Printable View
Well just throwing in a thread..But who do you think is the best PG in the league...I am just guessing the top 5
http://www.bballcity.com/images/2007...chris-paul.jpg
1.Chris Paul?
http://i.a.cnn.net/si/2005/writers/m....parker.si.jpg
2.Tony Parker?
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/200...n.williams.jpg
3.Deron Williams?
http://images.usatoday.com/sports/_p...enas-large.jpg
4.Gilbert Arenas?
http://www.nbaobsessed.com/wp-conten...ey-billups.jpg
5.Chauncey Billups?
Tell me what you guys think...
Paul
Williams
Parker
Nash
Davis
dittoQuote:
Originally Posted by Mr.Bottomtooth
Almost DittoQuote:
Originally Posted by Mr.Bottomtooth
1. CP3 & DWill
2. Tony
3. Gnash
4. B-Diddy
5. Kidd
Tony & Gnash are hard to pick over each other, Tony's more of a scoring guard and Gnash is the better facilitator. I'd probably pick Tony if starting a team now though.
Gilbert Arenas plays PG but he's more of a shooting guard.
Yeah all good PG but i never liked Kidd:/
You are putting the '08 Kidd in the top 5-6 PGs in the NBA - ahead of Billups?:wowQuote:
Originally Posted by Allanon
+1Quote:
Originally Posted by Kindergarten Cop
Maybe 07 and back Kidd... but 08? He is going to be even worse this year. I honestly predict he will be traded off before the allstar break... Mav fans will be livid with anger for his play production... Cuban will spend money on a hack and blame everything on the coach.
1. cp3
2. williams
3. parker
4. nash
5. davis
6. arenas
7. billups
8. calderon
9. kidd
10. rondo
Arenas is a PG in name alone. His team did better without him. But other than that the list looks good.Quote:
Originally Posted by Iheartspurs
1. Chris Paul
2. Steve Nash
3. Deron Williams
4. Baron Davis
5. Tony Parker
6. Gilbert Arenas
7. Chauncey Billups
8. Jose Calderon
9. Andre Miller
10. Jason Kidd
true and much better than calderon and rondo...Quote:
Originally Posted by rj215
LOL at rondo being in the top 10. although he did improve the past year.
TOP 10:
1. Chris Paul
2. Deron Williams
3. Tony Parker
4. Steve "No D" Nash
5. Baron Davis
6. Gilbert Arenas
7. Chauncey Billups
8. Jason Kidd
9. Andre Miller
10. Jose Calderon
I like this listQuote:
Originally Posted by timtonymanu
1- CP3
2- TP
3- D-Will
4- Nash
5- Gil-Arenas
6- Davis
7- Andre Miller
8- Billups
9- Calderon
10- Rondo
If Tony's a top 5 point guard then I'd better be listed 6th.
"B-Diddy"? Then why not "T-Piddy" for Parker? And "J-Kiddy", "C-Piddy", "D-Willy" and "Snatchy"?Quote:
Originally Posted by Allanon
J-Kiddy and D-Willy are actually pretty good :lolQuote:
Originally Posted by peskypesky
1.CP3
2. Deron Williams
3. Steve Nash
4. Jason Kidd
5 . Jose Calderon
6. Chauncey Billups
7. Baron Davis
8. Tony Parker
9. Gilbert Arenas
10. Sam Cassell
Tony has three rings and a finals mvp he is the #1 , only other pg on the list that has a championship is Bilups
oh, so then the list should look like this:Quote:
Originally Posted by STEVEYCU
#1: TP
#2: Rondo
#3: Billups
#4: J. Williams
#5: D. Fisher
or wait, fisher should probably be #2
name the top 5 point guards that would fit into the spurs system
Your a good poster, but this may be the worst list ive seen in quite some time.Quote:
Originally Posted by lefty
Why ???Quote:
Originally Posted by mystargtr34
Good poster? i dunno,but I agree that's some bad list right there.Quote:
Originally Posted by mystargtr34
WTF are you ? :lmaoQuote:
Originally Posted by san antonio spurs
No rafer alston???? WTF this list fails IMHO:downspin:
How good would Paul be if he didn't have Chandler to bail him out when he penetrates? Its the same as Nash, they both have players who can jump insanely high.
Parker 8th???Quote:
Originally Posted by lefty
No way in hell, is is closer to the top 3 than that. And is probably in the top 3, I for once would never take Nash over him, and I'm not that crazy about DW either...
:hatQuote:
Originally Posted by NZ Spurs
how is jose 5Quote:
Originally Posted by lefty
http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/player...?playerId=2806 that is his stats
how is sam cassel 10:wow:wow:wow:wow:wow:wow:wow:wow:wow
Parker is NOT in the top 5 :lol
Paul
Nash
Williams
Kidd
Davis
Arenas
than probably Parker. you are a huge homer to put Parker over Nash.
:DQuote:
Originally Posted by ducks
Jose is underrated because of his stats, and because he is playing in Toronto; he is a great PG, should have been an all-star last season, and is a better decision maker than Parker.
Sam Cassell, well.... I love his leadership and clutchness
1. Deron Williams
2. Chris Paul
3. Tony Parker
4. Chauncey Billups
5. Rajon Rondo
6. Baron Davis
7. Andre Miller
8. Steve Nash
9. Jason Kidd
10. Jose Calderon
Rajon Rondo is the 5th best point guard in the NBA?
