-
Could it happen here?
How would you feel about a law similar to what was signed in Arizona coming to Texas?
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/...n/6978757.html
it's already in the works....
-
Re: Could it happen here?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
it is but it is unlikely it passes. and certainly texas will want to see how this plays out in the courts in arizona first.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
also, texas has a more positive impact from illegals than arizona does. even perry will probably not back such a bill too much, if at all.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
Cool.
so when is the next klan meeting?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
[QUOTE=panic giraffe;4292663]so when is the next klan meeting?[/QUOTE That's it .....
-
Re: Could it happen here?
? i'm sorry, i don't read bad code.
but i thought all you teabagger types were for civil liberties? where are the libertarians calling out against this bill and the possible infringement of native born american rights that this thing will bring about?
until they do that, i'll just go on with the assumption they're just a bunch of racists.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Yeah 20 million forgien nationals invade your nation. drive down the wages and living conditions of the poorest citizens, flood the public educations system, soak up the saftey net of social programs,fill the prisons, march for amnesty under the red flag of international socialisim.......and you and this regime are worried about the illegal's civil rights..I can only assume your an Obamanation.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
Yeah 20 million forgien nationals invade your nation. drive down the wages and living conditions of the poorest citizens, flood the public educations system, soak up the saftey net of social programs,fill the prisons, march for amnesty under the red flag of international socialisim.......and you and this regime are worried about the illegal's civil rights..I can only assume your an Obamanation.
I don't know what level of education you have, but I for one, have never had my employment challenged by an undocumented immigrant. if you are a native born american and you mow lawns, pick strawberries, or clean houses etc, for a living then you have bigger issues to battle than the immigration issue.
as far as welfare, it's impossible to get without a social security card or eisn. if you want to prove me wrong go down to a HHS office and try under a assumed name, if you succeed i will retract that statement. we do give anyone insured or not, emergency care, would you rather hospitals ask for your hmo while you were in a coma and just let you die?
as far as prisons, i had a ex who's dad was a drug runner, he was here legally, as soon as he was busted, he was deported and had to serve his time in a mexican prison. if we do that to legal, documented immigrants i can't imagine how we don't do that for illegal ones.
illegals are great. not only are they the backbone of our service/manufacturing industries, but they pay taxes that they will never see a dime back from. the contribute to our social security ponzi scheme, pay gas tax, property taxes, pretty much every tax besides income tax, can't get a refund. generally speaking have children that work harder at education then the average citizen. i just can't see any downside to them, they're just chasing the american dream like the waves of immigrants before them.
no, actually i'm worried about my own civil rights. i'm brown. will i be asked to produce a passport and social security card every time i get pulled over or will my drivers license suffice? will i be pulled over more often at the assumption that i am illegal? my family never crossed the american border except to go for war for this country (and at one point against, but that's how we got here), so why should i have to deal with added interrogation when ever i see a police officer just because some peon redneck lost a roofing contract to a more skilled immigrant?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
drive down the wages
Is that wrong? I'm sorry but we live in a capitalist economy where profits are more important than wages. If I can make more money by paying an illegal 10 cents an hour than paying a good old American 10 dollars an hour so I can reep higher profits, then damn it it's my right and duty as an American who loves capitalism to do it.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Is that wrong? I'm sorry but we live in a capitalist economy where profits are more important than wages. If I can make more money by paying an illegal 10 cents an hour than paying a good old American 10 dollars an hour so I can reep higher profits, then damn it it's my right and duty as an American who loves capitalism to do it.
As long as you do it within the parameters of the law.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
I don't know what level of education you have, but I for one, have never had my employment challenged by an undocumented immigrant. if you are a native born american and you mow lawns, pick strawberries, or clean houses etc, for a living then you have bigger issues to battle than the immigration issue.
as far as welfare, it's impossible to get without a social security card or eisn. if you want to prove me wrong go down to a HHS office and try under a assumed name, if you succeed i will retract that statement. we do give anyone insured or not, emergency care, would you rather hospitals ask for your hmo while you were in a coma and just let you die?
as far as prisons, i had a ex who's dad was a drug runner, he was here legally, as soon as he was busted, he was deported and had to serve his time in a mexican prison. if we do that to legal, documented immigrants i can't imagine how we don't do that for illegal ones.
illegals are great. not only are they the backbone of our service/manufacturing industries, but they pay taxes that they will never see a dime back from. the contribute to our social security ponzi scheme, pay gas tax, property taxes, pretty much every tax besides income tax, can't get a refund. generally speaking have children that work harder at education then the average citizen. i just can't see any downside to them, they're just chasing the american dream like the waves of immigrants before them.
no, actually i'm worried about my own civil rights. i'm brown. will i be asked to produce a passport and social security card every time i get pulled over or will my drivers license suffice? will i be pulled over more often at the assumption that i am illegal? my family never crossed the american border except to go for war for this country (and at one point against, but that's how we got here), so why should i have to deal with added interrogation when ever i see a police officer just because some peon redneck lost a roofing contract to a more skilled immigrant?
For godsakes I can't believe someone with such a pedestrian education would brag about it. Yeah I think you pretty much exemplify the La Mecha party lies, it's up to the nation to decide if we want another 20 million assholes like you.
I guess all those poor americans of all colors just deserve what they get.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
For godsakes I can't believe someone with such a pedestrian education would brag about it. Yeah I think you pretty much exemplify the La Mecha party lies, it's up to the nation to decide if we want another 20 million assholes like you.
