PDA

View Full Version : Rank these Spur role players in terms of their contribution..



apalisoc_9
08-07-2019, 12:14 PM
For the respective year or years they played during Spurs Championship years.

Nazr Mohammed
Malik Rose
Patty Mills
Tiago Splitter
Brent Barry
Micheal Finley
Speedy Claxton

Chucho
08-07-2019, 12:16 PM
Mills
Splitter
Barry
Findog
Mohammed
Rose
Claxton

mudyez
08-07-2019, 12:39 PM
It would be fun, if every list gets an additional entry...

Mills
Splitter
Barry
Findog
Mohammed
Bonner
Rose
Claxton

RD2191
08-07-2019, 12:54 PM
Why isn't Tony Parker on the list?

Rocalcio
08-07-2019, 01:04 PM
Why isn't Tony Parker on the list?

Cause you know shit about basketball ?

RD2191
08-07-2019, 01:10 PM
Cause you know shit about basketball ?

Who da fook is this guy?

DAF86
08-07-2019, 01:28 PM
For the respective year or years they played during Spurs Championship years.

Nazr Mohammed
Malik Rose
Patty Mills
Tiago Splitter
Brent Barry
Micheal Finley
Speedy Claxton

Without checking the stats I say:

-Splitter
-Rose
-Mohammed
-Barry
-Mills
-Finley
-Claxton

Leetonidas
08-07-2019, 01:34 PM
Barry
Mills
Splitter
Nazr
Rose
Claxton
Finley

KimmyGib
08-07-2019, 01:41 PM
Splitter
Barry
Mills
Nazr
Rose
Finley
Claxton

Drom John
08-07-2019, 01:44 PM
Ignoring the intent of the post, best to worst WS in combined 99, 03, 05, 07 14, regular season and playoffs

76.4 Duncan
42.6 Ginobili
35.7 Parker
19.1 Bowen
17.4 Robinson,D
14.3 Barry
11.2 Horry
10.6 Leonard
10.5 Rose
6.9 Diaw, Splitter
6.7 Belinelli, Mills
6.3 Finley
6.1 Jackson,S, Green
5.8 Elie
5.6 Oberto
5.4 Elliott, Johnson,A
4.3 Nesterovic, Bonner
3.9 Udrih
3.8 Kerr, Brown,D
3.6 Elson
2.9 Joseph
2.7 Jackson,J
2.6 Ayres
2.4 Smith
2.0 Daniels, Claxton
1.9 Willis
1.7 Perdue, Vaughn
1.1 Massenburg
0.8 Mohammed, Baynes
0.7 Kersey, Robinson,G
0.6 Wilks, De Colo
0.3 Ferry, James
0.2 King, Glover, Marks, Williams,E, Daye
0.1 Butler, Jeffers
0.0 Gaze, Williams,B, Johnson,L, Ely, Thomas
-0.2 Bateer, Brown,S

Dex
08-07-2019, 01:45 PM
Barry (integral to 2005 and 2007, veteran who gave up money to come to the Spurs and hit big shots)
Rose (key player on the 1999 and 2003 teams, long-time Spur and was a much-needed weapon against Shaq in that period)
Splitter (major pivot point of the Beautiful Game teams...when he was healthy)
Mills (hit big shots to fuel the 2014 run, especially against Miami. Also a long-standing Spur, for better or worse)
Claxton (huge in the 2003 Finals especially Game 6, Spurs might lose that game if they had to stick with Parker. Speedy didn't do much of note otherwise)
Nazr (was a nice asset to have in 2005, but didn't contribute much outside of that and was over-shadowed by Horry)
Finley (aging veteran who was a solid role-player in 2007, but did more for Dallas than he ever did for SA...then forced his way out when things got tough)

cool cat
08-07-2019, 02:07 PM
Remember Rose abusing Dirk and those Nash/Dirk Mavs teams. Good times...

Chucho
08-07-2019, 02:52 PM
Remember Rose abusing Dirk and those Nash/Dirk Mavs teams. Good times...

I don't recall Rose every abusing anyone. Good lord, I don't think any other player frustrated me more than Malik Rose...Mr. Fucking 3 Seconds with his shit pump fakes after getting an offensive board or ANY time Pop threw him on Shaq- that dude was rocked like 4-5 inches every time Diesel backed him down a step.

I seriously might have hated Malik Rose more than I hated Matt Bonner, and I haven't hated any athlete more than I've hated Matt Bonner. I can't fathom how a more worthless, 1 dimensional sack of shit who NEVER had a big moment when it mattered stayed on the roster so long. It's mind numbing realizing that pud wasted a roster space all those years...

Brazil
08-07-2019, 02:55 PM
Why isn't Kawhi Leonard on the list?

fify faggot

Roscoe P. Coltrane
08-07-2019, 03:02 PM
If we are talking non starters I would put Diaw #1

cool cat
08-07-2019, 03:18 PM
I don't recall Rose every abusing anyone. Good lord, I don't think any other player frustrated me more than Malik Rose...Mr. Fucking 3 Seconds with his shit pump fakes after getting an offensive board or ANY time Pop threw him on Shaq- that dude was rocked like 4-5 inches every time Diesel backed him down a step.

I seriously might have hated Malik Rose more than I hated Matt Bonner, and I haven't hated any athlete more than I've hated Matt Bonner. I can't fathom how a more worthless, 1 dimensional sack of shit who NEVER had a big moment when it mattered stayed on the roster so long. It's mind numbing realizing that pud wasted a roster space all those years...

The guy is immortalized on the '03 championship DVD with the Dallas fan having a conniption.

