Anyone watch American Idol?

[adrienne]

Okay...I'm a little embarassed to admit that I hate to miss this show. But I just have to say, as far as this year goes....I want to have Ace's babies. He's just so pretty. Our children would be gorgeous.

I was going to post a picture of him, but he apparantly is not photogenic...so much more beautiful on TV.

Oh, and I also have a soft spot for the precious younguns, Will Makar and David Radford. And I think Kellie Pickler is adorable, and absolutely gorgeous.

[Spurminator]

I think Ace will probably win but I'm rooting for Chris Daughtry.

[adrienne]

I love Chris's voice...if he had a CD I think I'd probably buy it, whether he wins or not.

[Big Worm]

http://theoneboard.com/board/viewtopic.php?t=14386

[DeeBo]

Take away the past show winners? This season has the best talent ever, I don't know how they are going to pick a winner this year.

It's all about Gimmicks if you ask me. Think about it. we are a in a Brokeback mode right now. If that little Cowboy dude would have made the top 12 he would be a hit singing Dancing queen,

That black guy who sang "Shout"? will get more votes than the computer geek before him who sang that song from the 1940s

I will admit the guy with down syndrome who sang Barry Mannilow's "LOLA"? he was not that great.

If anyone who is reading this topic hates this show at least tune in to see this dude who looks like the ex singer from Doobie Brothers

http://www.gocontinental.com/photos3/mcdona~1.jpg

[Spurminator]

One other predicition, she may not sing very well but Brenna is going to get a job in Television the instant she gets voted off.

[tlongII]

Gay Forum.

No offense to gayABC.

[Horry For 3!]

I listened the other night to like the last 2 girls. That very last girl who sang was really good.

[ShoogarBear]

Proud to say I have never wasted a moment of my life watching this show.

[Spurminator]

Here you go Tlong...

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/heather.jpg

Heather Cox.

[Spurminator]

Proud to say I have never wasted a moment of my life watching this show.

I make compromises to view shows my wife likes, but I find myself sucked in by some of them.

Thankfully, I still haven't gotten into Desperate Housewives or those godawful home design shows...

[Guru of Nothing]

I prefer music with musical instruments.

American Idol is not far removed from yodeling, except that yodeling is a little more dignified.

[tlongII]

Here you go Tlong...

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/heather.jpg

Heather Cox.


I'd hit it.


but I still wouldn't watch that show.

[Tonto]

Proud to say I have never wasted a moment of my life watching this show.


http://www.theworriedshrimp.com//denial.jpg

[ShoogarBear]

American Idol is not far removed from yodeling, except that yodeling is a little more dignified.:lol

[ZStomp]

http://www.kelliefans.com/gallery/data/508/medium/k_pickler_ai5_audition_full_vinman_pic3.JPG

She's hot! But won't win.

Here is the winner. Mark it down.

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/paris.jpg

Bank it!!

[Horry For 3!]

http://img240.imageshack.us/img240/4020/katharine7hj.jpg
^^^ She has the best voice on American Idol

[IceColdBrewski]

I make compromises to view shows my wife likes, but I find myself sucked in by some of them.

That's how I got suckered in. Very first season, I had seen the previews leading up to it, and was like, "no fucking way." Then the wife begged me to watch it with her. I was annoyed of course. But I figured I'd sit through one episode with her, tell her it sucked, and never have to endure it again. But 5 minutes into the show, this Simon guy has some of these no-talent brats crying with his insults. And of course, I'm loving every minute of that shit. The arguements they aired between Simon and the try-outs were classic. I was in tears I was laughing so hard. I guess that's what Simon had planned all along. Bastard.

I'm hoping the guy with the grey hair wins it this year. That guy is one cool cat.

[ZStomp]

http://img240.imageshack.us/img240/4020/katharine7hj.jpg
^^^ She has the best voice on American Idol


She has a great voice.

She is so pretty.

Reminds me of a thicker Katie Holmes

[Silver21_Black20]

:lol

You watch American Idol Z?

[Kdfelicity]

David Radford is all I gotta say...(see Hot Guy pics thread)

[ZStomp]

:lol

You watch American Idol Z?


Shhhh!

[Silver21_Black20]

She has a great voice.

She is so pretty.

Reminds me of a thicker Katie Holmes

Everyone reminds you of Katie Holmes :lol

[Trainwreck2100]

Whoever wins won't go on to do shit. Cept bone the other idols when they have that stupis ass tour.

[ZStomp]

David Radford is all I gotta say...(see Hot Guy pics thread)

Fortunately, they base the show on voice talent and not looks. Not that he would win on that anyway.


Whoever wins won't go on to do shit. Cept bone the other idols when they have that stupis ass tour.

Who cares

[Kdfelicity]

Fortunately, they base the show on voice talent and not looks.

That's not hard to see after Ruben won...

David's got the "Bub"(Michael Buble) factor, that's really what makes him most appealing, to me any way.

[angel_luv]

I have been wanting to watch but some emergency has kept coming up every time I try. Maybe next episode.

I like American Idol but I'm much more excited about Prison Break coming back on next month.

[ZStomp]

That's not hard to see after Ruben won...

David's got the "Bub"(Michael Buble) factor, that's really what makes him most appealing, to me any way.

What?

Ruben could sing!!

[Horry For 3!]

That's not hard to see after Ruben won...

David's got the "Bub"(Michael Buble) factor, that's really what makes him most appealing, to me any way.
You like the kid that is like 16 or 17? :lol

[Horry For 3!]