I guess all those poor americans of all colors just deserve what they get.
my god man how many times do i have to tell you...its just fucking MEChA, drop the la, it makes you look uneducated.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
and honestly you feel like it's okay for the government of certain states to infringe on the rights of its citizens for the sole purpose of tracking down a few people who came her illegally.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
... it's up to the nation to decide if we want another 20 million assholes like you...
but i'm not illegal. you're probably a few more generations removed from being a border jumper than i am.
way to let your racism show.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
As long as you do it within the parameters of the law.
Oh..isn't that convenient? So now we're placing limits on capitalism?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
and honestly you feel like it's okay for the government of certain states to infringe on the rights of its citizens for the sole purpose of tracking down a few people who came her illegally.
20 million illegals is not a few people it's close to the population of the entire nation of italy.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
my god man how many times do i have to tell you...its just fucking MEChA, drop the la, it makes you look uneducated.
using expressions like "my god man" makes you look like a semiliterate posturing buffoon emulating some 19th century english novel, you know like a babu. I like using La Mecha cause he gets you so riled up.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
but i'm not illegal. you're probably a few more generations removed from being a border jumper than i am.
way to let your racism show.
Yeah dude, really you can call me a racist all day, but it doesn't matter a pile of beans to me but hey knock yourself out.
What I meant by assholes like you is the whole La Mecha motto of "for those of the race everything, for those outside the race nothing" I'm sure you're aware of their motto, I mean even the council of La Raza was so embarassed be La Mecha's blatant racist overtones that they offically distantsed themselves.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Oh..isn't that convenient? So now we're placing limits on capitalism?
Aren't you supposed to be in class, they're just about to pass out the milk and cookies.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
the whole La Mecha motto of "for those of the race everything, for those outside the race nothing"
You translate "La union haze la fuerza?" to "for those of the race everything, for those outside the race nothing?"
Unless I missed something, you probably shouldn't diss Panic's education.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by micca
using expressions like "my god man" makes you look like a semiliterate posturing buffoon emulating some 19th century english novel
Reminds me of your own semiliterate posturing familiarity with Charles Dickens in these pages, in which you were the butt of the joke:
http://www.spurstalk.com/forums/show...6&postcount=60
-
Re: Could it happen here?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
so when is the next klan meeting?
we have a winner.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
I don't know what level of education you have, but I for one, have never had my employment challenged by an undocumented immigrant.
Are you saying it doesn't happen because you never have seen it? I had a friend who's dad mowed yards and made a good living. He was definitely pushed out because he couldn't compete with the low wages people were offering.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
and honestly you feel like it's okay for the government of certain states to infringe on the rights of its citizens for the sole purpose of tracking down a few people who came her illegally.
illegals are not citizens
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Oh..isn't that convenient? So now we're placing limits on capitalism?
So you are against unions and cartels?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
calling someone who you disagree with racist just devalues the true meaning of that word.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
illegals are not citizens
I was referring to myself. are you calling me illegal just because i'm brown?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
calling someone who you disagree with racist just devalues the true meaning of that word.
calling a native born american, former soldier, an illegal based solely on the color of his skin is racist, wouldn't you agree?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
Are you saying it doesn't happen because you never have seen it? I had a friend who's dad mowed yards and made a good living. He was definitely pushed out because he couldn't compete with the low wages people were offering.
he should have made a better product, or sold his customer on his service and English speaking ability. If he had some american ingenuity he would remain competitive and would have grew his business using those same hard working illegals.
what i was stabbing at was how if your skills set isn't even competitive with someone who can effectively communicate to the majority of the population, then you have bigger problems (like finding a new skill set or trade) than the issue of immigration.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
he should have made a better product, or sold his customer on his service and English speaking ability. If he had some american ingenuity he would remain competitive and would have grew his business using those same hard working illegals.
what i was stabbing at was how if your skills set isn't even competitive with someone who can effectively communicate to the majority of the population, then you have bigger problems (like finding a new skill set or trade) than the issue of immigration.
There are over 1 billion people on this planet that make less than a dollar a day.None of them live in latin america.How's about we take oil tankers over to say India and empty it's ghettos, I could find harder, cheaper, labor who'd speak english faster than any mexican in the U.S. hell I could sneak them into Mexico and undercut Mexicans in Mexico, but of course that'd be illegal.
Your asinine idea that the poor have no one to blame but themselves for greedy assholes breaking the laws and hiring illegals, thus driving wages and conditions for all workers down, reminds me of the shortsighted and pig ignorant attitudes that prevade and exemplify Latin America.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
calling a native born american, former soldier, an illegal based solely on the color of his skin is racist, wouldn't you agree?
yeah.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
Ahh precious.Are you once again courageously standing up for the manufactured consent of the time, wrapping yourself in the New Yorker and NPR hoping you can pass for intelligent.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
he should have made a better product, or sold his customer on his service and English speaking ability. If he had some american ingenuity he would remain competitive and would have grew his business using those same hard working illegals.
his ethics wouldn't allow him to. I gave you one sentence of how illegal immigration impacted his family directly, and you put him in a little bubble where you can give him some absurd advice. Why are you even assuming he spoke english? douchebag. I try not to namecall here, but this is ridiculous. Anyone who agrees with this law is racist? Your ridunculous assumptions. Get off your high horse. Clinton/Bush/Obama should have done something on a national level. They should have some form of security for the citizens of this state that made the law, which is backed by 70% of their population.