Dex
08-07-2019, 03:25 PM
I don't recall Rose every abusing anyone. Good lord, I don't think any other player frustrated me more than Malik Rose...Mr. Fucking 3 Seconds with his shit pump fakes after getting an offensive board or ANY time Pop threw him on Shaq- that dude was rocked like 4-5 inches every time Diesel backed him down a step.

I seriously might have hated Malik Rose more than I hated Matt Bonner, and I haven't hated any athlete more than I've hated Matt Bonner. I can't fathom how a more worthless, 1 dimensional sack of shit who NEVER had a big moment when it mattered stayed on the roster so long. It's mind numbing realizing that pud wasted a roster space all those years...

Considering he was massively undersized against Shaq, Rose did about as well as anybody we tried to throw at him outside of Kevin Willis (who also got pushed around). Let's face it...there wasn't anyone who was really going to stop him.

Tim could hold his own, but wasn't given the assignment because he couldn't afford the foul trouble (which was really the only way to slow down prime Shaq)

Chucho
08-07-2019, 04:04 PM
If we are talking non starters I would put Diaw #1

I really can agree with this, but went with the people listed.

FkLA
08-07-2019, 04:35 PM
Is it just me or is 2014 Mills getting overrated? And I'm not just saying because I don't like him now. I don't remember him making any big shots or a game where his contributions were key. His most memorable moments were those threes he hit in Game 5 against the Heatles but by that point the Spurs had already roared back and were up 20+. I think 2015 was by far his best playoffs.

Before reading the responses I honestly thought most lists were going to be similar to mine:

Splitter
Rose
Barry
Mohammed
Finley
Wombat
Claxton

FkLA
08-07-2019, 04:38 PM
Also why is my nigga RD2191 talking to himself? :lol

FkLA
08-07-2019, 04:46 PM
I don't recall Rose every abusing anyone. Good lord, I don't think any other player frustrated me more than Malik Rose...Mr. Fucking 3 Seconds with his shit pump fakes after getting an offensive board or ANY time Pop threw him on Shaq- that dude was rocked like 4-5 inches every time Diesel backed him down a step.

I seriously might have hated Malik Rose more than I hated Matt Bonner, and I haven't hated any athlete more than I've hated Matt Bonner. I can't fathom how a more worthless, 1 dimensional sack of shit who NEVER had a big moment when it mattered stayed on the roster so long. It's mind numbing realizing that pud wasted a roster space all those years...

You're right that he didn't ever abuse anyone but otherwise your way off on Rose, imo.

Matty Ice did have his moment in 2011 but Enrique+RJ ended up fucking it all up:

(1:30)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tSerVBppBgE

timtonymanu
08-07-2019, 05:14 PM
Is it just me or is 2014 Mills getting overrated? And I'm not just saying because I don't like him now. I don't remember him making any big shots or a game where his contributions were key. His most memorable moments were those threes he hit in Game 5 against the Heatles but by that point the Spurs had already roared back and were up 20+. I think 2015 was by far his best playoffs.

Before reading the responses I honestly thought most lists were going to be similar to mine:

Splitter
Rose
Barry
Mohammed
Finley
Wombat
Claxton

That’s exactly my list too. People underrating the Golden God per par. We don’t get through Mavs and he shut LMBeta that entire 2014 series.

FkLA
08-07-2019, 05:28 PM
That’s exactly my list too. People underrating the Golden God per par. We don’t get through Mavs and he shut LMBeta that entire 2014 series.

Yeah, it has to be a memory thing for some of these posters because if you asked this in 2014 the consensus would've been that Splitter was way more valuable than Mills.

timtonymanu
08-07-2019, 05:30 PM
When Bonner was used correctly and not treated as the 2nd big next to Duncan, he did his job fine. Nothing like LMA and his choker moments when he was the 1st/2nd big on the team.

RD2191
08-07-2019, 05:40 PM
Also why is my nigga RD2191 talking to himself? :lol

:pctoss

RD2191
08-07-2019, 05:41 PM
Why isn't Tony Parker on the list?

Maybe my nigga ElNono can answer the question for me?

ElNono
08-07-2019, 08:37 PM
Maybe my nigga ElNono can answer the question for me?

who? the Hornets player?

RD2191
08-07-2019, 08:54 PM
who? the Hornets player?

:lmao :tu

apalisoc_9
08-07-2019, 09:35 PM
Man im just gonna end this manu vs tony debate so people can stop hijacking the the thread.

Manu 03-14 Role player in those two championships
Tony 03 role player in 1 championship out of 4

SpurPadre
08-07-2019, 09:50 PM
If you count farting as a contribution, then it's ok to include Bonner.

Rocalcio
08-08-2019, 07:44 AM
Who da fook is this guy?

A guy who knows a lot about basketball ?

Rocalcio
08-08-2019, 07:48 AM
Also why is my nigga RD2191 (https://www.spurstalk.com/forums/member.php?u=42690) talking to himself? :lol

Schizophrenic idiot...

ZeusWillJudge
08-08-2019, 08:32 AM
Man im just gonna end this manu vs tony debate so people can stop hijacking the the thread.


LOL. You might as well accuse people of wanting to hijack that nasty old Impala sitting up on blocks in your front yard. :lol

KenMcCoy
08-08-2019, 03:56 PM
For the respective year or years they played during Spurs Championship years.

Nazr Mohammed
Malik Rose
Patty Mills
Tiago Splitter
Brent Barry
Micheal Finley
Speedy Claxton

Splitter
Rose
Mills
Barry
Claxton
Finley
Mohammed