David Radford is all I gotta say...(see Hot Guy pics thread)
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/david_radford/


He is goofy lookin and has a strange voice too. Way different from what I have heard before.

[Horry For 3!]

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/will_makar/

This kid is from The Woodlands, TX


I lived 30 mins from The Woodlands a couple of years ago.

[ChumpDumper]

I admit it.

I watched that Aussie chick snap her MCL on the ski jump and her shrieking reminded me, "Oh yeah, when is Idol on?"

[SpursWoman]

I think Ace will probably win but I'm rooting for Chris Daughtry.


:tu

[SpursWoman]

But 5 minutes into the show, this Simon guy has some of these no-talent brats crying with his insults. And of course, I'm loving every minute of that shit. The arguements they aired between Simon and the try-outs were classic. I was in tears I was laughing so hard. I guess that's what Simon had planned all along. Bastard.

This season was the first I've ever watched it ... it started when I was channel surfing and waiting for a Spurs game to come on and I just left it on that channel. The original auditions are by far the best part of the show. Do some of those motherfuckers really think they can sing? Who has been lying their ass off to these people? :wow :lmao

[SpursWoman]

And BTW, if you ever have two 10 year old girls at your house bored out of their minds because it's cold & rainy outside, just pop in then "The Best of the Worst" of American Idol and they will be hysterical a few solid hours. :wow :lol

[ShoogarBear]

This season was the first I've ever watched it ... it started when I was channel surfing and waiting for a Spurs game to come on and I just left it on that channel.

Wait . . .you missed a Spurs game for American Idol? :spin

Oh, please let that be true. We'd never think of holding it over you. /SequBowling

[angel_luv]

I think I remember the time she is talking about and that we were chatting online.
If it is the time I am thinking of Idol was on the hour before the Spurs. I remember watching all of both Idol and the game

[mouse]

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/paris.jpg





http://media.mnginteractive.com/media/paper210/061105_coleman.jpg






http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/gary-Idol.jpg

[SpursWoman]

Wait . . .you missed a Spurs game for American Idol? :spin

Oh, please let that be true. We'd never think of holding it over you. /SequBowling


No ... American Idol comes on at 7:00, I believe that particular game didn't start until 8:00ish...so I DVR'd the end of AI. Sorry. :lol :makeout

[SpursWoman]

I think I remember the time she is talking about and that we were chatting online.
If it is the time I am thinking of Idol was on the hour before the Spurs. I remember watching all of both Idol and the game


Yes, that was it. :lol :lol



















*thanks for the back-up* :lmao

[mouse]

I have all shows on VHS, if you have some blank VHS tapes call me.
561-9941

[SpursWoman]

I think Ace will probably win but I'm rooting for Chris Daughtry.


Funny thing about this guy ... we were watching when it was his turn and they did the little biography on him and thought it was really weird, in a coincidental kind of way....that his name is Chris, that he married a girl a little older than him and became an awesome stepdad to her two kids. :spin

[SpursWoman]

I have all shows on VHS, if you have some blank VHS tapes call me.
561-9941

I wish I would have know that before I went and bought the box set so I could catch up. :depressed :oops

[mouse]

How can there be a Box set if the show just started last week?

[TOP-CHERRY]

hi mouse.

[mouse]

hi mouse.


Was Sup?
Nice sig who made it?

I have the original show were William Hung made his first debut on American Idol.

I remember the first thing I said after he was only 15 seconds into his song. I said this guy is going to be famous. everyone in my trailer that night said I was crazy,


If you order mouse's American Idol box set I might toss it in as a bonus,


But wait! theres more.............

[TOP-CHERRY]

Katyon6th made it. Ain't she just the talented type.

[SpursWoman]

How can there be a Box set if the show just started last week?


Seasons 1-4. :lol

It's not every complete episode, so that sucked....although I finally got to find out who William Hung is/was. :fro :lmao

[Looter]

I finally got to find out who William Hung is/was. :fro :lmao

So was he?

[SpursWoman]

I have no idea...they must have edited that part out. :)

[ShoogarBear]

everyone in my trailer that night said I was crazy,


So, it was just like every other night.

[mouse]

So, it was just like every other night.

Except for Sundays when I let Black folks come over

[Old School Chic]

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/paris.jpg





http://media.mnginteractive.com/media/paper210/061105_coleman.jpg






http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/gary-Idol.jpg

:lol That's his daughter... I thought you knew that by now.

[Silver21_Black20]

:lol That's his daughter... I thought you knew that by now.

Is she really his daughter?

[Horry For 3!]

Is she really his daughter?
No :lol

[Silver21_Black20]

No :lol

Oh...cause I see the resemblance...thanks to mouse :lol

[Big Worm]

I at first thought gawd damn they're lip syncing .


People still do that?

Sincerly:

http://cache.eonline.com/Gossip/Answer/Images/210.simpson.ashlee.020305.jpg

[Kahn Souphanousinphone]

They need to bring back William Hung, us Asians show you Hillabilly's how to sing

[adrienne]

I'm pretty sure I orgasmed watching this last night. (http://youtube.com/watch?v=PM86PK0rJ8M&search=ace%20young)

[SpursWoman]

That one almost got me in trouble last night ... I managed to settle for making eyes at my daughter. :lol :nerd

[ZStomp]

What about the guys?

