-2019, 12:27 PM
Sure It's way too early. And unlike Metu it's easy to see NBA potential there.
Was just saying he seems like... not the type of player Pop prefers to work with, that's all.

The question I got about Metu is.... why can't he replace Cunningham?

He's taller, more mobile and can shoot the 3. He's not as bulky, but Cunningham can't guard anyone and is worthless in help defense.

Degoat
01-27-2019, 12:33 PM
Will be interesting tonight, idk who’s playing yet but potentially LA, DeMar, Gay, Davis could be out, id imagine some of them will play though but if not lonnie should get some more minutes again

sasaint
01-27-2019, 12:46 PM
Good win, game was tricky, with all the missing players on both sides you really never know...Anyway, I find extremely positive that, once ahead, the game was never in doubt. Which is quite something, considering last game and others in the near past.

Impressed by QP, played well with good energy, a true pro. Proved why he was signed. I also liked Pau start, pretty solid minutes.
Pity for Gay, but with a depleted bench and LMA injured, he had to be on the court. Let's hope he can rest tonigh -if not him then it will be LMA.

Any news about Bertans?

Do you think there is the remotest possibility that Pop believes that Quincy is still in recovery mode, that he can recover enough to approach his former level of athleticism/effectiveness and that, consequently, they still have a plan (at least a tentative plan) for him as a Spur?

vavvi
01-27-2019, 12:54 PM
The question I got about Metu is.... why can't he replace Cunningham?

He's taller, more mobile and can shoot the 3. He's not as bulky, but Cunningham can't guard anyone and is worthless in help defense.

I saw every minute Metu played in NBA and zero minutes of him in Austin. I haven't noticed a single thing he's good at or can be good in the future (except cheering for his teammates). He looks clueless on both ends. And I doubt he can shoot the 3 as you say.
Also: it's weird to develop a young prospect into Cun's role meaning vet min body you are playing when noone's available

Chinook
01-27-2019, 12:57 PM
Chim's already a pretty good d-league player. What's hurting him is that he's not going to be a first-option player in the NBA, and it's hard to develop those skills with the lack of complimentary talent. Guards have it easiest there, because they can pretty much do everything they need to no matter how bad the rest of the team is. Bigs just need a good guard. Forwards are tricky. Chim being a selfish/"assertive" player in the d-league works, but in the pros, he'll have to learn to be "solid" before anyone's gonna start giving him the ball. Give him time. The Spurs guaranteed two years of his deal for a reason.

BackHome
01-27-2019, 01:16 PM
I think they will start focusing on Walker as far as making him run point and given him the Green light to shoot the 3 ball. I think Metu can make it but SF/PF takes longer to develop and I think he will be the next player they focus on next year in G League.

Pavlov
01-27-2019, 01:18 PM
I think they will start focusing on Walker on Walker as far as maybe making him run pointThat was a disaster in the D-League tbh.

vavvi
01-27-2019, 01:21 PM
Chim's already a pretty good d-league player. What's hurting him is that he's not going to be a first-option player in the NBA, and it's hard to develop those skills with the lack of complimentary talent. Guards have it easiest there, because they can pretty much do everything they need to no matter how bad the rest of the team is. Bigs just need a good guard. Forwards are tricky. Chim being a selfish/"assertive" player in the d-league works, but in the pros, he'll have to learn to be "solid" before anyone's gonna start giving him the ball. Give him time. The Spurs guaranteed two years of his deal for a reason.

But which position will he play? It's hard to see him anything beside 5. And we have not enough 5 minutes for our actual 5s.

BackHome
01-27-2019, 01:24 PM
Yeah it has which was I was surprised he was running the point for the Spurs this past game. He was not great but he was not bad he showed he has pretty good handles. While I liked what I saw he still needs to play all the G League games but still be bought up when we can give him minutes with the big boys.

BackHome
01-27-2019, 01:26 PM
Metu can not play Center well not unless he uses John Jones secrete dick pill recipes.

Pavlov
01-27-2019, 01:33 PM
But which position will he play? It's hard to see him anything beside 5. And we have not enough 5 minutes for our actual 5s.I don't know why folks don't think he can't play the four. His face up game and spot shooting are what he does best on offense and he's certainly mobile enough to defend PFs. What gives?

wildbill2u
01-27-2019, 02:13 PM
Going into your first game in a bigger league can be daunting mentally. If you ever played BB, think of the first time you experienced the rush and pressure. Most rookies take a long time to adjust.

vavvi
01-27-2019, 04:01 PM
I don't know why folks don't think he can't play the four. His face up game and spot shooting are what he does best on offense and he's certainly mobile enough to defend PFs. What gives?

We'll wait and see.
To me he hasn't showed enough shooting or passing. Today's fours are Lebrons and Durants and Harrises and Gays. I just can't see him competing against this type of players.

Dallas has this Kleber fellow who can protect the basket on one end and stretch the floor on the other end. This is what Metu needs to become to be a competent back-up four.

Spurtacular
01-27-2019, 04:37 PM
Summary: Cunningham's D was bad.