Quote:
what i was stabbing at was how if your skills set isn't even competitive with someone who can effectively communicate to the majority of the population, then you have bigger problems (like finding a new skill set or trade) than the issue of immigration.
same could be said by all the jobs going over seas. Are you ok with all the jobs going elsewhere because the skills aren't good enough?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
So you are against unions and cartels?
Unions are socialist and communist.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
illegals are not citizens
No one is saying they are dumbass. The arguement against the entire immigration law that passed in Arizona is the constitutionality of pulling people over who simply "look" illegal.
What does an illegal immigrant look like? The law in Arizona makes reference that the cops should have reasonable suspicion, well what does that even mean?
panic giraffe and myself are both brown skin very ethnic looking mexicans I'm assuming. Are we going to be pulled over and asked for proof of residency? I would object very strongly to anyone who asks me for it. I'm sure that's very unconstitutional.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Unions are socialist and communist.
it's artificial control of the free market. What are you talking about?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
me
illegals are not citizens
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
are you calling me illegal just because i'm brown?
what?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
I don't know what level of education you have, but I for one, have never had my employment challenged by an undocumented immigrant. if you are a native born american and you mow lawns, pick strawberries, or clean houses etc, for a living then you have bigger issues to battle than the immigration issue.
as far as welfare, it's impossible to get without a social security card or eisn. if you want to prove me wrong go down to a HHS office and try under a assumed name, if you succeed i will retract that statement. we do give anyone insured or not, emergency care, would you rather hospitals ask for your hmo while you were in a coma and just let you die?
as far as prisons, i had a ex who's dad was a drug runner, he was here legally, as soon as he was busted, he was deported and had to serve his time in a mexican prison. if we do that to legal, documented immigrants i can't imagine how we don't do that for illegal ones.
illegals are great. not only are they the backbone of our service/manufacturing industries, but they pay taxes that they will never see a dime back from. the contribute to our social security ponzi scheme, pay gas tax, property taxes, pretty much every tax besides income tax, can't get a refund. generally speaking have children that work harder at education then the average citizen. i just can't see any downside to them, they're just chasing the american dream like the waves of immigrants before them.
no, actually i'm worried about my own civil rights. i'm brown. will i be asked to produce a passport and social security card every time i get pulled over or will my drivers license suffice? will i be pulled over more often at the assumption that i am illegal? my family never crossed the american border except to go for war for this country (and at one point against, but that's how we got here), so why should i have to deal with added interrogation when ever i see a police officer just because some peon redneck lost a roofing contract to a more skilled immigrant?
Yours is the most compelling argument so far that I have heard against immigration reform.
But why have immigration laws at all, by your reasoning?
My father was an immigrant. It took years of service and sacrifice to the US to gain citizenship, which he is quite proud of. It does bother him that he is in a position where he is under more of a microscope from organizations like the IRS than his illegal counterparts. Not to mention the fact that there is a bit of a conflict of interested in having people working in a place they have no interest in living in or supporting.
I am with Maddox, I think there isn't a problem as long as the workers are paying taxes.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
it's artificial control of the free market. What are you talking about?
Artificial control of the free market? What the fuck are you talking about? Explain how a union, that demands higher wages and will threaten with strikes is "artificially" controlling the free market?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Artificial control of the free market? What the fuck are you talking about? Explain how a union, that demands higher wages and will threaten with strikes is "artificially" controlling the free market?
I find it laughable that on one hand you support unions, and on the other hand you support the explotation of labor laws, and the ruling classes rape of the workers, just because it's wrapped in a mexican flag.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
No one is saying they are dumbass. The arguement against the entire immigration law that passed in Arizona is the constitutionality of pulling people over who simply "look" illegal.
What does an illegal immigrant look like? The law in Arizona makes reference that the cops should have reasonable suspicion, well what does that even mean?
panic giraffe and myself are both brown skin very ethnic looking mexicans I'm assuming. Are we going to be pulled over and asked for proof of residency? I would object very strongly to anyone who asks me for it. I'm sure that's very unconstitutional.
ding ding ding we have a winner here folks!!!
what surprises me is that all these "keep govt out of my healthcare" types are all for "paper's please"...
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
I find it laughable that on one hand you support unions, and on the other hand you support the explotation of labor laws, and the ruling classes rape of the workers, just because it's wrapped in a mexican flag.
Where in my two posts calling unions socialists and communists, and then asking for clarification on how they are "artificially" controlling the market with their tactics, is there a clear support for Unions?
Have you not learned anything? I'm an American, and as such, I care only for capitalism and profits.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
what?
that was addressed to hope4dopes, micca or whathaveyou saying "if the american people want 20 million more of you..." like i was an illegal alien.
to which i rightfully called him racist just because he would assume that since i'm of mexican decent and i'm brown that i'm just like 20 million illegal aliens.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
ding ding ding we have a winner here folks!!!
what surprises me is that all these "keep govt out of my healthcare" types are all for "paper's please"...
Well unlike health care....... one of the only jobs of the federal goverment is to protect the borders, which they haven't done.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jacobdrj
Yours is the most compelling argument so far that I have heard against immigration reform.
But why have immigration laws at all, by your reasoning?
