-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
The FO is working overtime to relieve Tim of his burdens for the last 2 seasons. Dice, Blair, Haisplip and Rats. That leaves Ian or Matt. Matt does the one thing Ian does't---a proven 3 point shooter. I don't see any minutes for Ian here. Question? What teams need a Mahimni[who needs to play minutes this year]? A rebuiding team! #1 choice -the Rockets. Mahimni + whatever makes sense for us--Bonner or Findley or Mason, Haireston] for LUIS SCOLA. That trade has been a pin in our ass for 2 years. Houston is simply waiting for Yao in 2010. SCOLA coming off the bench for Tim would be awesome. LUIS should have always been a Spur! Rats one year deal indicates that Splitter will be coming next season. If The Rockets were desperate enough to offer Gortat the MLE then Ian[22] is a good risk for a 28-29 year old PF. My #2 choice is the Wizards Mike Miller. The Wizards have too, too, too many shooter/ scorers. Miller really doesn't fit because shooters need to shot a lot. If Air-Arenas is back then Miller will be looking at 6-8 attempts a game. His contract is big[less likely] but expiring. Hell of a starter with Manu relieving him.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
I know, I know...speaking of possible trades, that never have mentioned bei either FO is retarded (start the bashing!), but:...
thinking about the possibilities and the chances of trades happening one trade makes a lot of sense to me:
http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMa...tradeId=l7zn6q
allredy mentioned it (kind of):
Thabo for Finley and Ian!
for OKC:
1) they should be interested in Ian...Mullins could be a nice project, but they could use someone like Ian as an even better prsopect...especially with Krstic beeing able to play PF for some minutes which would give them a nice big lineup
2) they should like Finley beeing the mentor to Harden and Durant
3) they are not there yet...teams like Cleveland, Boston or the Mavs wont trade with us, but they shouldnt have problems
4) Sam Pestri
for us:
1) we get that defensive wing without loosing much
2) "not much"=trading a player with good potential for a player with good potential while only adding someon who is redundant
things that speak against it:
1) Sam Pestri...he should have an open line to RC and Pop...why didnt it already happen
2) its nothing which will double our chances to become champion...it just evens out the lineup, while giving us the oportunity to pick up Bowen too
btw.: I like to play with the new lineups in NBA2k9 and Ian always seems like the player I have no use for (not with ratliff on board)
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Fuckers are crazy if they want to ship Ian away.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
mudyez
things that speak against it:
Thunder players who play PF or C: Green, Ibaka, White, Collison, Krstic, Mullens
players, who are projects: Ibaka, White, Mullens
players similar to Ian: Ibaka, Mullens
Thunder players, who are above average wing defenders: Sefolosha
if you are a GM, who wants to keep his job, would you add another project where you already have a longjam and therefore trade away your best defender?
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
mudyez
I know, I know...speaking of possible trades, that never have mentioned bei either FO is retarded (start the bashing!), but:...
thinking about the possibilities and the chances of trades happening one trade makes a lot of sense to me:
http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMa...tradeId=l7zn6q
allredy mentioned it (kind of):
Thabo for Finley and Ian!
for OKC:
1) they should be interested in Ian...Mullins could be a nice project, but they could use someone like Ian as an even better prsopect...especially with Krstic beeing able to play PF for some minutes which would give them a nice big lineup
2) they should like Finley beeing the mentor to Harden and Durant
3) they are not there yet...teams like Cleveland, Boston or the Mavs wont trade with us, but they shouldnt have problems
4) Sam Pestri
for us:
1) we get that defensive wing without loosing much
2) "not much"=trading a player with good potential for a player with good potential while only adding someon who is redundant
things that speak against it:
1) Sam Pestri...he should have an open line to RC and Pop...why didnt it already happen
2) its nothing which will double our chances to become champion...it just evens out the lineup, while giving us the oportunity to pick up Bowen too
btw.: I like to play with the new lineups in NBA2k9 and Ian always seems like the player I have no use for (not with ratliff on board)
Not losing much? A 22-year-old C with quickness and athletic ability isn't a lot? Not to mention the fact that, for his age, he's actually quite developed, especially when you see the other Cs his age that are highly thought of (Thabeet, for example) and have similar talents. I understand what you're saying that Sefolosha still has potential, along with far more polish than Mahinmi. However, Mahinmi, despite what you may think, has a TON of potential (more than Sefolosha). The only thing that really stopped him from competing for a spot last year was a badly mis-diagnosed injury. Why would you give up on Mahinmi when he hasn't had a real chance to prove himself?