Seen a lot of posters fawn over his defense. But at 1:40 just way too easy. His spacial awareness seemed lacking too.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCuTNyrnxLo&t=304s

monty4329
01-27-2019, 05:18 PM
Do you think there is the remotest possibility that Pop believes that Quincy is still in recovery mode, that he can recover enough to approach his former level of athleticism/effectiveness and that, consequently, they still have a plan (at least a tentative plan) for him as a Spur?

No, I don't think so. I believe what he is doing is exactly why he is the roster. Positive attitude, can play when needed, professional. Nothing less, nothing more. The perfect 10-11th player.

monty4329
01-27-2019, 05:23 PM
The question I got about Metu is.... why can't he replace Cunningham?

He's taller, more mobile and can shoot the 3. He's not as bulky, but Cunningham can't guard anyone and is worthless in help defense.

Because Metu can't play NBA basketball right now (and never will, I am afraid). He is clueless about what to do, and when. It is painful yo watch. Seems a good guy but, really, he can't play in the NBA.

monty4329
01-27-2019, 05:26 PM
Metu can not play Center well not unless he uses John Jones secrete dick pill recipes.

:lmao

sasaint
01-27-2019, 05:31 PM
No, I don't think so. I believe what he is doing is exactly why he is the roster. Positive attitude, can play when needed, professional. Nothing less, nothing more. The perfect 10-11th player.

Yeah, kind of a pity. When we signed him I was hopeful that maybe he could bounce back all the way to the rotation.

acoelho1
01-27-2019, 06:25 PM
In my view, Walker should get any minutes that that Cunningham would normally see action. Pop won't do that because he's stubborn as mule in terms of playing veterans. Nevertheless, as Walker said, just keep grinding it out and take advantage of every opportunity when out on the court and hopefully that will sway Pop to play him more.

timvp
01-27-2019, 06:39 PM
Eh, I assumed Rudy was going to rest tomorrow, which is why Pop played him so much.I don't buy that excuse, tbh. Gay hasn't purposely been sat on the second game of a back-to-back this season. In fact, he hasn't been rested for any games this seasons. Any games he has missed were due to injury.


Yeah, I'm not sure about the whole Pop critique concerning Gay. The game was still relatively in doubt and it made more sense to keep Gay in than LMA who was already playing a lot of minutes. I like to call out Pop as much as anyone but I can't really blame him for Gay's injury.Even in retrospect a day later, I still agree with my original critique, tbh.

1) Pop has made it a point to play Gay less than 30 minutes, even in tightly contested games. Hell, against the Sixers, Gay played less than he did against the Pelicans. The only games Gay has played more than 30 minutes are tight games against good teams (for the most part, tbh).

2) The game was over. Six minutes to go against a depleted Pelicans team down 20 points? Yeah, there was no way they were coming back. Not really comparable to a fully healthy, explosive Sixers team being down eight points. Maybe that was Pop's thinking too but I disagree.

3) There was a timeout a couple minutes prior to Gay getting hurt and Pop subbed in Walker for Forbes. I was wondering at that point why Walker came in for Forbes and not Gay. If Pop was worried about the 20-point lead, just keep Forbes out there. He can soak up minutes and could help hold off the shell of a team that was New Orleans.

Gay is such a vital part of this team (some posters have said he's the most irreplaceable part -- and that's difficult to disagree with) and he's so injury prone that Pop has to be careful about playing him only needed minutes. He's been really good at that this year until last night. Maybe DeRozan being out and the Sixers game scared him but, IMO, it was the wrong move.


I think your grade on Lonnie was optimistic or at least somewhat misleading.Fair.

I based my expectations off of what I expected from him from watching him play in the G-League. He's been pretty meh on that level given he has a speed and athleticism advantage on everyone and the paint defense is exceptionally weak compared to the NBA.

I gave him a good grade but I don't think he's ready for prime time. I'm not even sure that he's healthy (he doesn't look 100% confident on his leg when I watch him in the G-League). But as a spark when the Spurs are trudging along against a cellar dweller, Walker can play that role already. (Whether having him play that role is better than him getting minutes in the G-League is another question.)


I thought his rebounding was okay. Like it's nice that he got that many, but he didn't attack the glass or anything.Pretty true. I don't remember one that was overly contested.

That said, I thought it was notable that he pulled down five in limited time considering he's been pretty pathetic in that category in the G-League, especially factoring in his athletic advantages.

Walker doesn't need to be a good rebounder to make it in the NBA but it'd be nice if he rebounded better Bryn Forbes, tbh.


Lonnie Walker was getting beat by his man a couple of times so I wouldnt put a grade so high for him


Walker was a turnstile defensively.


When Walker was defending weak side and a big set a screen on him-everytime he got rubbed off on the screen and his man stolled into the paint. LW needs to see that coming and do better-that is really fundamental.

I mean, I agree. But seeing Walker in the G-League where his defense makes Marco Belinelli look like Bruce Bowen had me expecting next to nothing from him at that end. He flashed some ability and seemed to know what to do team-defense-wise ... and that was enough for me to be impressed. He's terrible at getting around screens, true, but it's looking like his horrendous G-League defense is mostly a case of either being cautious about his knee or being disinterested. I suspected it wat probably a mental issue rather than a physical issue but I'm glad we got some small sample size confirmation.


