PDA

View Full Version : Charley Rosen: Grading the free-agent comings and goings



Spurs Brazil
07-15-2007, 06:42 PM
http://msn.foxsports.com/nba/story/7021990

As the pace of the free agent signings and re-signings quickens, let's evaluate what impact the latest changes of addresses might have on the players and the teams involved.

Grant Hill, Phoenix
Mike D'Antoni has wisely predicted that Hill will only play 25-30 minutes per game. Even so, there's no way that Hill's oft-injured, 35-year-old legs can keep up with Steve Nash and Co. In addition, Hill is a poor 3-point shooter, plays only moderately effective defense (which is, actually, business as usual in Phoenix), is notoriously soft, and has always been turnover-prone. Barring any further injuries, Hill does provide maturity and unselfishness as well as an excellent one-on-one option when the Suns are forced to take the air out of the ball. In other words, Hill's value will become more apparent in the playoffs. And by presumably pushing Boris Diaw out of the starting lineup, Hill's presence will also lengthen the Suns' bench. Grade: B


Darko Milicic, Memphis
Add Marc Iavaroni to the lengthening list of coaches who believe that they are the ones who can motivate Milicic. Getting him to play hard night in and night out. Convincing him to do something on defense besides blocking shots. To make quick, crisp passes instead of massaging the ball and casting longing looks at the hoop. To work to improve his post-up game. To avoid careless turnovers. To improve his free-throw shooting. To start behaving like a grown-up.

Good luck, coach. Grade: C-


Steve Blake, Portland
This guy can play. Offense, that is. He's smart, a dangerous spot-shooter, a more than adequate finisher, and a terrific passer. Blake's athleticism is surprising and is a definite upgrade over Jarrett Jack, who will be a superb backup. Blake's hustling but less-than-average defense will provide Greg Oden with numerous opportunities to block shots and pick up fouls. Still, this is a good move for the Blazers.

Now if they can only find some way to rid themselves of Darius Miles. Grade: B


Chucky Atkins, Denver
Here's the drop-it-like-it's-hot perimeter shooter the Nuggets have so sorely lacked. In addition, Atkins can drive both ways, excels in screen/rolls, has an excellent pull-up game, and would rather run than walk. However, he's a much better jump shooter than he is a finisher. At the other end, Atkins likes to pressure the ball and gamble on steals, but doesn't play solid contain defense. Also, since he's only 5-11, it's unlikely that Atkins can ever play in tandem with Allen Iverson. For Atkins, that unavoidable reality doesn't amount to very much leftover time or shots. Grade: C-


Mikki Moore, Sacramento
Despite his threatening glares, cheap shots and overly aggressive fouls, Mikki Moore is not nearly as tough as he thinks he is. Also, his defense is poor, he doesn't rebound well in heavy traffic, he's an inferior passer, and a habitual fouler. What he is, though, is an exceptional mid-range shooter. Strictly a one-trick pony.

If Moore is a useful player, he's not the force that the Kings need in the middle. Grade: C


If you've got a topic you'd like to see Charley Rosen address, submit it below and Charley may just respond.
Subject:

Comment/Question:

Name: (ex, john doe)
Email: (ex, [email protected])
Hometown:





Jamaal Magliore, New Jersey
Magliore will bang around some in the paint and attack every up-for-grabs offensive rebound (much more so than he does on defense). If his post-up moves are somewhat stiff and studied, they can be effective against both poor and reluctant defenders that he can bully. Conversely, bigger, stronger opponents can make Magliore flinch. Passing is not his game, and double-teams turn him into a turnover machine. Magloire provides adequate insurance in case Nenad Krstic fails to make a full recovery from his injury. And, should Krstic be A-OK, his ability to knock down 15-footers just might compliment Magloire's inside presence well enough to constitute a relatively formidable front-court combo in the weak-kneed Eastern Conference. Certainly a much better alliance than Krstic and Moore would have been. Grade: C+


Derek Fisher, Los Angeles Lakers
All of the legalities haven't been fully satisfied, but this transaction will certainly be consummated shortly. When it is, the Lakers will have the experienced guard they've missed since Fisher signed with Golden State in 2004. His widely celebrated clutch shooting and stubborn defense will be welcomed, as will his total mastery of the triangle offense. Fisher compensates for his relative slowness afoot by smartly drawing charges and by avoiding egregious mistakes at both ends of the court. While he's not the tall, long-limbed backcourtsman that Phil Jackson pines for (which enables the quick-switching defense that PJ desires), Fisher is a huge plus. Not the least of what Fisher brings is the fact that during his previous tenure in L.A. he was the only player on the team who was close to Kobe. Grade: A-


