PDA

View Full Version : ESPN.com's Hollinger: Dirk vs. Duncan



CubanMustGo
05-09-2006, 02:18 PM
From http://insider.espn.go.com/nba/playoffs2006/insider/columns/story?columnist=hollinger_john&id=2438275


Who'll win the Dirk vs. Duncan battle?


Yes, there are some secondary players who will play key roles in the Spurs-Mavs series -- Tony Parker vs. Jason Terry and Josh Howard vs. Manu Ginobili, for instance.

And no, Duncan and Dirk aren't going to be matched up against each other much, if at all.

But set that aside for a second. In the big picture, chances are the series will come down to which team's superstar plays better.

In the regular season, this was a slam dunk for Nowitzki. The Teutonic titan had the best season of his career and had the league's highest PER. Duncan, meanwhile, was slowed by plantar fasciitis and averaged career lows in every important category. As a result, he'll likely be left off the first-team All-NBA squad for the first time in his nine pro seasons.

But lo and behold, Timmy's foot doesn't seem so bothersome anymore. Just check out his past five games for proof. Duncan's numbers in that span are 25.2 points, 9.6 boards and 61.3 percent shooting, and they would be even more impressive if the Spurs hadn't cut back his minutes in a couple of blowout games against the Kings.

We didn't pay much attention when Duncan went off on the Kings, who are featherweights in the paint, but Game 1 against Dallas certainly got everyone's attention. Duncan dropped 31 and 13 in the opening win, on a day when the other options struggled, and in doing so kept Erick Dampier and DeSagana Diop in foul trouble for most of the game.

Nowitzki, meanwhile, was dominant in a first-round sweep of the Grizzlies -- posting the best PER in the first round -- but struggled against longtime nemesis Bruce Bowen in Game 1. Although Dirk's bottom line -- 20 points and 14 boards -- didn't look too bad, he got many of his points at the expense of Michael Finley when Bowen was in foul trouble.

And at the end of the game, with Dallas needing a basket to tie, it was Bowen who first forced Nowitzki to catch the ball a few feet outside his post-up comfort zone, then harassed him into a wild cross-court pass that ultimately resulted in time running out on the Mavs.

The kicker here is that Nowitzki can't just play Duncan to a draw -- with Parker and Ginobili likely having the edge in the two pairings referenced above, Dallas doesn't advance unless Dirk outplays Duncan. Based on recent history, that's not looking like a smart bet.

A-Train
05-09-2006, 02:23 PM
The kicker here is that Nowitzki can't just play Duncan to a draw -- with Parker and Ginobili likely having the edge in the two pairings referenced above, Dallas doesn't advance unless Dirk outplays Duncan. Based on recent history, that's not looking like a smart bet.

Funny. The journalist/dude posting at home in his underwear/blogger/whoever at dallasbasketball.com said that the Mavs had the edge at those two spots but that Dirk's game negated that advantage.

Duff McCartney
05-09-2006, 03:32 PM
We didn't pay much attention when Duncan went off on the Kings, who are featherweights in the paint, but Game 1 against Dallas certainly got everyone's attention.

As opposed to Dampier and Diop? Give me a break...Sacramento are featherweights in the paint, but so is Dallas. Dampier ain't shit.

Dallas fans must be mighty happy to be paying $70 million for 6 fouls a night from this guy.

LEONARD
05-09-2006, 03:50 PM
As opposed to Dampier and Diop? Give me a break...Sacramento are featherweights in the paint, but so is Dallas. Dampier ain't shit.

Dallas fans must be mighty happy to be paying $70 million for 6 fouls a night from this guy.

5 blocks and 10 reb's in Game 1...they'd take from him every game and be perfectly happy. Is he a bargain? No.

He didn't really have foul problems this year. Although not starting since mid-season or so, he does play more min's than Diop and he's the one in at the end of the game...

Supergirl
05-09-2006, 04:31 PM
Dampier and Diop > Miller.

I wanted the Spurs to go after Miller when they had the chance, but since then I've concluded he's overrated - he disappears in the playoffs and plays pretty soft D.

Diop is the best defender of the 3, and Dampier can actually block a few shots now and then. So yeah, Dallas is tougher in the middle than Sacramento, though Sacramento's D as a team is still better since Artest joined the team.

A-Train
05-09-2006, 04:34 PM
Compared to what the Mavs used to have in the middle, they are stacked. TD will still punk them, though.

DieMrBond
05-09-2006, 08:08 PM
but struggled against longtime nemesis Bruce Bowen in Game 1.

Excuse me if i'm wrong, but didnt we only just recently figure out that Bowen can guard Dirk?

thispego
05-09-2006, 08:12 PM
Excuse me if i'm wrong, but didnt we only just recently figure out that Bowen can guard Dirk?
thats what i was thinking