Who is the best at each position?-SF

[gaKNOW!blee]

for me this one is clear cut, but what do you think?

[dallaskd]

make this a poll

[dallaskd]

for me this one is clear cut, but what do you think?

Jason Kapono?

[dallaskd]

Bruce Bowen??? lmfao. Peja, Rudy Gay, Marvin Williams, and Rashard Lewis are better options

[gaKNOW!blee]

Bruce Bowen??? lmfao. Peja, Rudy Gay, Marvin Williams, and Rashard Lewis are better options



offense isnt everything....Marvin Williams?????? are you serious.


Bruce Bowen helps his team more than all those guys combined.

[dallaskd]

Bowen

6.5 ppg
4.1 rpg
1.3 apg
+9.0 eff

Williams

13.1 ppg
5.3 rpg
1.9 apg
+12.55 eff

[JMarkJohns]

McGrady is the most polished of the SFs in the League. If you have a couple of really good rebounders/shotblockers to make up for his softness/lack of defense, then he'll help you far and away more than any other SF. His offensive game is limited only as much as he is willing to settle.

[dallaskd]

who voted for bowen?? :lol

[gaKNOW!blee]

Bowen

6.5 ppg
4.1 rpg
1.3 apg
+9.0 eff

Williams

13.1 ppg
5.3 rpg
1.9 apg
+12.55 eff

good stats, next time Williams effectivley guards AI, Melo, Williams, Lebron and Nash all in one playoff year then let me know.

[itzsoweezee]

carmelo is the only one of those guys that is unstoppable offensively.

[dallaskd]

carmelo is the only one of those guys that is unstoppable offensively.

no bruce bowen is unstoppable

[gaKNOW!blee]

no bruce bowen is unstoppable



much like the rest of the nba fans out there, you fail to realize defense is just as important as offense.


Bruce isnt unstoppable, he stops people all the time.

[DOMINATOR]

T-mac is the best all around player on that list.

[dirk4mvp]

'Melo

[gtownspur]

no bruce bowen is unstoppable



Why are you the only brazillian that makes all the other brasilerhinos look like dumbasses?

[Findog]

who voted for bowen?? :lol

Spurs homers.

[Findog]

much like the rest of the nba fans out there, you fail to realize defense is just as important as offense.


Bruce isnt unstoppable, he stops people all the time.

He's a nice role player on a championship team. Let's not get carried away.

[Findog]

How the hell does Josh Howard have more votes than Paul Pierce?

[Bear Grylls]

How the hell does Josh Howard have more votes than Paul Pierce?



Because more people voted for Josh Howard.

[DOMINATOR]

How the hell does Josh Howard have more votes than Paul Pierce?
no celtics fans here.
Pierce is a little overrated considering he is #1 option while howard is #2 option on the mavs.

[Findog]

Because more people voted for Josh Howard.

Okay, well let me rephrase then: What is the rationale for claiming Howard > Pierce? I've also noticed he's got more votes than Carmelo. I'm a Mavs fan and I loves me some J-Ho, but I'm not a homer.

[Bear Grylls]

Okay, well let me rephrase then: What is the rationale for claiming Howard > Pierce? I've also noticed he's got more votes than Carmelo. I'm a Mavs fan and I loves me some J-Ho, but I'm not a homer.


Thats because I voted for him 6 times.

[B and P Cats]

Carmelo. He was terrific on the USA team last summer under Coach K. Too bad he can't seem to follow-up in Denver the same way!

[itzsoweezee]

Carmelo. He was terrific on the USA team last summer under Coach K. Too bad he can't seem to follow-up in Denver the same way!

what are you talking about? he was awesome in denver this year.

[B and P Cats]

what are you talking about? he was awesome in denver this year.


Matter of opinion. I thought he was better last summer.

[Bear Grylls]

Carmelo. He was terrific on the USA team last summer under Coach K. Too bad he can't seem to follow-up in Denver the same way!

Early nomination for dumbest post of the day.



:gpower :cheer :bike: :flypig :sequ :sucker :elephant :dizzy :sombrero: :guin

[B and P Cats]

Early nomination for dumbest post of the day.



:gpower :cheer :bike: :flypig :sequ :sucker :elephant :dizzy :sombrero: :guin


:lol :lol Thank you!!

[J.T.]

McGrady is the best player on that list, but he gets a bad rep because of his 2nd round virginity.

