PDA

View Full Version : Incumbent senator Gary Peters (D-MI) retires



Millennial_Messiah
01-28-2025, 08:08 PM
Will not run for re-election for 2026. Allows him to be a potential wild card vote in the next couple years. He's been a pretty solid Democrat vote over his two terms.

https://apnews.com/article/gary-peters-michigan-retirement-72fb02bbc816e31f035d797f9185599c


For the Democrats, Whitmer has ruled out running for Senate, as has Debbie Dingell, their probably next-best choice. The favorite right now for the primary is Hillary Scholten. The wild card for both Senate and Governor is Indiana's own Mayor Pothole Pete Buttplug (Buttigieg), who would easily lose any statewide general election for multiple reasons in an increasingly socially moderate state who voted to the right of Ohio and Florida (!) on its recent abortion referendum, and is ranked "considerably" more religious than either of Wisconsin or Pennsylvania.

I'd like to see Lisa McClain re-consider and run for this seat. She's the strongest candidate by far being a house committee member and a born-and-raised Michigander and the open Governor race will also be very competitive if not Lean R in 2026, so, as long as you run someone competent and campaign halfway decently and treat the state like Ohio in the past decade, the GOP can serious turn Michigan into the next 2010s Ohio in 2026 and beyond, considering recent trends. Michigan borders Indiana and Ohio and doesn't have the white progressive base of either Wisconsin or Pennsylvania, at least proportionately. The entire state aside from the area west of Grand Rapids and the Traverse City area is zooming red.

Just don't nominate someone terrible and polarizing like a James Craig, Tudor Dixon, Peter Meijer, Karamo, Upton, or Amash who can alienate a lot of people on either side of the base. Also, no carpetbaggers. It looks like John James wants to run on the GOP side. I don't support that. He's not a terrible candidate but he is a bit of an underperformer in MI-10 and most importantly he's lost twice as challenger for Senate. Third-time rerun candidates who are 0-2 don't have a good track record of winning really in any state for either party.

SnakeBoy
01-28-2025, 09:33 PM
:lmao if it's John James

Millennial_Messiah
01-29-2025, 02:56 PM
:lmao if it's John James

And as bad as running a candidate a third time (to be fair, he didn't do poorly in either given the circumstance of 2018 being a blue wave and 2020 being on the Biden/Trump ticket in COVID) and both times he outperformed the top of the ticket, be it governor or Trump) James actually wouldn't be the worst candidate compared to some of the names floated out there. We definitely don't need a zero-experience podcaster type again.

Looks like Rogers is going to run for governor. Good for him. He lost to Slotkin by 19,000 votes and he's the type of GOP governor Michiganders tend to elect. He'll probably win if he does.

For Senate in MI. My personal first choice is Lisa McClain and has been for awhile, the sucky thing is she's declined multiple times opportunities to run for Senate in the past few years, I hope she changes her mind. Kari Lake did change her mind and it cost us a Senate seat, for worse. With Trump winning AZ by 6% any generic R like Mark Lamb would have won fairly handily. Anyone except Lake.