My father was an immigrant. It took years of service and sacrifice to the US to gain citizenship, which he is quite proud of. It does bother him that he is in a position where he is under more of a microscope from organizations like the IRS than his illegal counterparts. Not to mention the fact that there is a bit of a conflict of interested in having people working in a place they have no interest in living in or supporting.
I am with Maddox, I think there isn't a problem as long as the workers are paying taxes.
actually i'm all for a new way of thinking about citizenship. i'm all for a complete open border, with universal healthcare, free education, social security, basically any service that would lead to MH's post earlier of FDR's 2nd bill of rights....but there's a catch...
minimum two years of service to the country to attain the status of citizen.
if you don't serve, then you're just a tax payer. no vote. nothing. lets see how soon we rush to war when it involves everyone....but that's just a weird fantasy. til then i'm all for a better work visa program.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
actually i'm all for a new way of thinking about citizenship. i'm all for a complete open border, with universal healthcare, free education, social security, basically any service that would lead to MH's post earlier of FDR's 2nd bill of rights....but there's a catch...
minimum two years of service to the country to attain the status of citizen.
if you don't serve, then you're just a tax payer. no vote. nothing. lets see how soon we rush to war when it involves everyone....but that's just a weird fantasy. til then i'm all for a better work visa program.
Communist.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Communist.
not at all.
all for a free market.
a true free market, the govt should have no say in what i want to buy(food, drinks, liquor, drugs, who cares its my choice), but the ability to tax it as it sees fit based on consumption.
edit note:fuck i wasted post 666 on this shit. damn this thread.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
We should have the EXACT same immigration policies as Mexico.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
word
We should have the EXACT same immigration policies as Mexico.
Agreed.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Your an idiot...the Mexican laws are tough to attempt keep South American immigrants from migrating to America in mass...nobody migrates to Mexico..
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nbadan
Your an idiot...the Mexican laws are tough to attempt keep South American immigrants from migrating to America in mass...nobody migrates to Mexico..
And, ours should be tough to attempt to keep Mexicans from migrating to America en mass.
I don't see the issue.
And, actually, you're wrong. Aside from border areas, Mexico is an attractive retirement destination for many Americans.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
And, ours should be tough to attempt to keep Mexicans from migrating to America en mass.
I don't see the issue.
They are tough, but unenforceable...so what good are new laws going to do? For the Arizona taxpayer its gonna be billions...
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
And, actually, you're wrong. Aside from border areas, Mexico is an attractive retirement destination for many Americans.
Many rich Mexicans migrate to the U.S. to retire, so what?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nbadan
Many rich Mexicans migrate to the U.S. to retire, so what?
And, both probably do so legally.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nbadan
They are tough, but unenforceable...so what good are new laws going to do? For the Arizona taxpayer its gonna be billions...
I guess we'll see.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nbadan
Your an idiot...the Mexican laws are tough to attempt keep South American immigrants from migrating to America in mass...nobody migrates to Mexico..
Yeah, except, not so much about keeping South Americans out of the United States...
Mexico acknowledges migrant abuse, pledges changes
Quote:
Central American migrants are frequently pulled off trains, kidnapped en masse, held at gang hideouts and forced to call relatives in the U.S. to pay off the kidnappers. Such kidnappings affect thousands of migrants each year in Mexico, the report says.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
actually i'm all for a new way of thinking about citizenship. i'm all for a complete open border, with universal healthcare, free education, social security, basically any service that would lead to MH's post earlier of FDR's 2nd bill of rights....but there's a catch...
minimum two years of service to the country to attain the status of citizen.
if you don't serve, then you're just a tax payer. no vote. nothing. lets see how soon we rush to war when it involves everyone....but that's just a weird fantasy. til then i'm all for a better work visa program.
So what you are proposing is basically the Israeli system. Their situation is a bit different (small country with a small population with a disproportionately large border with almost no natural resources surrounded on all sides by aggressive nations/peoples).
Let me posit some issues that may come up with your system:
A) With a volunteer army you may have a higher level of morale due to the fact that the people volunteered.
B) As far as getting out of service, politicians have always found a way to have themselves, as well as their families, either excluded from mandatory service or at least put in 'cushy' BS clerk jobs outside the real spheres of danger. I doubt many politicians would think any differently about the mandatory service as they would still be apart from it.
C) Just because everyone serves doesn't mean taxes will be less of an issue. Health care will still cost money, and for 2 years of every person's young adult life, they wouldn't even have the option of being a productive member of society to add value to the system, and be taxed, to be able to pay for a VA style health system (which from my parents' experience, is quite impressive and extensive).
D) You would likely get refuseniks, much like in Israel now and the US in the Vietnam era, and would have a huge part of the population thrown in jail for that.
E) The military is trying to downsize even while in the middle of 2 wars. What would a military of 90 million do?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Nonetheless, what is wrong with having the same policy as Mexico regarding immigration, foreign investment and entire host of other things ? Fact is, no one has as open of a country as the US yet ...if there is any talk of enforcing the law....the words Nazi and racist come up.
The issue of immigration, legal or otherwise, is unique along the southern border. Further, the changes to immigration law during the Johnson administration, allowing 'reunification' heavily favored Mexican immigrants because Europeans had long since cut ties to their European heritage. Most European Americans don't even KNOW any family in the old country even though they all HAVE family in the old country.
In the 1920's the last time there was a large scale reform in immigration policy, prior to the 60's, was decidedly...purposefully..ANTI Asian, to stem the tide of Chinese immigration.