[~~Ice Man 2000~~]

:lol :lol Thank you!!
I can totally top that...
My vote t-mac

[Bear Grylls]

Carmelo by a mile; and he is only 22 years old. He can shoot the jumper and post him too and takes it to the basket strong. He is learning to shoot the 3 also, if he adds that to his repertoire he can become unstoppable.


:lmao :lmao :lmao

[dallaskd]

Why are you the only brazillian that makes all the other brasilerhinos look like dumbasses?

idk..?

[ambchang]

Anybody who doesn't vote for Lebron is a moron, or a sick homer.

[Bear Grylls]

explain who is better than Anthony on this list? The kid averaged almost 30 points this year?


Come back when the only thing that matters is scoring.


Guess you did not know that Lebron is the better rebounder, passer, he turns the ball over fewer times, shoots better from behind the arc, and he averages more steals and blocks.


But hey, Carmelo averaged 1.6 more PPG than Lebron, HE MUST BE THE BETTER PLAYER.

[Bear Grylls]

Anybody who doesn't vote for Lebron is a moron, or a sick homer.


I voted for Josh Howard 6 times, if I could remember the rest of my names it would be alot more.

[Bear Grylls]

Lebron has the ball more than Melo, so he has to be a better passer, he is their defacto point guard. And Yeah against the Spurs looks at Melo's numbers and then look at Lebrons, and come back and talk to me about who is better!

So the only thing that Lebron was really better was at assists which is given since he is their point guard, and his rebounding was 2 more per game, but that should be given since he plays in the East and only plays west teams twice a year, which means most small forwards he only plays twice unlike Melo. And don't talk about blocks....it's 0.7 for James and 0.4 for Melo. And the steals are about the same too...1.6 for Lebron and 1.0 for Melo. Yes he shoots better 3's but Melo shoots 10% percent higher from the Line. Blocks for James this year 0.7 and for Melo 0.4.



Ummmm........Wow






Moron in the house

[gaKNOW!blee]

Lebron has the ball more than Melo, so he has to be a better passer, he is their defacto point guard. And Yeah against the Spurs looks at Melo's numbers and then look at Lebrons, and come back and talk to me about who is better!

So the only thing that Lebron was really better was at assists which is given since he is their point guard, and his rebounding was 2 more per game, but that should be given since he plays in the East and only plays west teams twice a year, which means most small forwards he only plays twice unlike Melo. And don't talk about blocks....it's 0.7 for James and 0.4 for Melo. And the steals are about the same too...1.6 for Lebron and 1.0 for Melo. Yes he shoots better 3's but Melo shoots 10% percent higher from the Line. Blocks for James this year 0.7 and for Melo 0.4.


Melo second round apperances: 0

[itzsoweezee]

Anybody who doesn't vote for Lebron is a moron, or a sick homer.

or saw him exposed in the finals

[KidCongo]

explain who is better than Anthony on this list? The kid averaged almost 30 points this year?

Ok so LeBron averaged 31 points last year so explain who's better on that list...

[SpursIndonesia]

1. LeBron James
2. Luol Deng
3. Josh Howard
4. Carmello Anthony
5. Tracy MacGrady
6. Paul Pierce

[Bear Grylls]

1. LeBron James
2. Luol Deng
3. Josh Howard
4. Carmello Anthony
5. Tracy MacGrady
6. Paul Pierce




Holy Shit.



:elephant :elephant :elephant :elephant

[itzsoweezee]

josh howard is never going to be more than a sidekick. just because the spurs pathetic defense against him in last year's playoffs made him look like a great player doesn't mean that's actually the case.

[freedom&justice]

How the hell does Josh Howard have more votes than Paul Pierce?

umm...because he was hurt most of the year and no one knows if he'll come back the same player? Dude has totally fallen off the map since his injury. And his team sucks. The best SF is Lebron - but I voted for Pierce. Bron's got way too many votes, thought I'd even things up a little.

[dallaskd]

How does Bowen have so many votes?

[Leetonidas]

1. LeBron James
2. Luol Deng
3. Josh Howard
4. Carmello Anthony
5. Tracy MacGrady
6. Paul Pierce
I'm sorry, but while Luol Deng is a beast, no way is he better than Melo. And Josh Howard? :lmao

I see it more like this:

1. LeBron James
2. Carmello Anthony
3. Tracy McGrady
4. Paul Pierce
5. Luol Deng
6. Josh Howard

[dallaskd]

Mcgrady is #1 by far.

[BUMP]

1. LeBron James
2. Luol Deng
3. Josh Howard
4. Carmello Anthony
5. Tracy MacGrady
6. Paul Pierce
Luol Deng better than Melo and McGrady?