The Leno look a like.


http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/taylor.jpg
He's unique and he rocks!

[SpursWoman]

I like him ... and I think it's great that he's comfortable with himself, but I have a hard time believing that anyone under 28 years old really prefers looking like they are 50. That blows me away. I'd be all over Clairol for Men. :lol

He's a great singer, though. :)

[adrienne]

http://youtube.com/watch?v=bstEk8gH5n0&search=ace%20young :smokin

[desflood]

Ace - that boy is HOT. But a little young for me. So, I'm rooting for Paris and Taylor.

[Looter]

http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/taylor2.jpg

[Spam]

Jay Leno is on American Idol?

[Sonia_TX]

Okay...I'm a little embarassed to admit that I hate to miss this show. But I just have to say, as far as this year goes....I want to have Ace's babies. He's just so pretty. Our children would be gorgeous.

I was going to post a picture of him, but he apparantly is not photogenic...so much more beautiful on TV.

Oh, and I also have a soft spot for the precious younguns, Will Makar and David Radford. And I think Kellie Pickler is adorable, and absolutely gorgeous.


Here you go! :)

http://i44.photobucket.com/albums/f26/idolrecaps/5x10/1029.jpg

[Looter]

http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/cute.jpg

[adrienne]

He's so gorgeous. Seriously, it's not good for me, I have such dirty thoughts watching him...the first thing to cross my mind when he sang "I'll be your daddy" was "you can be MY daddy..."

[Looter]

http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/cute2.jpg

[adrienne]

Yes, I would probably feel good messing up pictures of Jessica Alba too, but that doesn't mean she's not hot.:)

[SpursWoman]

Yes, I would probably feel good messing up pictures of Jessica Alba too, but that doesn't mean she's not hot.:)


^5 :spin

[Mixability]

Yes, I would probably feel good messing up pictures of Jessica Alba too, but that doesn't mean she's not hot.:)

you could put Barbara Walters face on her body and most of the guys here would still hit it. :lol

[Kdfelicity]

What?

Ruben could sing!!


I was referring to looks and how it's easy to see that they don't focus on that after Ruben won.

[Kdfelicity]

You like the kid that is like 16 or 17? :lol


Hell yes.

[angel_luv]

How did they manage to not advance any good looking guys? Ace has nice eyes but besides that :sleep

[spurs=bling]

How did they manage to not advance any good looking guys? Ace has nice eyes but besides that :sleep
sway is good looking

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/jose.jpg

[angel_luv]

Darn it. I kind of liked Patrick. I didn't hear any of the other auditions though so maybe he did deserve to go.

[ShoogarBear]

I bet you guys watch that "Dancing and Skating with Jerry Rice" shit, too.

[angel_luv]

I bet you guys watch that "Dancing and Skating with Jerry Rice" shit, too.


Only because I am too lazy to get up and go change the channel. :lol

[spurs=bling]

I bet you guys watch that "Dancing and Skating with Jerry Rice" shit, too.
not me

[adrienne]

Ace just has nice eyes? Am I crazy or something? Because I think I would do just about anything if he asked...okay, anything...

http://aceyoung.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10001/normal_acebts6.jpg

[adrienne]

Darn it. I kind of liked Patrick. I didn't hear any of the other auditions though so maybe he did deserve to go.

He didn't necessarily deserve to go, but he was pretty much the only one that didn't have either an outstanding peformance on Wednesday or some special likability factor.

[ShoogarBear]

He looks like a hairier, more rodent-like version of Keanu.

[Horry For 3!]

sway is good looking

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/jose.jpg
:lol

[adrienne]

Shoogar, watch the clips I posted. Maybe you'll understand more.:)

[ShoogarBear]

Uhhhhhh, okay if I pass? I'll take your word for it. :lol

[Looter]

http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/chino3.jpg

[spurs=bling]

:lol

what ever :rolleyes

[Summers]

How did they manage to not advance any good looking guys? Ace has nice eyes but besides that :sleep

Oh, good, it's not just me! He's cute, but that thing he does after every song (that "look at how pretty I am!" stare) is going to get old fast.

And on that note, I think I'm in love with Taylor Hicks. :lol

[Horry For 3!]

Oh, good, it's not just me! He's cute, but that thing he does after every song (that "look at how pretty I am!" stare) is going to get old fast.

And on that note, I think I'm in love with Taylor Hicks. :lol
I could be on there

[Horry For 3!]

I'd be like I dedicate this song to the Blow & Hand Job Girl!

[adrienne]

He's cute, but that thing he does after every song (that "look at how pretty I am!" stare)

Maybe I don't mind it because when he's thinking "look how pretty I am!" I'm thinking "look how pretty he is!"


I'd be like I dedicate this song to the Blow & Hand Job Girl!

I don't get it.

[SpursWoman]

Ace just has nice eyes? Am I crazy or something? Because I think I would do just about anything if he asked...okay, anything...

http://aceyoung.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10001/normal_acebts6.jpg


He looks like Keanu Reeves in that picture. No, you're not crazy. :tu :tu

[SpursWoman]

I bet you guys watch that "Dancing and Skating with Jerry Rice" shit, too.




I watched that skating thing afterwards .... I didn't like it. Was that supposed to be an insult?

[ShoogarBear]

I watched that skating thing afterwards .... I didn't like it. Was that supposed to be an insult?

Nope. I hold shows like "Prancing with the Washed-Up Celebrities" in the highest regard.

