Trade Idea: Ginobili for Redd

[ggf33]

For Michael Redd and 2009 1st round pick + Oberto and Udoka.

[Marcus Bryant]

Pass.

[Emanuel20]

For Michael Redd and 2009 1st round pick + Oberto and Udoka.

Redd is not worth that much!

[FromWayDowntown]

Pardon my ignorance, but what is TI? And is there some sort of link?

[E20]

He plays worse D than Manu, has to jack up a lotta shots and can't slash like Manu............next

[AFBlue]

Pardon my ignorance, but what is TI? And is there some sort of link?

trade idea?

[Spurminator]

TI = Trade Idea?

[E20]

Pardon my ignorance, but what is TI? And is there some sort of link?
TI = Totally Insane

[ggf33]

Its trade idea plus we get a possible lottery pick next year if the Bucks fail again which seems possible!

[FromWayDowntown]

trade idea?

That makes sense. Just want to be sure whether we're talking about someone's random idea or a rumor (that may have about the same amount of credibility).

[mytespurs]

blech!

[K-State Spur]

Usually, fans of a team have a major problem with OVER-valuing their own players.

Spurs fans seem to have issues with doing the opposite.

[Ocotillo]

I am absolutely speechless.......... you sure you don't want to throw in a few more picks as well?

[Bob Lanier]

:lol

[Lake_show]

Michael Redd is better than Ginobli. No lie.

[dg7md]

Redd is way better... he can give you 25 a night and is one of the elite shooters in the league.

[tav1]

Pass. Ginobli is considerably better than Redd, not to mention that Udoka and Oberto are valuable to the team.

[Lake_show]

Manu is a good player, but you can't compare him to number 1 options that see double teams all the time.

Michael: 22-4-3 2.51 TO
Manu: 19-4-4 2.70 TO

[angelbelow]

Hell No

[Big P]

Way to show support to the guy that has bascially bought us a couple of titles. This is so far out there from what the FO would really do...Redd is a nice shooter..thats about it..granted he is a very elite player, but the Spurs are not going to pay this guy $16, $17, & $18 million over the next 3 years & sell Manu out in the process...I'm sure Gino has always wanted to play for the Bucks. Threads like this need to be locked IMO.

[RuffnReadyOzStyle]

:rolleyes

Enough with trying to trade Manu already.

He is still one of the three clutchest players in the game, and next year Pop will find a way to rest him for the playoffs.

Next.

[K-State Spur]

Manu is a good player, but you can't compare him to number 1 options that see double teams all the time.

Michael: 22-4-3 2.51 TO
Manu: 19-4-4 2.70 TO

Redd spends far too much of each night hanging out beyond the 3 point line to be doubled all the time.

[T Park]

:lmao

Spurs need an athletic swingman and you guys want a spot up shooting Michael Redd!???!

[Bob Lanier]

Michael Redd is better than Ginobli. No lie.

Redd is way better... he can give you 25 a night and is one of the elite shooters in the league.
:lol

[jag]

Manu is a good player, but you can't compare him to number 1 options that see double teams all the time.

Michael: 22-4-3 2.51 TO
Manu: 19-4-4 2.70 TO

Redd also averages 7 more minutes per game.

Manu doesn't see double teams?

Redd is supposed to be a "sharpshooter"...he shot 36% from downtown, while Manu shot 40% from three.

I'd take a healthy Ginobili over a straight up trade for Redd. I'm by no means a manu homer, but let's be real here.

[Mr.Bottomtooth]

Redd also averages 7 more minutes per game.

Manu doesn't see double teams?

Redd is supposed to be a "sharpshooter"...he shot 36% from downtown, while Manu shot 40% from three.

I'd take a healthy Ginobili over a straight up trade for Redd. I'm by no means a manu homer, but let's be real here.

Agreed.

[rAm]

:rolleyes

Enough with trying to trade Manu already.

He is still one of the three clutchest players in the game, and next year Pop will find a way to rest him for the playoffs.

Next.

I love it when I see Manu eying a 3 ball, and I just know its going in.

[Aggie Hoopsfan]

Its trade idea plus we get a possible lottery pick next year if the Bucks fail again which seems possible!

You should have captioned it STI.

Stupid trade idea.

[angelbelow]

For Michael Redd and 2009 1st round pick + Oberto and Udoka.

i doubt the salaries even match up for that one.

[hsxvvd]

TI= Terrible Idea.

[Septic]

Why don't you give them Tim Duncan while you're at it.

[nfg3]

:lmao

Spurs need an athletic swingman and you guys want a spot up shooting Michael Redd!???!

:tu

[Bob Lanier]

Redd is actually pretty damn good at getting to the basket for someone with his limited athletic abilities. He has nice footwork and can draw a ton of fouls. He's a superstar-caliber offensive talent who would be marketed as such if he didn't play in bumfuck Wisconsin.

But he's also one of the biggest ballhogs in the NBA and (this is the bigger issue) just plain doesn't play defense. Not that he's physically capable of playing much defense, but he doesn't care enough to even put in that minimal effort. Spurs fans tend to overrate Ginobili's defensive abilities, but he's still above-average; all of the Spurs starters are at least average defenders. Redd would present a huge gaping hole in that lineup.

[timvp]

I wouldn't trade Manu for two Michael Redds.

[ElNono]

Its trade idea plus we get a possible lottery pick next year if the Bucks fail again which seems possible!

They won't fail if they got Manu, Oberto and Udoka alongside Bogut...

[tmtcsc]

Just stop already.

Unless you are offering Kobe or Lebron, you don't trade Ginobili. Do you all realize he is a friggin bargain ?
Tony is younger but I'd move him before I ever even consider Ginobili.

[Budkin]

Please delete this retarded fucking thread.

[GrandeDavid]

I don't want Manu to wear any other jersey but that of the San Antonio Spurs, even if it might hurt the team down the road. He's that important to this franchise, fan base and city. No way.

[smrattler]

One of the worst ideas in the history of life.

[rAm]

Please delete this retarded fucking thread.

[MannyIsGod]

People who posts these threads deserve autobans.

[SpurOutofTownFan]

For Michael Redd and 2009 1st round pick + Oberto and Udoka.

I really don't know if I have to call you an idiot or not. What do you want to trade for.... Redd?

Manu
Oberto
Udoka
1st round 2009 pick

?????

Anything else? your panties maybe?
Thank god you don't run shit. Your ignorance insults me.

[td4mvp21]

Yeah let's trade Manu because he got worn out and battled injuries on and off during a postseason and sucked at times. It's not like he was having a career year before that or anything.

[pawe]

Hell no and stop with these trade Manu/TP bullcrap. Manu aint going nowhere. He's gonna retire as a Spur.

[picnroll]

One more example of no matter how stupid an idea is it can't get you banned from SpursTalk.

Too bad.