2024 QB Rankings

[Millennial_Messiah]

1. Mahomes



2. Burrow
3. Rodgers
4. Stroud
5. Love
6. Herbert
7. Lawrence
8. Jackson
9. Stafford
10. Goff
11. Purdy
12. Allen
13. Tagovailoa
14. Watson
15. Carr
16. Murray
17. Hurts
18. Williams
19. Prescott
20. Wilson
21. Smith
22. Mayfield
23. Jones
24. Richardson
-- and the rest are all backup stopgap types, rookies, or Bryce Young --

[DAF86]

2. Burrow

Get that overrated piece of crap out of there, tbh.

[DAF86]

Heading into the 2024 season:

1-Mahomes












2-Allen


3-Stroud
4-Lamar
5-Herbert
6-Burrow

7-Stafford
8-Hurts
9-Purdy
10-Goff

HM: Tua, Lawrence, Murray.

Wild card: Rodgers.

I wrote this at the end of last season and it holds up pretty well after week 1. I would probably add Dak over Lawrence in the HM, and we have to see how the wild card looks tonight.

[MultiTroll]

This is how far ahead.
1831903953250136219

[Blake]

This is how far ahead.
1831903953250136219

Yeah that was right after he missed his open receiver by 5 yards on the last play

[Will Hunting]

Ive always been a Burrow fan but no way he’s #2 right now. I think like 80+% of his throws yesterday were dump offs within 5 yards of the LOS.

hes always been shitty in September and his receivers are banged up, so it could be different in a few months, but right now idk if he’s even top 5.

[FrostKing]

Bengals have a toxic locker room. The SB run blew up alot of their egos. Mixon took a shot at his former home recently.

[DeadlyDynasty]

I’m a big Stafford guy, and honestly think he belongs in Top 5 tbf

[DAF86]

Joe Oveburrowated snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. Watch the media put the blame anywhere else, though. :lol

If the Bengals had Josh Allen, they might be the team to beat in the NFL, instead of the Chiefs, tbh.

[MultiTroll]

Moar Mahomes greatness.
1835437100277375395

[Thanos]

Breaking News: Jared Goff is still Jared Goff.

lol @ anyone thinking they can win a Super Bowl :lol

current rankings tbh fwiw imho

1. MAGAhomes
2. Allen
3. Stroud
4. Burrow
5. Herbert I guess? Woof we are in a real valley of terrible QB play.

[Darth_Pelican]

Breaking News: Jared Goff is still Jared Goff.

lol @ anyone thinking they can win a Super Bowl :lol

current rankings tbh fwiw imho

1. MAGAhomes
2. Allen
3. Stroud
4. Burrow
5. Herbert I guess? Woof we are in a real valley of terrible QB play.

If this is 2024 rankings, then Carr should be on your list right now.

Passing TD's: 5 (1st)
Yards Per Pass Attempt: 11.4 (1st)
Passer Rating: 142.4 (1st)
QBR: 96.2 (1st)

[FrostKing]

https://i.ibb.co/5F8JPSx/Screenshot-20240917-181920-Chrome.jpg

Speaking of right now. 2nd consecutive subpar season? Turning 29 years old soon. The less he runs, the more he turns the ball over.

[Blake]

https://i.ibb.co/5F8JPSx/Screenshot-20240917-181920-Chrome.jpg

Speaking of right now. 2nd consecutive subpar season? Turning 29 years old soon. The less he runs, the more he turns the ball over.

Yeah when they double team Traylor kelce who is he supposed to throw it to? His top two wide receivers have a combined 1 full year of NFL experience

[MultiTroll]

Yeah when they double team Traylor kelce who is he supposed to throw it to? His top two wide receivers have a combined 1 full year of NFL experience
Will gladly trade you Rashod Bateman for either of them.

[DAF86]

https://i.ibb.co/5F8JPSx/Screenshot-20240917-181920-Chrome.jpg

Speaking of right now. 2nd consecutive subpar season? Turning 29 years old soon. The less he runs, the more he turns the ball over.

Except when it matters most.

[Thanos]

BREAKING NEWS: Derek Carr is still Derek Carr :lol

[Blake]

Will gladly trade you Rashod Bateman for either of them.

K, take Rice

[MultiTroll]

Will gladly trade you Rashod Bateman for either of them.