But I"m not sure, if during any time in our history we've had a huge problem with illegal immigration like we have now simply because it's too hard to illegally immigrate across oceans.
Further, the immigration policies of the US have historically TRIED to have policy based on needs. Granted, there has always been a way for those seeking political asylum to get in, if they can prove their life is in danger, but what we're seeing here, to a degree is simply a government saying to a group of immigrants...you're not what we need. It's happened before. We let a ton of engineers in during the tech boom. It's not so easy to get in now and there are fewer HB1 visa's available for tech workers, and fewer people getting in in ALL areas.
The bottom line is, it's our country, and we have a right to say who gets in and in what numbers. The majority of people support that. Just follow the rules. We let plenty of people in taking the legal route.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Wgaf what race you are.
If you are not American, GTFO. We can't even take care of our own problems caused by our own americants.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
.
illegals are great. not only are they the backbone of our service/manufacturing industries, but they pay taxes that they will never see a dime back from. they contribute to our social security ponzi scheme, pay gas tax, property taxes, pretty much every tax besides income tax, can't get a refund. generally speaking have children that work harder at education then the average citizen. i just can't see any downside to them, they're just chasing the american dream like the waves of immigrants before them.
No they don't. They are illegal and therefore don't have a SS card. Their employer can't legally have them on the payroll to pay those taxes. They aren't on the books or if they are the employer, if audited, will be prosecuted or at least heavily fined. That's one of the main reasons illegals are so attractive to some business owners. They don't have to match the SS and medicare taxes. So if you take all the wages earned by illegals and tax it at 30% - 15 from them and 15 from the business - you will get an idea of the amount of monies missing from the US Treasury. Also those businesses that choose to hire illegals don't have to pay them health benefits if they don't want to.
I wont argue that illegals don't benefit our society but they are still non citizens with little stake in this country. They are here due to the fact that their own country can't establish a stable economy and therefore there is a lack of viable work. They are here to help provide for their families. That is an admirable goal but let's not forget that they are here illegally. Any country has the right to establish laws in order to protect their sovereinty, ilrespective of the goals and desires of the illegals, however honorable.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
word
Further, the immigration policies of the US have historically TRIED to have policy based on needs. Granted, there has always been a way for those seeking political asylum to get in, if they can prove their life is in danger, but what we're seeing here, to a degree is simply a government saying to a group of immigrants...you're not what we need. It's happened before. We let a ton of engineers in during the tech boom. It's not so easy to get in now and there are fewer HB1 visa's available for tech workers, and fewer people getting in in ALL areas.
The bottom line is, it's our country, and we have a right to say who gets in and in what numbers. The majority of people support that. Just follow the rules. We let plenty of people in taking the legal route.
Agreed. This country should be able to determine who gets in or who doesn't. This isn't an issue based on race, creed or clolor but what type of individual this nation finds desirable to have as a citizen.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Passing this law as a "cry for help" or "defiant stance" toward the Federal government until we can put the Senate and House and Administration officials before the American people to explain why "we are not ready" to discuss Immigration is cutting off your nose to spite your face.
The crime levels will stay the same, except the community won't be as helpful because they feel offended and less inclined to work with police. They could be right in that offense, they could be wrong to take offense - but it will happen and it will have an effect on normal citizens and Local Law Enforcement.
It won't happen here and if it did, you can bet your boy Stringer would be on top of that shit naming names and shaming them. Texas Reps. Leo Berman (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/0..._n_552239.html ) and Debbie Riddle are planning to introduce legistlation...these people talk so much shit but don't have the balls to go after the real problems.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
Are you saying it doesn't happen because you never have seen it? I had a friend who's dad mowed yards and made a good living. He was definitely pushed out because he couldn't compete with the low wages people were offering.
That's called capitalism.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jacobdrj
E) The military is trying to downsize even while in the middle of 2 wars. What would a military of 90 million do?
I will note that there is a program for citizenship for immigrants who join the military. I'm not familiar with the specifics, but serving a certain number of years allows you citizenship.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
it's artificial control of the free market. What are you talking about?
How is it artificial? Unions go perfectly in line with capitalism, in theory. (Some laws protecting workers on strike throw it off a little bit.)
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jacobdrj
So what you are proposing is basically the Israeli system. Their situation is a bit different (small country with a small population with a disproportionately large border with almost no natural resources surrounded on all sides by aggressive nations/peoples).
Let me posit some issues that may come up with your system:
A) With a volunteer army you may have a higher level of morale due to the fact that the people volunteered.
B) As far as getting out of service, politicians have always found a way to have themselves, as well as their families, either excluded from mandatory service or at least put in 'cushy' BS clerk jobs outside the real spheres of danger. I doubt many politicians would think any differently about the mandatory service as they would still be apart from it.
C) Just because everyone serves doesn't mean taxes will be less of an issue. Health care will still cost money, and for 2 years of every person's young adult life, they wouldn't even have the option of being a productive member of society to add value to the system, and be taxed, to be able to pay for a VA style health system (which from my parents' experience, is quite impressive and extensive).
D) You would likely get refuseniks, much like in Israel now and the US in the Vietnam era, and would have a huge part of the population thrown in jail for that.