Really?
Really really?
:lmao Oh, man...I needed that before work.Quote:
Originally Posted by sook
Tony Parker is not better than Deron Williams or Steve Nash. Personally I put him in more of a scoring PG class, with guys like Baron Davis and Gilbert Arenas. He doesnt have NEAR the PG skills/instincts of Williams, Paul, or Nash.
This is quite possibly the stupidest list I have ever seen.Quote:
Originally Posted by Supergirl
this list and I have something in commonQuote:
Originally Posted by Supergirl
Let's talk homer, Jason Kidd present over Parker present? Laughable. Incomprehensible. But that's part of being a Mavs fan, it is both mind boggling and funny to watch the lying that they do to themselves, but they do it anyway. godblessum.Quote:
Originally Posted by dallaskd
After the way Nash and Parker performed against each other's teams these past playoffs, I'm not so sure your argument is that clear-cut anymore.Quote:
Originally Posted by dallaskd
Gilbert Arenas the Best Scorer
Yes. Next.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackBellamy
When the hell did Calderon become hot shit?
Any of you putting him higher than 8th need to share a little of whatever you're smoking.
As for my 2 cents, Jason Kidd may be a more prototypical point guard than Tony, but you'd be hard pressed to find one respectable team that would take 2008 Kidd over 2008 Tony.
Maybe the dumbass Mavericks, but they don't count.
Quote:
Originally Posted by STEVEYCU
So I guess that makes Robert Horry the best player in the NBA.
cmon rondo in the top 5?! without the big 3 of the celtics, he's nothing. overrated!Quote:
Originally Posted by Supergirl
Quote:
Originally Posted by stretch
Hey, what do you know, we actually agree on something, lol.:lol
Actually, it's Rondo who is underrated. People know how good Pierce and KG are. There is a reason why when the Jefferson-KG trade went down, Minnesota wanted them to include Rondo, but the Celtics refused. He should have proved his worth last year in the Finals, but still people underrate him.Quote:
Originally Posted by timtonymanu
He's one of the best defending PGs in the league, and he's athletic and smart. After Paul, Billups, Williams, and Parker (not necessarily in that order) I can't think of a PG I'd rather have on my team.
Rondo>Billups
:lmaoQuote:
Originally Posted by urunobili
Not yet. But give Rondo a few years and he probably will be.Quote:
Originally Posted by urunobili
I'd take Tony over Nash every day of the week.
sam cassell really? lol, heres my list :p
1. Chris Paul (blossomed into the best pg in the league)
2. Steve Nash (no one runs an offense more beautifully than him)
3. Deron Williams (A true PG, that knows how to score)
4. Tony parker (experience, 3 rings, 1 finals mvp at age 26)
5. J-kidd (he's one of the greatest leaders, plus hes a triple double king
6. Baron Davis (very incosistent, but in some nights he can be the best pg with his size)
7. Chauncey Billups (clutch as hell)
8. Allen iversion (does he count? great scorer)
9. Gilbert Areneas (a great scorer, but very injury-prone)
10. Jose Calderon (a great PG, if given more playing time/starting time, maybe all-star status, double-double)
No, this is...Quote:
Originally Posted by stretch
1. Jason Williams
2. Rafer Alston
3. Beno Udrih
4. Stephon Marbury
5. Jordan Farmar
6. Earl Boykins
7. Sebastian Telfair
8. Delonte West
9. Mo Wiliiams
10. J.J. Redick
There ya go.
1 Deron Williams
2 CP3
3 Nash
4 Parker
5 Davis
6 Billups
7 Arenas
8 Calderon
9 Kidd
10 Andre Miller
CP3 was the runner up in MVP voting but If i started a team i would pick Williams as my lead guard. His size and 3 point shooting puts him over the top on my list.
1. CP3
2. DWILL
3. Parker and Nash tied
5. Davis
6. Billups
7. Arenas
8. Calderon
9. Kidd
10. Miller
How good is Paul if you know he's going to lob it to Chandler and he does it anyway over and over again? Hell, how good is Paul when people are posting about a a second rate scrub like Chandler as though he's good enough to bail anyone out or comparing him to Amare?Quote:
Originally Posted by NZ Spurs
If I had to choose a PG for the 2008-09 season...
1. Chris Paul
2. Steve Nash
3. Deron Williams
4. Tony Parker
5. Baron Davis
6. Chauncey Billups
7. Gilbert Arenas
8. Jason Kidd
9. Jose Calderon
10. Andre Miller
This list is ridiculous, J.J. Reddick doesn't even get PT. How could you not include Tyronn Lue or Juan Jose Barea?Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackBellamy
Quote:
Originally Posted by BlackBellamy
lol worst list in no order would be:
1. Eric Snow
2. Steve Francis
3. Jamaal Tinsley
4. Tyronn Lue
5. Sebastian Telfair
6. Stephon Marbury
7. Beno Udrih
8. Jacque Vaughn
9. Damon Stoudamire
10. Antonio Daniels
Just off the top of my head, y'know? Ta' be funny... or not, whatever.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dramon