K, take Rice
Done
Gladly

[MultiTroll]

Breaking News: Jared Goff is still Jared Goff.
https://i.imgflip.com/1w9mwh.jpg

.

[DAF86]

So, let's recount Burrow's game today:

-He throws an interception when the Bengals had the game in the bag.

-He can't do shit with 1:31 to go, 3 timeouts and needing only a FG to win the game in regulation.

-After the Ravens practically gifted them the game in OT, he can't mustard more than 3 fucking yards to get his kicker closer. The bad hold probably doesn't matter if it is a 40 yard kick instead of a 53 yards one. And don't give me the playcalling excuse. You are the QB, you have more than a say in that.

Yet, I just know the narrative tomorrow will be "look at his numbers (without a mention of those coming from him being a YAC merchant), what more can you ask of him?"

And this is exactly why he's the most overrated player in the league. It is not because he's bad, he clearly isn't; but he's more in the 5/6/7 range than the second best, as many people had him when his defense was leading him to the SB.

[DAF86]

Wait, it gets better. The Bengals head coach said that he called a pass and Burrow audibled to a run in that OT series. :lmao

[DAF86]

“We called a pass. Joe (Burrow) actually did a great job getting us out of it back into a run because the look was not there to throw it.”

https://www.google.com/amp/s/syndication.bleacherreport.com/amp/10138342-bengals-zac-taylor-explains-playcalling-before-missed-fg-in-ot-loss-to-ravens.amp.html

[Will Hunting]

Wait, it gets better. The Bengals head coach said that he called a pass and Burrow audibled to a run in that OT series. :lmao
Jesus

[MultiTroll]

Wait, it gets better. The Bengals head coach said that he called a pass and Burrow audibled to a run in that OT series. :lmao

You Burrow Haters are pathetic.

"Joe (Burrow) actually did a great job getting us out of it back into a run because the look was not there to throw it."

[MultiTroll]

He can't do shit with 1:31 to go, 3 timeouts and needing only a FG to win the game in regulation.
He really needed a fake pass interference call or similar bullshit like #1 gets on the regular.
Maybe his line being able to hold at will would also promote Joe.
:rolleyes

[DAF86]

You Burrow Haters are pathetic.

"Joe (Burrow) actually did a great job getting us out of it back into a run because the look was not there to throw it."









I posted that same literal quote one post below. As if that saving face comment would change anything. :lol

[MultiTroll]

Kicker Harrison Butker's Game-Winning Field Goal Comes From 51 Yards Out (chiefs.com) (https://www.chiefs.com/video/harrison-butker-s-game-winning-field-goal-comes-from-51-yards-out)

[MultiTroll]

I posted that same literal quote one post below. As if that saving face comment would change anything. :lol
Your face saving comment or the coaches?

[DAF86]

Your face saving comment or the coaches?

Yours and the coaches. :lol

[MultiTroll]

Yours and the coaches. :lol
I have no idea what you're spinning.

Bottom line what you are attemtpting to fabricate:

Patty gets bailed out by bogus ref calls and record setting FGs = Patty genius.

Joe B gets his team to the same spot -legitimately and without BengalREf- while holder and/or kicker pooch the FG = Joe sucks Patty is great.

[DAF86]

I have no idea what you're spinning.

Bottom line what you are attemtpting to fabricate:

Patty gets bailed out by bogus ref calls and record setting FGs = Patty genius.

Joe B gets his team to the same spot -legitimately and without BengalREf- while holder and/or kicker pooch the FG = Joe sucks Patty is great.

Mahomes is a 3 times SB champion, Burrow is barely over .500 in his career. That's the difference. Burrow needs to do more to get the same benefit of the doubt.

[MultiTroll]

Mahomes is a 3 times SB champion, Burrow is barely over 50% in his career. That's the difference. Burrow needs to do more to get the same benefit of the doubt.
So now calls are based on previous SB experience + Taylor Swift marketing dollars.
Vs fairness.

Head to head Joey B played Mahomes to an absolute tie and pending OT.
We saw the super holds by the square dancing WWE Chief lineman.
Combined with moron Bengals rookie who hit's Mahomes two steps out of bounds.

But somehow that's on Joe.
Wow.