Not to mention the thought that even if Sefolosha had the same amount of potential that Mahinmi has with his current level of polish that:
Young, very athletic C > Young, talented, defensive wing
Why? Simply put, there are a lot more talented defensive wings out there than highly athletic centers. Hell, why not give Hairston the chance to be that defensive wing that we all covet so much? If he doesn't turn out to be that by the trade deadline, then you can make a trade for a defensive wing, and you might not have to give up as much to get him (depending if the trading partner is out of contention and desperately trying to free up cap room).
All that being said, there is absolutely ZERO reason to trade Mahinmi at the moment, and it would take Scola trade-esque stupidity for the FO to do so.
Add to that, he may turn out to be a better option at back-up C than Ratliff this season; it wouldn't shock me in the least if Mahinmi out performed the 36-year-old who only played in 46 games last year AND who has a rather long history of injury.
Oh, and also, game creators use past performances to decide the ratings of the players, so a video game is not a good indicator of future successes/failings at all, especially during the off-season.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
mahimini may still be able to offer something to the spurs and obviously the spurs FO believes this or else he would have been dumped by now.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
buujness
Not losing much? A 22-year-old C with quickness and athletic ability isn't a lot? Not to mention the fact that, for his age, he's actually quite developed, especially when you see the other Cs his age that are highly thought of (Thabeet, for example) and have similar talents. I understand what you're saying that Sefolosha still has potential, along with far more polish than Mahinmi. However, Mahinmi, despite what you may think, has a TON of potential (more than Sefolosha). The only thing that really stopped him from competing for a spot last year was a badly mis-diagnosed injury. Why would you give up on Mahinmi when he hasn't had a real chance to prove himself?
Not to mention the thought that even if Sefolosha had the same amount of potential that Mahinmi has with his current level of polish that:
Young, very athletic C > Young, talented, defensive wing
Why? Simply put, there are a lot more talented defensive wings out there than highly athletic centers. Hell, why not give Hairston the chance to be that defensive wing that we all covet so much? If he doesn't turn out to be that by the trade deadline, then you can make a trade for a defensive wing, and you might not have to give up as much to get him (depending if the trading partner is out of contention and desperately trying to free up cap room).
All that being said, there is absolutely ZERO reason to trade Mahinmi at the moment, and it would take Scola trade-esque stupidity for the FO to do so.
Add to that, he may turn out to be a better option at back-up C than Ratliff this season; it wouldn't shock me in the least if Mahinmi out performed the 36-year-old who only played in 46 games last year AND who has a rather long history of injury.
Oh, and also, game creators use past performances to decide the ratings of the players, so a video game is not a good indicator of future successes/failings at all, especially during the off-season.
don't get me wron! I like Ian! I like him very much! It's just, that I think we should win now and that said, its not that much about potential, as it is for production right now.
Lets not call Ian the next coming of Dwight Howard! Can he be good? Yeah! Can he fail badly? Absolutely! Ask the Sonics/Thunder about big players that failed (and yeah, I want to sell them one more of them).
Ian has a nice skillset but nothing thats needed at this point. I see him more on a run and gun team, with more of an offensive agenda.
In terms of C vs. Wings:
First of all: how many defensive wings do you trust to defende players like Kobe? I like Hairston too, but you need to build kind of a reputation. Bowen had it. Battier has it. Bell has it. Thabo is on the best way to earn it. Hairston has nothing like that und would need at least 2 seasons to earn it...by that time we are done anyway.
And for C>smaller players: Thats only true if you have less than 7 frontcourtplayers :-)
As for the idea to wait untill the trade deadline: I like that idea (actually said it a lot of times myself)! By that time there will be teams allready going to rebuilding mode and we might get something cheap.
I'm not the biggest fan of a Ian trade, but it would be a nice step into the "win now" mode...and even while players like Hill and Blair can contribute to that, I don't see Ian getting playoff minutes with vets like McDyess and Ratliff on board.