Morris Peterson, New Orleans
Mo-Pete was often buried on the bench in the Raptors' overhaul, but he remains a slasher-driver-shooter-creator-runner who can score in a variety of ways. The more he plays, the better he plays. Look for him to have a big season with the Hornets. Grade: A-


Chauncey Billups, Detroit
Ever since Larry Brown left, Billups has lost his way. In Flip Saunders' iso-oriented scheme, Billlups basically delivers the ball to whichever teammate has been tabbed to take the shot. Billups gets to shoot only when the other guys are firing blanks, or when he's on the plus-side of a glaring mismatch. Gone are the days when Billups orchestrated a quick-hitting, cohesive team-offense and got his shots within the flow. Now he's just another guy waiting in line with a number in his hand. That's why his offensive output has been so erratic.

So, if the return to the Motor City is a good deal for the Pistons, Billups would have been better served gong elsewhere. Grade: A for the Pistons, C- for Billups


Gerald Wallace, Charlotte
Wallace was, and will continue to be, the best player on the Bobcats. The only soft spots in Wallace's arsenal are his propensity to pick up fouls (mostly because of his aggressive defense), his free-throw shooting, and his turnovers. In Wallace and Jason Richardson (if he stays healthy), Charlotte now boasts one of the finest sets of wingmen in the league. Grade: A


Matt Carroll, Charlotte
Every team needs a dead-eye shooter, and that's what Carroll provides for the Bobcats. The bonus is Carroll's athleticism and mobility. True, his defense is barely adequate and he mishandles the ball too often, but he's surely good at what he's supposed to do. Grade: B




Jerry Stackhouse, Dallas
Why change a good thing? Stackhouse is an explosive scorer who can still bust to the middle, shoulder an opponent to create space for his fade away jumper, or drain 3-balls from either corner. Sure, Stackhouse isn't a solid defender, and doesn't deliver in the clutch — but this only makes him a perfect fit in a team loaded with players sporting similar flaws. Grade: C


Devean George, Dallas
Along with Greg Buckner, George represents the only Mavs who can play major league defense in the backcourt. Too bad George has trouble staying healthy. But his being prone to missing clutch shots isn't a factor with Dallas since he's usually on the bench in the endgame watching others do the same. Grade: C-


Matt Bonner, San Antonio
A big-time long-distance shooter and earnest banger, Bonner is in the process of learning how to defend and play according to Pop's high standards. In granting him a three-year contract, the Spurs are demonstrating their belief that sooner rather than later he'll become a useful player. How could anybody question their judgment? Grade: B


Jacque Vaughn, San Antonio
He pressures the ball, makes good decisions, and even knocks down important jumpers. The perfect place for the imperfect player. Grade: B+


Fabricio Oberto, San Antonio
Where else would this guy have fit in so well? He can't jump, shoot, run, handle, block shots, move laterally, or use his left hand. But he can play bump and grind defense on post-up players until he picks up his usual early fouls. And he's always in the right place at the right time. Grade: A

FromWayDowntown
07-15-2007, 06:46 PM
How could anybody question their judgment?

Ask SpursTalk.

JamStone
07-15-2007, 06:54 PM
lmao @ A- for Derek Fisher ... this guy is still a Phil Jackson cocksucker

da_suns_fan__
07-15-2007, 07:19 PM
lmao @ A- for Derek Fisher ... this guy is still a Phil Jackson cocksucker


CO-SIGN.

djohn14
07-15-2007, 07:23 PM
It should say "Grading the free-agent comings, goings, and stayings"

Dro210
07-15-2007, 11:27 PM
Fisher's a great sign for the Lakers....... Their PG play has been absolutly horrible. Fisher's a big improvement even if he didn't know the system, and work well with Kobe and Phil.... but since he does... that much better

justanotherspursfan
07-15-2007, 11:44 PM
Fisher's a great sign for the Lakers....... Their PG play has been absolutly horrible. Fisher's a big improvement even if he didn't know the system, and work well with Kobe and Phil.... but since he does... that much better
Yeah, but at this stage in his career, Fisher is a guy you want as a sub off the bench who can play crunch time, not as a guy who can be a starter. For that matter, they need someone younger who can develop with what is really a pretty young team, not an aging guy who's going to decline every year. Throw in the fact that they overpaid drastically and it prevented them from using their midlevel on anyone else, and it completely looks like a desperation move.

Mr. Body
07-16-2007, 01:13 AM
I missed some of these. When did Magloire go to New Jersey? For how much?

OldDirtMcGirt
07-16-2007, 01:59 AM
All Rosen does is blow San Antonio and LA. He seriously thinks that Steve Blake is an upgrade over Jarrett Jack? Does he even watch basketball?