SuperBowl it's be documented. Aaron Donald clearly lines up offside with his helmet eclipsing the ball. Auto 1st down for Joey B and the Bengals with 57 seconds to go on the Rams 40 yard line? Nope, his last name is not Mahomes. No call, Donald gets the *sack*, game over.

RRRRRRaaaagh great plays Patty. You suck Joe.

[DAF86]

So now calls are based on previous SB experience + Taylor Swift marketing dollars.
Vs fairness.

Head to head Joey B played Mahomes to an absolute tie and pending OT.
We saw the super holds by the square dancing WWE Chief lineman.
Combined with moron Bengals rookie who hit's Mahomes two steps out of bounds.

But somehow that's on Joe.
Wow.

SuperBowl it's be documented. Aaron Donald clearly lines up offside with his helmet eclipsing the ball. Auto 1st down for Joey B and the Bengals with 57 seconds to go on the Rams 40 yard line? Nope, his last name is not Mahomes. No call, Donald gets the *sack*, game over.

RRRRRRaaaagh great plays Patty. You suck Joe.


You are the only one talking about calls here. I'm talking about whether or not Burrow deserves the semen shielding he gets.

[Will Hunting]

You Burrow Haters are pathetic.

"Joe (Burrow) actually did a great job getting us out of it back into a run because the look was not there to throw it."








I’m not even trying to hate on Burrow but this statement from the coach was nonsense. Jamar Chase was in man coverage with no safety help over the top and Baltimore was stacking the box against Cinci in OT. Three straight running plays on that drive made no sense.

im also not sure i buy the coach’s story that it was Burrow’s idea to go into cuck mode on that drive. Seems like that’s the last thing a quarterback wants to do.

[DAF86]

I’m not even trying to hate on Burrow but this statement from the coach was nonsense. Jamar Chase was in man coverage with no safety help over the top and Baltimore was stacking the box against Cinci in OT. Three straight running plays on that drive made no sense.

im also not sure i buy the coach’s story that it was Burrow’s idea to go into cuck mode on that drive. Seems like that’s the last thing a quarterback wants to do.

Why would Taylor lie about that, though? That could create animosity from his star QB towards him.

[Will Hunting]

Why would Taylor lie about that, though? That could create animosity from his star QB towards him.
I don't think he'd outright lie but I think he might have been telling half truths about whether Burrow really had total discretion to audible into a run or a pass....like yes, maybe Burrow technically audibled into a run, but it could have been because of an instruction he was given to audible into a running play unless the defense was showing certain opening(s).

[MultiTroll]

I don't think he'd outright lie but I think he might have been telling half truths about whether Burrow really had total discretion to audible into a run or a pass....like yes, maybe Burrow technically audibled into a run, but it could have been because of an instruction he was given to audible into a running play unless the defense was showing certain opening(s).
Joe going into cuck mode and not wanting to pass all three times?

Ya i don't believe that bullshit at all.

[Millennial_Messiah]

You are the only one talking about calls here. I'm talking about whether or not Burrow deserves the semen shielding he gets.

12 TD / 2 INT. Can't argue with his results.

He's had the worst defense and special teams in the league. Don't think Brady wins any of his first three Super Bowls without having both of those components. Holders and kickers who can execute a kick in a Boston blizzard vs. units who bungle that basic operation on a nice warm sunny day.

[DAF86]

12 TD / 2 INT. Can't argue with his results.

He's had the worst defense and special teams in the league. Don't think Brady wins any of his first three Super Bowls without having both of those components. Holders and kickers who can execute a kick in a Boston blizzard vs. units who bungle that basic operation on a nice warm sunny day.

The results are that he's barely above .500 for his career. Way below that these past couple of seasons. His replacement, Browning, has a better record than him.

Again, Burrow is clearly a top 10 QB in the league, maybe even top 5. So don't missinterpret what I'm saying. He's not the unquestionable #2, though. He hasn't prove enough to have that title.

[DAF86]

I'll add you one more thing: it is impossible to prove but I'm sure guys like Mahomes, Allen and Lamar wouldn't be 1-4 right now if they were the QBs of the Bengals.

Mahomes, there's no doubt, he did it for years with the Chiefs before they got a good defense. He'll probably be 4-1 or 5-0.