Could it turn out to be the next Scola f§$% up? Maybe, but in order for that Ian would have to become an allstar. We traded Scola for nothing (basically Butlers money), while we get a quallity player in the mentioned trade.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
If trading Ian or any other Spur for that matter can add value in return which increases the chance of winning a championship during Duncan's shrinking window of opportunity, then why not? All these moves since the Jefferson trade were made with this in mind.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
I can't stand how so many people think Raja Bell would improve this team.
He looked so slow in his final season with Phoenix, that Suns fans didn't even want him around. He couldn't stay in front of Manu and he didn't look any better against Kobe than Mason did.
He's not defensive stopper that he was 4 years ago and his 3pt shooting is a downgrade when compared to Mason Jr.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
cd98
Ian needs lots of minutes to develop. He won't get that in S.A. We are in win now mode. If we can get a Battier type of defender, Spurs will make that trade in a second.
Personally, I am certainly not in favor of the Spurs trading Ian for any reason. Even if the it means getting a chance to acquire a player of Battier's caliber, I would have to believe he could be had with some other combination of Finley+Bonner+???. I would really prefer Bonner be sacrificed moreso than Ian.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Phila_Chamberlain
Bonner and Finley are two players that can be traded, but in all honesty they are also two players on this roster that are not wild cards. We don't know what we are getting from Ian, Haislip, Hairston, Theo, Blair, and Williams (that is half our possible active roster). Bonner and Finley on the other hand are players who we know will give us solid minutes on offense, defense not so much.
If Larry Brown will do us a solid I say we offer Bonner and Finley for Bell? The Camby trade is less likely with a lot of bigs already on the roster, and a shot blocker semi crossed off the list. We need that outside defender/shooter and Bell can take care of that.
Our depth chart would look something like this:
Parker/Hill/Williams(?)
Bell/Mason
RJ/Manu/Hairston
Duncan/Blair/Haislip
McDyess/Ian/Theo
The worst part about that is that only 5 players were key in last year's team. I had to REALLY think about who was where because I forgot about a lot od people.
Bell would be a monster for the spurs. He's a younger bruce bowen. Great shooter and defender. He is a battier-type player. A Kobe stopper. Would really help the spurs in the postseason. Don't know if you could get him for just bonner and finley though. Might have to add a draft pick or a overseas prospect as well. I've always wanted Bell to be a Hornet, but it's wishful thinking at best.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
buujness
The only thing that really stopped him from competing for a spot last year was a badly mis-diagnosed injury.
Not debating your other points, I want to see how Ian pans out this season too. But in what way was he 'badly misdiagnosed' ? Why is it someone else's fault that he injured himself? Sometimes shit just happens, it's not necessarily someone's fault or negligence.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duncan the G.O.A.T.
Raja Bell is the Kobe stopper
He's just as good at it as Ruben Patterson was.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
mudyez
don't get me wron! I like Ian! I like him very much! It's just, that I think we should win now and that said, its not that much about potential, as it is for production right now.
Lets not call Ian the next coming of Dwight Howard! Can he be good? Yeah! Can he fail badly? Absolutely! Ask the Sonics/Thunder about big players that failed (and yeah, I want to sell them one more of them).
Ian has a nice skillset but nothing thats needed at this point. I see him more on a run and gun team, with more of an offensive agenda.
In terms of C vs. Wings:
First of all: how many defensive wings do you trust to defende players like Kobe? I like Hairston too, but you need to build kind of a reputation. Bowen had it. Battier has it. Bell has it. Thabo is on the best way to earn it. Hairston has nothing like that und would need at least 2 seasons to earn it...by that time we are done anyway.
And for C>smaller players: Thats only true if you have less than 7 frontcourtplayers :-)
As for the idea to wait untill the trade deadline: I like that idea (actually said it a lot of times myself)! By that time there will be teams allready going to rebuilding mode and we might get something cheap.
I'm not the biggest fan of a Ian trade, but it would be a nice step into the "win now" mode...and even while players like Hill and Blair can contribute to that, I don't see Ian getting playoff minutes with vets like McDyess and Ratliff on board.
Could it turn out to be the next Scola f§$% up? Maybe, but in order for that Ian would have to become an allstar. We traded Scola for nothing (basically Butlers money), while we get a quallity player in the mentioned trade.