QP looks like a dying deer when he runs. Like I'm always amazed when he does something positive bc he just looks like the most unathletic guy I've ever seen. Just awkward. But I'm glad he did well lolHa, true. Give him credit though, it's a minor miracle he's in the league at this point after what he's gone through physically and the fact that he's on the wrong side of 30.

Pondexter seems to be a great locker room guy, doesn't complain about his role, is at a position of need and stays ready. It'd be more exciting to have a legit prospect at his spot in the roster but Pondexter is fine for a 12th man all things considered. Trading him out for a prospect that needed minutes would probably do more harm than good unless the hypothetical player was better than a player already in the rotation -- and such players are unlikely to be found on the waiver wire.

DAF86
01-27-2019, 08:54 PM
As I mentioned in the trade thread, Pau played well, but the game showed why he's not all that valuable. It's easier than ever to find a center who can score. Gasol adds a whole bunch of intangibles, but he just can't do enough to play with Aldridge against most teams, and I've yet to see him and Poeltl both play well in the same game. The rotation just doesn't seem big enough for three centers. It's gonna be hard for Pau to get his consistent minutes, on the Spurs or anywhere else. He's not a bad player, but he's an awkward one in today's league, and with that contract, that's not a good thing.

How can you, of all people, say that Pau isn't valuable when you think he's a good offensive center and you also think he's a better defensive player than our most impactful defensive player: Poeltl?

In your opinion, Gasol= good on offense, good on defense but still not valuable? :lol

Chinook
01-27-2019, 09:54 PM
How can you, of all people, say that Pau isn't valuable when you think he's a good offensive center and you also think he's a better defensive player than our most impactful defensive player: Poeltl?

In your opinion, Gasol= good on offense, good on defense but still not valuable? :lol

Because homeboy makes a ton of money. Poe doesn't.

DAF86
01-27-2019, 10:05 PM
Because homeboy makes a ton of money. Poe doesn't.

Well, then say that. Don't talk about his game as if that were the reason he isn't valuable. :lol

DAF86
01-27-2019, 10:06 PM
Because homeboy makes a ton of money. Poe doesn't.

Well, then say that. Don't talk about his game as if that were the reason he isn't valuable. :lol

Chinook
01-27-2019, 10:06 PM
Well, then say that. Don't talk about his game as if that were the reason he isn't valuable. :lol

Why not?

DAF86
01-27-2019, 10:08 PM
Why not?

Because you will confuse people and I doubt your goal is to be confusing.

Chinook
01-27-2019, 10:12 PM
Because you will confuse people and I doubt your goal is to be confusing.

Nope, because I already explained what I meant.

DAF86
01-27-2019, 10:23 PM
Nope, because I already explained what I meant.

After somebody quoted you thinking you meant something else. Just saying it would have been better being clearer from the start, tbh.

Chinook
01-27-2019, 10:27 PM
After somebody quoted you thinking you meant something else. Just saying it would have been better being clearer from the start, tbh.

Huh? The first time I said it, I was very direct. You caught it the second time around. Shit, you even saw the first mention, but you were so hung up on me saying Pau was better than Poeltl that you probably didn't actually read anything else.

DAF86
01-27-2019, 10:45 PM
Huh? The first time I said it, I was very direct. You caught it the second time around. Shit, you even saw the first mention, but you were so hung up on me saying Pau was better than Poeltl that you probably didn't actually read anything else.

Dude, it doesn't matter what I got or didn't get in other threads. On this thread you wrote a post saying Pau isn't valuable because of what he does on the floor is supposedly easy to find, you didn't mention anything about his contract.

If you wanted people to get 100% what you were trying to say, you should have wrote something that mentioned his contract. E.G: "Pau isn't valuable because there are a lot of other players that can bring what Pau brings for a lot less money".

Chinook
01-27-2019, 10:50 PM
Dude, it doesn't matter what I got or didn't get in other threads. On this thread you wrote a post saying Pau isn't valuable because of what he does on the floor is supposedly easy to find, you didn't mention anything about his contract.

If you wanted people to get 100% what you were trying to say, you should have wrote something that mentioned his contract. E.G: "Pau isn't valuable because there are a lot of other players that can bring what Pau brings for a lot less money".

You're just mad because you got confused. I referenced that previous post and everything.

DAF86
01-27-2019, 11:10 PM
You're just mad because you got confused. I referenced that previous post and everything.

I'm not mad. I'm just giving you tips to be clearer. You can take them or not, tbh. :lol

DAF86
01-27-2019, 11:30 PM
And on any case, Pau's trade value was never about what he can actually do on a basketball court. No playoff contending team has the cap room to trade for a backup center making 16 millions.

His value always came from the fact that any team trading for him would have 10 millions coming off the books for next season. Now, I have read here somewhere that teams can't really shave those 10 millions trading for him because of I don't know what. If that's true, then yeah, he has no trade value at all.