Allen and Lamar I'm sure that, at the very least, wouldn't have lost to the Pats scoring only 10 pts.

[Millennial_Messiah]

I'll add you one more thing: it is impossible to prove but I'm sure guys like Mahomes, Allen and Lamar wouldn't be 1-4 right now if they were the QBs of the Bengals.

Mahomes, there's no doubt, he did it for years with the Chiefs before they got a good defense. He'll probably be 4-1 or 5-0.

Allen and Lamar I'm sure that, at the very least, wouldn't have lost to the Pats scoring only 10 pts.

Eh. Week 1s and 2s are wonky. Allen lost at home to the pathetic 2021 Stoolers in week 1 2021 with terrible offense despite it being his overall best year in gaudy stats. Lamar lost at home to the putrid Raiders with no QB in week 2 this year. Mahomes lost at home in week 1 last year to Detroit, granted Detroit was a lot better and the drops were the issue on offense not Mahomes. I can't even begin to count how many bad week 1's and 2's guys like Brady and Rodgers had in their primes and ended up winning 12-13 games despite starting 1-2.

Meanwhile, is Jackson even the best black QB in his own state? There might be one in Prince George's County Maryland sitting pretty at 4-1 right now and commanding the division, pun intended.


My current rankings:

1) Mahomes


2) Burrow
3) Goff
4) Stroud
5) Daniels
6) Allen
7) Rodgers
8) Jackson
9) Stafford
10) Herbert


I'm not going to knee jerk reaction to something like Darnold's solid first five weeks, it's week 5 and they're carried by the defense and we've seen Minnesota flame out early before and we know who Darnold is by this point.

On the up since preseason: Daniels, Goff, Mayfield, Darnold, Cousins, you can argue Nix and Fields a bit... also Flacco lol
On the down since preseason: Rodgers, Love, Lawrence, Watson, Richardson, Young... RIP Tagovailoa's career
About the same: Mahomes, Jackson, Stroud, Stafford, Herbert, Williams, Purdy, Prescott... Prescott is basically Black Romo at this point who, (Romo in his prime) was never anywhere near top 10 due to turnovers, injuries, and sacks... but always made for exciting down to the wire games just about every time... even against bad teams.

[FrostKing]

Joe Flacco is still the standard for this position.

Big Ben should come out of retirement.

[MultiTroll]

12 TD / 2 INT. Can't argue with his results.

He's had the worst defense and special teams in the league. Don't think Brady wins any of his first three Super Bowls without having both of those components. Holders and kickers who can execute a kick in a Boston blizzard vs. units who bungle that basic operation on a nice warm sunny day.
But but but Burrow didn't play defense. That's on him.

[Thanos]

Sheesh, DAF hating on Burrow and Brady all the time. I wonder what they have in common?

[Thanos]

Joe Flacco is still the standard for this position.

Big Ben should come out of retirement.
https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/002/577/841/8a2.jpg

[Will Hunting]

Sheesh, DAF hating on Burrow and Brady all the time. I wonder what they have in common?
Thought provoking question!

[DAF86]

Sheesh, DAF hating on Burrow and Brady all the time. I wonder what they have in common?

What do they have in common? :lol

[Thanos]

What do they have in common? :lol
https://media1.tenor.com/m/Imb1cuYYVdEAAAAC/you-know.gif

[DAF86]

https://media1.tenor.com/m/Imb1cuYYVdEAAAAC/you-know.gif

I really don't :lol. They both beat Mahomes in the playoffs? Meh, a concussion beat Mahomes in 2021.

[Thanos]

^he already knew :lmao

[DAF86]

^he already knew :lmao

I really didn't, tbh :lol. I had to think about it and then it hit me.

I really don't think of that game as Burrow beating Mahomes. Mahomes beat himself that day. Josh Allen was way more impressive in any of his loses vs the Chiefs than Burrow on that win, tbh.

[Thanos]

https://media3.giphy.com/media/62aDCkUJ8AogFbqcVV/giphy.gif?cid=6c09b9528jun2iuacj1xa3fqq8jj74vtsr11 2hsenin53yjj&ep=v1_internal_gif_by_id&rid=giphy.gif&ct=g

[MultiTroll]

1. Patty Swift
2. Lamar Jackson
3. Josh Allen
4. Joey Burrow
5. Goff

[DeadlyDynasty]

1. Mahomes
2. Allen
3. Burrow
4. Love
5. Stroud

[MultiTroll]

Herbert might even be top 5. So many drops, such a suck ass organization cost him.