I'm not saying Ian is the second coming of Dwight Howard. To put those expectations on him would be rediculous. However, I think that, if he can provide something like 5 pts 4 rebs in 15 mins while providing energy and defense off the bench, then he would be a solid contributor this season to a championship caliber team. I'm guessing he'd outperform Ratliff at least, and would be our best option at back-up C.
However, if, by some miracle, Houston decided to offer Battier to us for a package of Ian + Bonner/Finley, then you'd be foolish to not at least consider it. I would really only look at Battier, though, because of all the wings that you listed, Battier is by far the best defender and really the only one that I think could really slow Kobe down (the thought, though, that Raja Bell would be worth the same package is ludicrous; he was too slow to guard Kobe two years ago). All that being said, it may not be a bad idea to at least give Hairston a look at some of the better perimeter scorers in the league (at least early in the season) just to see what he's capable of.
Though, your point on bigmen never performing is well taken. I just think that Ian can contribute this year, and improve in years to come, and I would hate to see that go for something less than an absolutely fantastic deal.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
superbigtime
Not debating your other points, I want to see how Ian pans out this season too. But in what way was he 'badly misdiagnosed' ? Why is it someone else's fault that he injured himself? Sometimes shit just happens, it's not necessarily someone's fault or negligence.
You have an explanation in this article
http://www.mysanantonio.com/sports/n...t_Mahinmi.html
Quote:
Mahinmi's injury nightmare began in August, when he stepped on another player's foot during a pickup game.
Initially diagnosed as a high right ankle sprain, the injury didn't improve with rest and treatment. In November, Mahinmi tested the ankle in a Development League game with the Austin Toros and re-aggravated the injury.
Mahinmi didn't know it yet, but his season was finished. He had wasted a year of his life. He had let the organization down.
I knew they wanted me to play, to show what I can do, Mahinmi said. I wanted that so bad, too.
In January, doctors finally pinpointed the cause of Mahinmi's recurring pain. A small piece of bone had broken off and was floating around inside his ankle. It hadn't appeared on any of his previous MRIs.
Mahinmi would need season-ending surgery to correct the problem. By that point, he was the cheeriest surgery patient imaginable.
I wish I had surgery from the beginning, Mahinmi said. It's usually the last resort, but it made me feel better.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
superbigtime
Not debating your other points, I want to see how Ian pans out this season too. But in what way was he 'badly misdiagnosed' ? Why is it someone else's fault that he injured himself? Sometimes shit just happens, it's not necessarily someone's fault or negligence.
Nevermind. I was typing while the other poster was responding.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duncan the G.O.A.T.
Raja Bell is the Kobe stopper
Anyone can stop Kobe if they clothesline him driving in the lane.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duncan the G.O.A.T.
Raja Bell is the Kobe stopper
Raja Bell is the Kobe slapper
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
raja bell's washed up, it would be stupid to trade finley or ian for him. Ian has plenty of potential, hopefully we still see that this year. The Fin dog will do his thing, wit this 3's.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
duncan the g.o.a.t.
raja bell is the kobe clothliner
fyp!
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
If we are looking for 3's and some "Kobe Stopping" it could be possible to acquire Shane Battier from the Rockets if they are looking to rebuild. They are waiting to see with Yao, they let Artest walk, they're looking to trade McGrady. What good is Battier for them? Besides, they basically signed a guy who is capable of filling that role, probably not to the standard of Battier though, in Travor Ariza. Not sure I would want to give up Ian in a trade though and the Rocket's probably wouldn't accept Bonner and Finley in return.
Maybe if we can get a 3rd team involved, something like this maybe?
http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMa...tradeId=mvqqhb
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
Quote:
“The goal right now is to build as productive a team as we can this year, but also try to search out some athleticism for the future,” Buford said.
The main pieces are already in place. Makes me think they're looking at adding a young prospect wing. Might not be a fancy name and might be someone who has sorta fallen off the radar but can get the job done.
I have no clue who that might be but it's my bet they're looking at someone like that than Bell or Battier or Posey and the like.
-
Re: The Spurs Aren't Done Making Moves This Summer - What Comes Next?
I personally love Ian, I think we need to win now but also keep an eye on the future, remember once Tim and manu are gone we will be lead by a still in his prime Tony Parker who will need some motivation to want to resign with us. He needs to know he won't waste the last years of his career on a Lottery team.
the balance to this is if the FO feels that one more move can bring us a championship you do it and worry about the future later.