E) The military is trying to downsize even while in the middle of 2 wars. What would a military of 90 million do?
not at all.
the isreali system is kind of a basis, but their system is mandatory.
what i purposed earlier is a system where its still 100% voluntary. you just don't have full on citizens rights unless you do it. no right to vote, your education ends at high school (unless you want to float it either yourself or through debt), no universal healthcare, no social security. you would be a 100% private person, however you would still be liable for things like property taxes, income tax, etc. so there would be no military of 90 million or overcrowded jails full of dodgers and the like. plus, i never said it had to be military service, i believe civil service is just as important, especially for those who cannot perform the function of military service, so for those municipalites that have a hard time filling in their police, emts, fireman, teachers, etc...
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
NFGIII
No they don't. They are illegal and therefore don't have a SS card. Their employer can't legally have them on the payroll to pay those taxes. They aren't on the books or if they are the employer, if audited, will be prosecuted or at least heavily fined. That's one of the main reasons illegals are so attractive to some business owners. They don't have to match the SS and medicare taxes. So if you take all the wages earned by illegals and tax it at 30% - 15 from them and 15 from the business - you will get an idea of the amount of monies missing from the US Treasury. Also those businesses that choose to hire illegals don't have to pay them health benefits if they don't want to.
i made it pretty clear that they didn't pay income tax. i'm sorry that i forgot to mention payroll, which is kind of a 50/50 roll of the dice when it comes to illegal immigrants, some of them have stolen ssn or expired eisn, so they would still not only pay property tax, gas tax, sales tax, hotel tax, any other consumption based tax, but also pay into medicare/social security and will never see a dime back from that. i doubt they would get an income tax refund, because you would have to be pretty bold to try to get a refund with a illegal ssn. not only that but those businesses pay taxes on them as well. the rest still pay consumption based taxes, its not like you can walk into a store and say, "fuck your 8% i'm not a citizen so i'm not paying it"
Quote:
Originally Posted by
NFGIII
I wont argue that illegals don't benefit our society but they are still non citizens with little stake in this country. They are here due to the fact that their own country can't establish a stable economy and therefore there is a lack of viable work. They are here to help provide for their families. That is an admirable goal but let's not forget that they are here illegally. Any country has the right to establish laws in order to protect their sovereinty, ilrespective of the goals and desires of the illegals, however honorable.
just an opinion. one that i think a country that is bases on ideals and immigration, not nationality should not and can not afford to keep.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hope4dopes
There are over 1 billion people on this planet that make less than a dollar a day.None of them live in latin america.
I know dopes is a proper name for you because not only are you a dope, you spout bullshit that isn't even true.
According to the 2009 HDR this is the percentage of people who live in extreme poverty in Latin America...(less than $1.25/day)
Argentina...4.5%
Bolivia...19.6%
Brazil...5.2%
Colombia..16%
El Salvador...11%
Guatemala...11.7%
Honduras...18.2%
That's not even all the Latin American countries. Stop making baseless claims. I'd say alot of people that live off less than $1 a day live in Latin America.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
what i purposed earlier is a system where its still 100% voluntary. you just don't have full on citizens rights unless you do it. no right to vote, your education ends at high school (unless you want to float it either yourself or through debt), no universal healthcare, no social security. you would be a 100% private person, however you would still be liable for things like property taxes, income tax, etc. so there would be no military of 90 million or overcrowded jails full of dodgers and the like. plus, i never said it had to be military service, i believe civil service is just as important, especially for those who cannot perform the function of military service, so for those municipalites that have a hard time filling in their police, emts, fireman, teachers, etc...
I know it's just a pipe dream, but that would never fly in the United States. The Constitution exists specifically to prevent things like taht from happening.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
i know it is, and never will happen here. it's just my long term dream solution to the immigration issue.
i do however believe that most of this country has the constitution wrong. it was never meant to be a bible or the 1297 version of the magna carta, it's a living fucking document. it's amendable to deal with the problems facing a changing nation. it's the will of the collective people of our nation and should not be seen as the ten commandments, if there is something in it we don't agree with or that needs changing we should not be afraid to do it, that would make our founding fathers happy.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
***fucking la migra made me doublepost***
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
LnGrrrR
I will note that there is a program for citizenship for immigrants who join the military. I'm not familiar with the specifics, but serving a certain number of years allows you citizenship.
I am aware of that, as that is how my father got his citizenship.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
not at all.
the isreali system is kind of a basis, but their system is mandatory.
what i purposed earlier is a system where its still 100% voluntary. you just don't have full on citizens rights unless you do it. no right to vote, your education ends at high school (unless you want to float it either yourself or through debt), no universal healthcare, no social security. you would be a 100% private person, however you would still be liable for things like property taxes, income tax, etc. so there would be no military of 90 million or overcrowded jails full of dodgers and the like. plus, i never said it had to be military service, i believe civil service is just as important, especially for those who cannot perform the function of military service, so for those municipalites that have a hard time filling in their police, emts, fireman, teachers, etc...
True, even in Israel, some students as well as women do not have to serve. And I understand your distinction in that you are not compelled to joint the military except to have 'full' citizenship, where incentive is not compulsion.
I still feel that there is something that may overly militarize the country: would this eventually lead to 'haves' and 'have nots' in this system, should people be voted out of the right to join a service corps?
If it is voluntary, how will this address the issue of the politicians being separate from the citizens they deploy to war?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
The union pretty much fought the civil war with German and Irish immigrants. About 30%. They'd have lost without 'em.
So, immigration has, historically, had a purpose.