[angel_luv]

Ace just has nice eyes? Am I crazy or something? Because I think I would do just about anything if he asked...okay, anything...

http://aceyoung.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10001/normal_acebts6.jpg


I guess he's pretty. But I prefer more manly, handsome guys.

Shut up, Bear! :lol

[ShoogarBear]

But I prefer more manly, handsome guys.

Bolts in the neck being a plus?

[SpursWoman]

:drunk

[tlongII]

I watched Dancing with the Stars last night. Stacy Keibler is HOT!

[adrienne]

I think what did it for me was in his interview talking about how he's a sports junkie. He played football. That's manly enough for me...and he's just still so pretty...

[angel_luv]

Bolts in the neck being a plus?

Better than having a few screw loose. You should know that. :angel

[ShoogarBear]

Better than having a few screw loose. You should know that. :angel

Owwwwwww!

[angel_luv]

I'm just kidding, Bear. You good ( looking, even) people. :D

[SpursWoman]

I think what did it for me was in his interview talking about how he's a sports junkie. He played football. That's manly enough for me...and he's just still so pretty...


I have no idea why you guys seem to think he looks pretty/feminine. I don't see that at all.

:fro

[SpursWoman]

I'd imagine the quality would be a lot better if they were lip-syncing. I've seen too many of them fuck up pretty badly to believe that.

:fro

[Sonia_TX]

A friend of mine went to the taping of the show and said that Ace is even hotter in person. Lucky bitch.

[Horry For 3!]

I don't get it.
That was towards Summers.

[Summers]

I'd be like I dedicate this song to the Blow & Hand Job Girl!

Aww! That's so sweet. But, really, you don't have to do that. :lol

[Summers]

Maybe I don't mind it because when he's thinking "look how pretty I am!" I'm thinking "look how pretty he is!"


:lol

[Horry For 3!]

Aww! That's so sweet. But, really, you don't have to do that. :lol
:)

[adrienne]

Good news. Ace is straight. And single. I think I should go for it....think I have a shot? :angel

[angel_luv]

Good news. Ace is straight. And single. I think I should go for it....think I have a shot? :angel


Go girl! :angel

[adrienne]

I'm not sure I have the moves. :lol I can see it going something like this...

"I uh....saw you on American Idol. Thought you were pretty sexy."
*Ace stares, confused*
"Umm..yeah...so...you're...single....?"
*Ace starts to walk away*
"Wait!"
*Adrienne panics, flashes Ace.*

[ZStomp]

I'm not sure I have the moves. :lol I can see it going something like this...

"I uh....saw you on American Idol. Thought you were pretty sexy."
*Ace stares, confused*
"Umm..yeah...so...you're...single....?"
*Ace starts to walk away*
"Wait!"
*Adrienne panics, flashes Ace.*


:wow

[Sonia_TX]

I was friends with someone that was on Idol season 1...but he and I got in to an argument so we don't speak anymore (as of a few months ago). I would have hooked you up (ok after I hooked myself up! lol jk)

[Kdfelicity]

http://www.boomspeed.com/woaimouse/chino3.jpg


He lookes like that guy on Austin Powers that throws the shoe.

[Horry For 3!]

What tha fuck is this song that Ace is singing? Whatever it is, he is singing horribly. :vomit

[T Park]

Gedeon and I thought Elliott were great tonight.

Rocky sucks to high heaven, why the FUCK that moron is STILL on is beyond me.

the 16 year old dork blew it with another old song.

Ace, well, he will stay on only because he has looks.

Will, the guy from Houston, was OK, nothing great.


If I were to vote two off, it would be Rocky, and and Kevin.


That simple.

[MaNuMaNiAc]

Is it me, or does Will look too much like Fred Savage when he was young?

[SpursWoman]

Gedeon and I thought Elliott were great tonight.

Rocky sucks to high heaven, why the FUCK that moron is STILL on is beyond me.

the 16 year old dork blew it with another old song.

Ace, well, he will stay on only because he has looks.

Will, the guy from Houston, was OK, nothing great.


If I were to vote two off, it would be Rocky, and and Kevin.


That simple.

You mean Bucky? I don't like him...I like the bald guy. :fro

[T Park]

The bald guy tonight, was OK.

Not his best performance.

His best performance was the Bon Jovi song by far.

Last week's Fuel song was cool but a bit edgy.


This week was kind of, scratchy.


Bucky sucks to high heaven.

Sway was better than him IMO.

[Horry For 3!]

Yeah, I don't get how that Bucky guy is still on. He sucks.

[T Park]

If it was up to me,

Bucky and Ace would be tossed.

Ace sings like a bad Prince backup singer.

[Duff McCartney]

No.

[Sonia_TX]

My predictions for who is going home tonight:

Girls : Lisa and Kinnik
Boys: Gideon and Kevin

[SpursWoman]

Girls: Lisa and Kinnik
Boys: Bobby Brady & Kevin :lol

[desflood]

You mean Bucky? I don't like him...I like the bald guy. :fro
Chris :tu He's married. What a waste of a good man :lol

[adrienne]

I don't think Will will go home...the 14-year-old girl fanbase will keep him in it for a while.

If I had it my way...the girls to go home would be Kinnik and Melissa. The guys will be Gedeon and maybe Kevin...

[adrienne]

So Kinnik and Ayla, Gedeon and Will go home tonight.