Justin Herbert Breaks Patrick Mahomes' NFL Record During Chargers-Cardinals (https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/justin-herbert-breaks-patrick-mahomes-nfl-record-during-chargers-cardinals/ar-AA1sGTji?ocid=msedgntp&pc=U531&cvid=1d802f72962d43d0b85dcd8615075668&ei=13)

[MultiTroll]

3. Rodgers
Andy did your fat grandma type girlfriend from Wisconsin influence you to vote for Rodgers?

[Millennial_Messiah]

Andy did your fat grandma type girlfriend from Wisconsin influence you to vote for Rodgers?

You mean the 5'10" 125 one from the first half of last year?

https://i.imgur.com/GH1G61k.png
https://i.imgur.com/Kd74CNu.jpg


Yeah, Amanda wasn't my favorite relationship, couldn't cook, didn't work, nothing to write home about in the bedroom compared to some of my previous, but she's the only Wisconsin girl I've been with

[FrostKing]

Josh Allen has yet to throw an INT

:dizzy

[MultiTroll]

You mean the 5'10" 125 one from the first half of last year?

https://i.imgur.com/GH1G61k.png

Yeah, Amanda wasn't my favorite relationship, couldn't cook, didn't work, nothing to write home about in the bedroom compared to some of my previous, but she's the only Wisconsin girl I've been with
Does Amanda have a beard? Kind of looks like a photoshop.
Is that her granddaughter?

[MultiTroll]

Aaron Rodgers suffers hamstring injury (https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/aaron-rodgers-suffers-hamstring-injury/ar-AA1sMV8u?ocid=msedgntp&pc=U531&cvid=69cd4ccc2666414f908a0e0fdb09124f&ei=8)

[Millennial_Messiah]

Does Amanda have a beard? Kind of looks like a photoshop.
Is that her granddaughter?

You're dumber than a box of rocks.

[MultiTroll]

You're dumber than a box of rocks.



3. Rodgers

[DAF86]

2nd best QB in the league on the brink of missing the playoffs in B2B seasons. :lol

And he better thank his defense for saving his ass the previous 2 weeks or else he would already be dead, tbh. :lol

[MultiTroll]

3. Rodgers
https://hollywoodlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/aaron-rodgers-gay-rumors-ftr.jpg?fit=600%2C400&resize=768%2C432

[Brazil]

I was impressed by Goff game against GB tbh.. under really tough conditions, clean passing, good decisions down the stretch, calm and composed.

[Donald Sterling.]

Kermit finally dropped down several spots in the race for MVP with Allen, Jackson and Goff now ahead of him in betting odds.

Frankly it should have happened weeks ago, his numbers are completely average and his td-int ratio is mediocre.

Even TOSB Rodgers has better numbers than Mahomo this season.

[UNT Eagles 2016]

Kermit finally dropped down several spots in the race for MVP with Allen, Jackson and Goff now ahead of him in betting odds.

Frankly it should have happened weeks ago, his numbers are completely average and his td-int ratio is mediocre.

Even TOSB Rodgers has better numbers than Mahomo this season.
Standings.

If they go 17-0 there's no way he doesn't win MVP.


I do agree Goff should be the front runner. I would take Henry over Jackson easily.

[DAF86]

The undisputed 2nd best QB in the entire league, maybe even #1, keeps on losing to the same guy.

[Donald Sterling.]

.

[Donald Sterling.]

The undisputed 2nd best QB in the entire league, maybe even #1, keeps on losing to the same guy.

It's been over a year since Mahomo threw for 400+ yards.

The luxury of having a 1:1 td-int ratio and being carried by the best defense in the league :lol

[DAF86]

It's been over a year since Mahomo threw for 400+ yards.

The luxury of having a 1:1 td-int ratio and being carried by the best defense in the league :lol

Don't worry, whenever Mahomo needs to throw for 400 yds, he will do it, tbh. He probably won't throw 300 yds to the same guy, since he doesn't have that kind of receiver, but he will do it anyways, tbh.

Also, he probably won't lose the game.