Getting your lawn mowed cheap, ain't a good reason.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jacobdrj
True, even in Israel, some students as well as women do not have to serve. And I understand your distinction in that you are not compelled to joint the military except to have 'full' citizenship, where incentive is not compulsion.
I still feel that there is something that may overly militarize the country: would this eventually lead to 'haves' and 'have nots' in this system, should people be voted out of the right to join a service corps?
If it is voluntary, how will this address the issue of the politicians being separate from the citizens they deploy to war?
how would that system of haves and have-nots be any worse than the current one? except it would be based on experience/national pride and not money or color.
i don't know what you mean by voted out of the right to join. explain please?
politicians would all be experienced citizen-soldiers after one generations time, and the parents/grandparents of another generation of citizen-soldiers. it would be the opposite of mitt romney, or dick cheney, no more war mongering politicians who don't have a personal, not just financial, stake in the war. could you vote your own son or daughter to the battlefield unless you truly believed it was the right thing to do?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
i know it is, and never will happen here. it's just my long term dream solution to the immigration issue.
i do however believe that most of this country has the constitution wrong. it was never meant to be a bible or the 1297 version of the magna carta, it's a living fucking document. it's amendable to deal with the problems facing a changing nation. it's the will of the collective people of our nation and should not be seen as the ten commandments, if there is something in it we don't agree with or that needs changing we should not be afraid to do it, that would make our founding fathers happy.
Clearly you are not aware of the process.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
I know dopes is a proper name for you because not only are you a dope, you spout bullshit that isn't even true.
According to the 2009 HDR this is the percentage of people who live in extreme poverty in Latin America...(less than $1.25/day)
Argentina...4.5%
Bolivia...19.6%
Brazil...5.2%
Colombia..16%
El Salvador...11%
Guatemala...11.7%
Honduras...18.2%
That's not even all the Latin American countries. Stop making baseless claims. I'd say alot of people that live off less than $1 a day live in Latin America.
The purpose of US immigration is not to alleviate poverty in other countries.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
word
Clearly you are not aware of the process.
what do you mean?
it's not like i believe that one person can make these changes.
we control congress(to a degree), they decided what amendments go before a vote. its not like the constitution is written in stone, so what am i not aware of?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
or a constitutional convention...
You appeared to be unaware there was a process to do this, implying the constitution could be amended on a 'whim'.
What in the Constitution do you desire to be changed ?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
nothing in particular at this time, it was in response to someone saying that the constitution was in place to keep ideas like mine from happening.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
back to the subject at hand, does anyone think AZSB1070 or something similar would happen in the great state of texas?
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
jacobdrj
I am aware of that, as that is how my father got his citizenship.
Props to your father. :toast
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
back to the subject at hand, does anyone think AZSB1070 or something similar would happen in the great state of texas?
No.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
from my understanding of this law. If someone is under police custody already, only then can police ask their citizenship. I don't see how that can be construed as racist.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
spursncowboys
from my understanding of this law. If someone is under police custody already, only then can police ask their citizenship. I don't see how that can be construed as racist.
The way I read it (from the excerpt posted by Crooks upstream), no custody is necessary. Just "lawful contact".
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
The way I read it (from the excerpt posted by Crooks upstream), no custody is necessary. Just "lawful contact".
If police custody were a necessary precondition, then this law wouldn't be nearly so bad.
Lawful contact would seem to include victims, witnesses . . . heck, even purely consensual, friendly encounters with police officers.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
Is that wrong? I'm sorry but we live in a capitalist economy where profits are more important than wages. If I can make more money by paying an illegal 10 cents an hour than paying a good old American 10 dollars an hour so I can reep higher profits, then damn it it's my right and duty as an American who loves capitalism to do it.
OK, I have too much catching up to do, I may read the posts after this one (#10) later.
I am all for opening the borders under the following conditions.
1) We eliminate all social welfare programs except for the elderly and handicapped.
Well, that's it. Then the lazy will have to compete in a supply and demand job market where the supply of labor is dramatically increased.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Wild Cobra
OK, I have too much catching up to do, I may read the posts after this one (#10) later.
I am all for opening the borders under the following conditions.
1) We eliminate all social welfare programs except for the elderly and handicapped.
Well, that's it. Then the lazy will have to compete in a supply and demand job market where the supply of labor is dramatically increased.
Social welfare for the elderly and handicapped? You socialist commie...get out of my country and go back to mother Russia.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
doobs
If police custody were a necessary precondition, then this law wouldn't be nearly so bad.
Lawful contact would seem to include victims, witnesses . . . heck, even purely consensual, friendly encounters with police officers.
You have 'contact' with law enforcment all the time and aren't aware of it. A cop pulls up behind you at a light late at night, you can bet he's running your plate. They run people plates randomly all the time, at all times of day and night. Further, carrying a valid ID with you has been the law for umpteen fucking years in most states. Is it enforced, no, but it's the law.
What I find funny is 'this law is wrong' because it catches people breaking the law, mentality. And for all those latino's raising hell about it, I'd bet their tune would change if millions of Haitians, legal and illegal, were pouring into LA or San Antonio or Phoenix.
And lets be real about this, there is plenty of racism in the Mexican American community. There are turf wars going on out in LA between blacks and latinos. When blacks start moving into what was primarily latino communities, they become unhinged.
All that 'La Raza' 'reconquista' bullshit is just stupid macho racist crap.