Top 12/ "Finalists":

Ace Young
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/ace.jpg
Taylor Hicks
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/taylor.jpg
Kevin Covais
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/kevin.jpg
Chris Daughtry
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/chris.jpg
Bucky Covington
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/bucky.jpg
Elliott Yamin
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/elliott.jpg

Katherine McPhee
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/katharine.jpg
Kellie Pickler
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/kellie.jpg
Lisa Tucker
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/lisa.jpg
Paris Bennett
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/paris.jpg
Mandisa
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/mandisa.jpg
Melissa McGhee
http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/t/melissa.jpg

[T Park]

Bucky Covington staying, and Gideon going home, is the biggest piece of shit bullshit Ive ever seen on TV in my life.

I just might stop watching after tonight.


Tonight proved, that the people that vote on this show, are dumber than fucking snot.

[T Park]

If I had it my way...the girls to go home would be Kinnik and Melissa. The guys will be Gedeon and maybe Kevin...



Gedeon?!?!

He had 20 billion times, the singing talent that that redneck goat herder Bucky does, and he goes home and that walking stereotype stays!??!?


People mightve been right a couple years ago when they said the voting is racist.

[adrienne]

Wow, Katherine looked gorgeous at the Top 12 party....she's a beautiful girl.

http://www.upload2.com/files/thumbnails/d5ace54128e23fe366f6b91595c1d64e.jpg (http://www.upload2.com/?cmd=_viewer&file=d5ace54128e23fe366f6b91595c1d64e.jpg&s=file-upload)
http://www.upload2.com/files/thumbnails/728864b9502584189719dd694b7d0442.jpg (http://www.upload2.com/?cmd=_viewer&file=728864b9502584189719dd694b7d0442.jpg&s=file-upload)

[Horry For 3!]

Wow, Katherine looked gorgeous at the Top 12 party....she's a beautiful girl.

http://www.upload2.com/files/thumbnails/d5ace54128e23fe366f6b91595c1d64e.jpg (http://www.upload2.com/?cmd=_viewer&file=d5ace54128e23fe366f6b91595c1d64e.jpg&s=file-upload)
http://www.upload2.com/files/thumbnails/728864b9502584189719dd694b7d0442.jpg (http://www.upload2.com/?cmd=_viewer&file=728864b9502584189719dd694b7d0442.jpg&s=file-upload)
I picked her to win it all at the very beginning.

[Sonia_TX]

^^ Katharine is my favorite contestant but I don't think she'll win. I think Chris will win since most people seem to love him. I don't like him then again I didnt like Bo last season and most people did. Kath will be in the final 2 though (IMO).

[MoSpur]

Kevin in the top 12 is a shock. I don't think Kevin has more talent and "star" quality than Gedeon.

[Sonia_TX]

Kevin should have been gone. I liked Gedeon's voice but I thought he was just creepy. I couldn't tell if he was putting on an act or if that is the way he really spoke. It was just odd.

I think it should have been Kevin/Will or Kevin/Gedeon.

[Spurminator]

Gedeon was the third best male in the group.

[T Park]

Gedeon had the best voice of all the guys.

ALL OF THEM.


Kevin even has a great voice, he just hasn't picked good songs.

Bucky sucks ass, and NO ONE ELSE SAYS THIS!?!?!?!?

ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?!?!?!?

[adrienne]

Gedeon was just creepy somehow to me. I can't explain it, he had a good voice and all but something rubbed me the wrong way. Obviously it was the same with some others, and that IS a problem. American Idol isn't just a voice competition, they have to be likable.



Tonight was pretty boring IMO. Katherine was good (and gorgeous), Kellie looked beautiful (Simon's a jerk) but not too good vocally, and I still think Elliott has the best voice. I'm a big Elliott fan.

[SpursWoman]

I still {heart} Chris. :)

[MaNuMaNiAc]

Is it me, or is Paula REALLY ANNOYING AS HELL!! She NEVER says anything different, its always "oh you're unique", "you always choose the right songs", "i'm beside myself", "I love you". She is so fucking false its disgusting. I like Randy and Simon because at least the have something original to say. Simon, to me, is the most truthfull.

[SpursWoman]

She is terrible ... and botoxed and tranquilized from hell. :wow :lol

[MaNuMaNiAc]

She is terrible ... and botoxed and tranquilized from hell. :wow :lol
seriously http://spurstalk.com/forums/images/smilies/smilol.gif

[angel_luv]

:wow about first one in bottom three!

Don't want to ruin it in case anyone Tivo-ed it.

[ZStomp]

Pretty boy Ace could be on the way out!

[angel_luv]

Why is Americal voting off the pretty people?

Chicken Little beat Ace? Seriously?

[ZStomp]

It's not about looks Angel!

besides those teeny boppers sure can use phones/cell phones!!

My favs: Paris, Taylor, and McPhee :makeout

http://www.idolonfox.com/contestants/i/f/katharine.jpg

[angel_luv]

I don't think Chicken Little can sing... do you?

[T Park]

Kevin can sing better than Ace, thats for one reason why.

Ace is only still there because he has looks.


And btw



WHY THE FUCK IS BUCKY STAYING THE FUCK ON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

HE FUCKING SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[T Park]

oh god angel.

Look past the goddamn looks, and look at talent.

Ace is a high pitched underwear model, and Kevin is the guy who has talent, but not the looks.


Look at talent for once.

[ZStomp]

I don't think Chicken Little can sing... do you?

Not any better than Ace or vice versa...i say get rid of both of them!