What I would like to see is Mexican Americans be more Mexican American and less Mexican American.
And most are, but a significant portion, particularly in SoCal, are not.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
panic giraffe
back to the subject at hand, does anyone think AZSB1070 or something similar would happen in the great state of texas?
I hope TX has something that penalizes the people who employ them, with a higher punishment for paying below what they would pay an american citizen. I hoped they already were allowed to question someones' citizenship. I also hope they have a plan to secure tx's international border and the border to oklahoma.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
IDK if it changed or not but a few years ago, TX was the only state where police can stop for no reason. If they had a law in TX, they would have to put that into account when making the wording.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
word
What I would like to see is Mexican Americans be more Mexican American and less Mexican American.
What does that even mean? Honestly, and I'm also sure panic giraffe can chime in here too.
I was having this debate with my friend the other day, he was saying I mean you and I we're Mexicans but we act American. As in Mexican heritage but we were born and raised here, but what does that mean?
His response...I don't know what it means to act American.
I eat tortillas with my meals more than I do bread and butter, does that make me more or less American? I prefer mexican pastries over apple pie, does that make me mexican or american?
I don't think anyone really knows what it means to be American. Some might say speaking English but they speak English in England, Australia, and New Zealand...that doesn't really distinguish Americans.
I think that argument is flawed because no one can really define what it really means, and I mean really means to be American. The fact that we're such a melting pot of different cultures makes it impossible to define.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Cops everywhere can stop you for no reason. They're not suppose to but it's called 'probable cause' and 'suspicious behaviour' and 'crossing the center line' and 'not coming to a complete stop' and 'irratic behaviour' and on and on and on....
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Duff McCartney
What does that even mean? Honestly, and I'm also sure panic giraffe can chime in here too.
I was having this debate with my friend the other day, he was saying I mean you and I we're Mexicans but we act American. As in Mexican heritage but we were born and raised here, but what does that mean?
His response...I don't know what it means to act American.
I eat tortillas with my meals more than I do bread and butter, does that make me more or less American? I prefer mexican pastries over apple pie, does that make me mexican or american?
I don't think anyone really knows what it means to be American. Some might say speaking English but they speak English in England, Australia, and New Zealand...that doesn't really distinguish Americans.
I think that argument is flawed because no one can really define what it really means, and I mean really means to be American. The fact that we're such a melting pot of different cultures makes it impossible to define.
It means loyalty to nation, not race or country of origin. You're thinking in terms of 'culture'. That's not what I"m talking about. It has nothing, zip, to do with culture.
What it means is, a lot of latino's it seems, want to turn a blind eye to illegal immigration from mexico and latin America because they are 'latino'. This is a racial view to this issue. As I said in another thread, if millions of Haitans began pouring into Arizona and Socal and SA illegally and even legally, latinos would be up in fucking arms. If you don't think so you're either a fool or a liar.
American culture is impossible to define ? American culture permeates the world. It is the most exported 'culture' in the world.
Hollywood, fast food, freeways, blue jeans, rock and roll, baseball, microsoft,
the space shuttle, going to the moon ie some of the best scientists in the world, new york, the grand canyon, D-day, pickup trucks, country western, jazz, hugh hefner, disneyland, Miami beach, LA, New Orleans, NFL, NBA ...muscle cars, chevrolet, apple pie, thanksgiving, college football, Boeing, the Hoover Dam, the Golden Gate Bridge... Vietnam, 911, Kennedy assassination, civil rights, slavery, the American revolution, the Alamo, PARIS FUCKING HILTON...
There is no American culture ?
A culture is made up of history, failures and accomplishments, and the people who make it up. Every country has a culture, including us.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
word
Cops everywhere can stop you for no reason. They're not suppose to but it's called 'probable cause' and 'suspicious behaviour' and 'crossing the center line' and 'not coming to a complete stop' and 'irratic behaviour' and on and on and on....
true and i think the texas law i was refering to were for dui's. other states can only stop people if they violated the law. in texas you could get stopped just so the police could see if you were drunk.
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
the border to oklahoma.
Damn Okies! Kick em out!
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
word
Cops everywhere can stop you for no reason. They're not suppose to but it's called 'probable cause' and 'suspicious behaviour' and 'crossing the center line' and 'not coming to a complete stop' and 'irratic behaviour' and on and on and on....
They can do it, but it has to be able to stand up in court.....this is, supported by physical evidence, witnesses, and such...if the case is weak, its likely to be plead down, sometimes way down..
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
What it means is, a lot of latino's it seems, want to turn a blind eye to illegal immigration from mexico and latin America because they are 'latino'. This is a racial view to this issue. As I said in another thread, if millions of Haitans began pouring into Arizona and Socal and SA illegally and even legally, latinos would be up in fucking arms. If you don't think so you're either a fool or a liar.
Ever hear of Cesar Chavez? A lot of Mexican-decent and even recent immigrants from Mexico-Americans don't want unrestricted immigration either...it kills border salaries for the most menial jobs, which is all the skill sets recent immigrants can offer an employer...
-
Re: Could it happen here?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nbadan
Ever hear of Cesar Chavez? A lot of Mexican-decent and even recent immigrants from Mexico-Americans don't want unrestricted immigration either...it kills border salaries for the most menial jobs, which is all the skill sets recent immigrants can offer an employer...
So why all the uproar ? What's it all about ?