[ZStomp]

Happy Angel?

He's 'safe'...he won't win it though.

Bank it.

Paris will win it. I called it the frist time I saw her audition.

[angel_luv]

I don't like the kid's voice. For me C.L. has nothing to recommend him.

At least Ace is easier on the eyes. Note I do not find him at all hot.

As for the girls I haven't yet been able to hear them sing.

[adrienne]

Ace is a high pitched underwear model

In a perfect world. :eyebrows

I actually kind of like Bucky. I like his voice. He's not necessarily right for the competition, but he can sing (in his genre) and seems like a really, really, really nice guy.

By the way, Paris will not win...it's Katherine.

[T Park]

I like his voice

you

like

THAT!!?!?


HE CANT SING!!!

HE SCREAMS AND SCRATCHES


HE cant fucking sing?!?!?!


no wonder this country is going down the shitter.


People actually think Bucky can freakin sing.


Gideon has 50 billion times the talent than that tall long haired rednecked Hayseed.

[Marklar MM]

Have they all been eliminated yet? Please say yes.

[adrienne]

Yes, I do like it. I'm not saying he's Pavoratti. I didn't like when he sang simple man because he forced it too much, but when he actually sings, I enjoy his voice.

[T Park]

omg.

oh my fucking god.....

[adrienne]

Did you have a hard day T Park? You seem a little fussy. :bang

[T Park]

No.

Not at all.

Just getting through another kidney stone thats all.


But Im just flabbergasted that someone from this board,

cause 95% of this board is intelligent, and you are a smart pretty girl adrienne.

Im just flabbergasted that you like that backwards hippie hayseed.

[angel_luv]

Obviously she is not the only fan of his seeing as he was safe.

[Sonia_TX]

Katharine or Chris will win.

[T Park]

Angel,

hence my point, that our country is going right down the shitter.

[Jekka]

Angel,

hence my point, that our country is going right down the shitter.

And your contribution to a "higher" culture is what?

I'm not even necessarily being cheeky - I'd honestly like to know when the last time was that you went to an art gallery, or to see a modern dance company, or to the symphony.

[T Park]

Went to the symphony in July with my ex fiance.

I thought it was cool.

I love music, so it was neat.


With her gone, lets just say symphonies are kinda sore subject.

[SpursWoman]

But Im just flabbergasted that someone from this board,

cause 95% of this board is intelligent, and you are a smart pretty girl adrienne.

Im just flabbergasted that you like that backwards hippie hayseed.


He's not as bad as having to suffer through listening to a 16 year old nerd singing about being a part time lover. I realize the whole "Lucas" thing gets a lot of people, apparently...but there aren't that many stars that can get away with not having a certain *look* or at least something that they find attractive. Sucks, but it's true.

That's why I was surprised that Ace was in the bottom 3 ... that he'd garner more of the female vote. I don't think he's that great at all, except for that first performance...but I guess the women voting aren't as shallow as the men...which would explain why Kellie Pickler is there...she's terrible. :vomit

[danyel]

Angel,

hence my point, that our country is going right down the shitter.

Sure, the country is going down the shitter because Bucky was safe...

Its not a show about who has the best voice or who perfoms better, its about who gets the more votes.

Seriously, he's alright, not that bad as you make him sound, but he and Kevin should have been in the bottom 3 with Melisa.

[angel_luv]

Okay, I decided today that Taylor has a handsome face. I still don't like the gray hair though.

I also think that Paula is way too biased in the guys favor.

[SpursWoman]

Paula is hammered. :drunk

Again.



So far it's been pretty weak....

[angel_luv]

Mandisa has soul. I got the vibe though that the judges didn't like that she chose such a Christian song.

Katherine is my favorite so far.

[SpursWoman]

She's awesome ... but I don't know about that song. Not because it's a Christian....it was kind of scream-y.

*shrugs*

[SpursWoman]

Just like Chris' was ... :depressed

[angel_luv]

She's awesome ... but I don't know about that song. Not because it's a Christian....it was kind of scream-y.

*shrugs*


I have heard better versions of that song so I didn't care so much about them saying she sang badly.

But all the references to church and it being a " personal" song- were over the line, I thought.

[Horry For 3!]

All of them has sucked except Kathrine.

Ace was the worst. He shouldn't even be on right now, he is only on cause of his looks which I don't get how because he can't sing worth shit.

[ZStomp]

It's sucking ASS tonight!!

[spurs=bling]

i haven't seen it in awhile.

[angel_luv]

Elliot.. ouch! :td

[Horry For 3!]

Me = :tu

[SpursWoman]

I can honestly say that all of them sucked equally tonight. :vomit

[spurs=bling]

Me = :tu
why aren't you there?

[Sonia_TX]

She's awesome ... but I don't know about that song. Not because it's a Christian....it was kind of scream-y.

*shrugs*
I actually love that original version of that song and probably listen to it about every day. I wasn't a fan of Mandisas version tonight though.

Chris shouted the whole time. Blech.

Katharine was great as usual.

Lisa will probably go home after that performance. She's nowhere near as good as Kelly.

Angel, I agree with the comment about Taylors face. He is a good looking man.

[T Park]

Ace was the best of the night :eek

Elliot was great, but, that dancing, WTF was that?!!?

Kelly Pickler wasn't bad, of course, singing a country song in front of all the pop people is just horrible so they HAD to shoot her down.

Lisa was fantastic!

Mandisa's worst performance.

Bucky's BEST, didn't hurt that it was one of my favorite songs from Tim Mcgraw ;)

Paris's performance was good, but Simon was right, it sounded like a kid trying to be like Beyonce.

all in all prob the worst show so far :lol

[T Park]

Chris shouted the whole time. Blech.



Yeah he took that song too harsh.

The original, if sang just a tick softer, is one hell of a rock song.

Of course my parents who I watched it with thought it was reprehensible.

I thought it was decent.

But not Chris's best.

[SpursWoman]

Kelly Pickler wasn't bad, of course, singing a country song in front of all the pop people is just horrible so they HAD to shoot her down.

No, it was a "Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer" song ... those kinds of songs make country look stupid. :lol

Bucky was actually decent this time...but not really good

Lisa was terrible ... I was constantly comparing it to Kelly Clarkson and it was like 165465132465 X worse. It'd be like choosing a Celine Dion or Mariah Carey song ... you have to be flawless to even appear decent.

I have to go back and watch Elliott .... I was watching Dallas v. Detroit and missed it.

:fro

[Horry For 3!]

why aren't you there?
I am, you didn't know that?

[T Park]

No, it was a "Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer" song

it was not.

Its a spunky love song.


Grandma got run over by a reindeer come on.

[SequSpur]

Mandisa sucks.

[SpursWoman]

it was not.

Its a spunky love song.


Grandma got run over by a reindeer come on.


Seriously...it was a goofy song. Suds in a Bucket or whatever? Come on. :lol

[Das Texan]

Just like Chris' was ... :depressed


remember what i said about Chris last week.

[SpursWoman]

Why I thought he didn't do that great of a job had nothing to do with his style, I just didn't like the way he did that particular song. Because unlike pretty much everyone in the history of everyone, I happen to actually really like Creed. :oops :lol

[dawn]

I'm right there with you Spurswoman! As for my man Chris, was not his best, but still loved it! What kills me though is Simon completly doing a 360 this week. Last week it was congrats for being you and not compromising, this week it is you can't just keep being you and win this? I don't get that?

[SpursWoman]

Last week it was congrats for being you and not compromising, this week it is you can't just keep being you and winthis? I don't get that?


Yeah...that was a little odd. :drunk :lol

[MaNuMaNiAc]

Anyone know where I can view the latest Idol performances online? 'cause over here we get them a week or two late I think and I missed the last one.

[T Park]

Seriously...it was a goofy song. Suds in a Bucket or whatever? Come on

You obviously didn't hear all the lyrics.

its about a girl eloping with her bf to get married, and the town being in shock that such a good girl would do such a thing.

Sara Evans sang it, but of course, shes fifty times the singer Kelly Pickler is.

[angel_luv]

I think Suds is one of those songs you either love or hate.

[katyon6th]

Last night's performances pretty much sucked a lot of ass.

[SpursWoman]

You obviously didn't hear all the lyrics..


WTF? There is nothing wrong with my hearing. For a singing competition, that was a stupid song to pick.

[T Park]

Not your HEARING.

You didnt hear the WHOLE song.

Settle down now....


Its a fun song to sing, and Im sure thats why she sang it.

[SpursWoman]

Its a fun song to sing.


So is Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer. :lmao

[T Park]

sigh :depressed

[T Park]

so

America, let me get this straight.

You think, Ace, and Katherine McPhee, are worse singers, than Bucky.



Im moving to Canada.

[T Park]

Lisa is worse than Bucky too eh America??

Our country has gotten stupid.

[Horry For 3!]

so

America, let me get this straight.

You think, Ace, and Katherine McPhee, are worse singers, than Bucky.



Im moving to Canada.
I thought it was going to be, Lisa, Ace, Bucky. It should have been that.

Ace is horrible as well as is Bucky but last night was one of his better ones so that is why I think he got safe for this week.

[T Park]

Lisa >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Bucky


At least she has singing talent.


Bucky has no singing talent, What, SO, EVER.

He can't SING.

Anybody that tries to say that he can is full of it.

[Sonia_TX]

I can't believe Katharine was in the bottom 3... shoot bottom 2 for that matter. WTF?! Maybe I need to start voting! lol I haven't voted since season 1 and I didn't want to start now.

[T Park]

LOL

Sonia, thats the exact same thing my mom said.

LMAO


"Katherine in the bottom 3?? Maybe I need to bust out a text message" :lmao

[Sonia_TX]

Ooh but mom is going high tech there! lol I guess it's easier doing the text thing. Tell your mom it only counts if she's with Cingular. Don't want her wasting votes if she's not with Cingular.

[T Park]

Didn't have the heart to tell her.

Her being 50 and all, practically over the hill.

[angel_luv]

Who got voted off?

[T Park]

Lisa.

Lisa>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Bucky

[angel_luv]

What did Lisa sing? Was she the Beyon. chick?

[T Park]

No that was Paris.

Lisa sang, Because of You.

Sung originally by, Kelly Clarkson.

[SpursWoman]

Katherine was in the bottom 3??


Now that was a shocker, big time. :wow

[dawn]

this is just me...

Katherine, I can't stand. She has a voice i'll give her that, but her...
She just rubs me the wrong way with her little pouty looks that she tries to give. I just don't dig her, then again, I really don't dig the POP thing. She does those "Broadway" faces. It just drives me nuts.

[Spurminator]

Chris is getting a little one dimensional. He needs a good ballad in the next couple of weeks.

[T-Pain]

fuck american idol, waste of my time

[SpursWoman]

Chris is getting a little one dimensional. He needs a good ballad in the next couple of weeks.



Next week is country week. That ought to be interesting... :lol

[SpursWoman]

this is just me...

Katherine, I can't stand. She has a voice i'll give her that, but her...
She just rubs me the wrong way with her little pouty looks that she tries to give. I just don't dig her, then again, I really don't dig the POP thing. She does those "Broadway" faces. It just drives me nuts.


I go back and forth about her ... but I like her waaaay more then the dingy blonde chick. :lol

[Horry For 3!]

Country songs are on tonight..... after 2 people, not good


Country songs are easy to sing...at least for me

[Spurminator]

This episode is going to be a beating.

[Horry For 3!]

This episode is going to be a beating.
Except Bucky should do good as he sings country all the time

[SpursWoman]

I just got home....I'm just starting at the beginning. Doesn't sound good. :lol

[Horry For 3!]

I should be on tonight's show. I am good at country music. It is the easiest for me but I can basically sing everything

[Horry For 3!]

I thought Paris did pretty good

[Horry For 3!]

Noooooooooo. Ace is singing the song that I excell at :pctoss

[Horry For 3!]

Except Bucky should do good as he sings country all the time
I forgot Pickler is a country singer too.

[Sonia_TX]

I didn't really like Taylors performance (I usually love him)... Mandisa sucked, Elliott was good (love Garth), Paris was really good and Ace was looking hot...I mean he sounded good. He needed it tonight or else he might have been in danger of going home. With Kellie I agree with Simon...didn't like the song but liked the performance although I think it started off slow.

[Spurminator]

Kellie has that typical nasal Nashville country voice that I can't stand but apparently sells a lot of albums.

[Horry For 3!]

Katharine :tu

[Spurminator]

When did that become a country song? Did someone remake it?

[Sonia_TX]

I'm so freakin' glad that Chris came out of his rock comfort zone. He finally stuck w/the theme and didn't change it to rock. He actually has a nice voice when he's not screaming.

Katharine can do no wrong in my book. She's gorgeous, her voice is amazing, and I want her to win. lol I didn't like the song tonight but her voice was still great.

I didn't really pay attention to Bucky's performance since I was wrapped up in other things. What do you guys think?

I honestly don't know who I think will be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. I would put Mandisa and Kellie in the bottom along with Taylor (although he probably won't be). I haven't gotten the whole Mandisa thing so I wouldn't hate to see her leave. She does nothing for me.

[T Park]

Mandisa butchered Shania Twain's song.


Proving to these pop punks that country is a music choice you gotta take serious.

[Spurminator]

Mandisa butchered Shania Twain's song.

Meh, it was like pissing on a pile of shit really.

[T Park]

I haven't gotten the whole Mandisa thing so I wouldn't hate to see her leave. She does nothing for me.

haven't gotten that she has more talent in her pinkie finger, than Bucky the wonder redneck has in his entire body.

[T Park]

Meh, it was like pissing on a pile of shit really

I'll take Shania Twain over any of these non talented rock and pop punks any fucking day.


So yeah, she did shit on it.

[T Park]

If tommarow never comes, prob one of the most beautifull songs ever written, while Garth Brooks, IMO, not that great a singer, made it fantastic


Elliott did a good job with it :tu Elliottt

[T Park]

Paula passes up Bill Maher for most painfull and annoying person on TV.

[T Park]

I agree with Simon, why do the brain dead morons in the crowd have to boo everytime hes honest?

[T Park]

Paris, wow, what a fantastic rendition of "How would I live" personally one of my favorites, and on top of it, a tough song to do after Leann Rimes and Trisha Yearwood have made it platinum. She did a an amazing job, so far from what I've seen, THE BEST perforance.

[Spurminator]

I'll take Shania Twain over any of these non talented rock and pop punks any fucking day.


Shania blows. She's among the worst female vocalists in Nashville's not-too-proud history.

Give her an average face and body and she's still in Canada selling handjobs for rent money.

[T Park]

Ace singing "I wanna cry" prob my favorite Keith Urban song.

And, folks, fantastic performance from Ace, his best this season.

Ace? Your in number 1 overall right now. Glad he stepped away from the whole falsetto thing too. He has a great voice, Im glad he showed it.

Bravo Ace.

[T Park]

Nashville's not-too-proud history

not too proud??

Well, I guess its too bad its not like hollywood, and all their rock and roll drugheads...

[Spurminator]

Who's comparing it to Hollywood?

They suck too.

[T Park]

I love how people like Spurminator, and at times Randy Jackson and others, who look down at country as its the underbelly of music, its just classic.


BTW, Kelly Pickler great rendition of "Fancy" by Reba.

I loved her line, and I feel that wayA when I work in California "Its good to talk to someone with a familiar accent"


AMEN SISTA!!

[T Park]

Who's comparing it to Hollywood?


Well your comparing it to something....

[T Park]

Rock on Chris. Great job with Keith Urban's "Memories of Us"

Great voice, glad he got away from the freaking SCREAMING

Way to actually SING finally Chris.

My favorite performance of his since the Bon Jovi song.

[Spurminator]

Well your comparing it to something....

Yeah, I'm comparing it to real country music.

[T Park]

ohhhhh

real country music, like what 50s??

I see....

[T Park]

Katherine McPhee, good song, but I've never heard of it...