-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
How long do we have to stay?
long enough for france to return the "dien ben phu" favor.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Offensively = without provocation
I'd say summarily throwing all members of one political party out of work and barring them from ever participating in government again was pretty provocative, to say nothing of the armed forces.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
How long do we have to stay?
I'd say permanently. Good strategic position for potential future campaigns.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
I'd say permanently. Good strategic position for potential future campaigns.
So you're hoping for imperial success.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ChumpDumper
I'd say summarily throwing all members of one political party out of work and barring them from ever participating in government again was pretty provocative, to say nothing of the armed forces.
IIRC, Saddam's old party is allowed to hold office in the new government.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
IIRC, Saddam's old party is allowed to hold office in the new government.
:lol
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ChumpDumper
So you're hoping for imperial success.
Our presence in Japan 55 years later is imperialism? I don't see how we're constructing or controlling their government at this point.
I simply said that it would be good for us to maintain a military presence there from a strategic position. This is the state department's mission now.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
I'd say permanently. Good strategic position for potential future campaigns.
Do tell.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
IIRC, Saddam's old party is allowed to hold office in the new government.
If that's true, it's a fantastic idea. We shouldn't have let our viceroy outlaw them in the first place, provoking them into a seven year insurgency.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Our presence in Japan 55 years later is imperialism? I don't see how we're constructing or controlling their government at this point.
Maybe we should leave, then.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
Sure.
Isn't it possible defense bureaucracies succumb like all others to the tendency to grow without respect to the ultimate mission?
Sure.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
Maybe we should leave, then. They've had a bellyful of us.
Good strategic position for possible future campaigns.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
anyone that they even think might have had ties to saddam are disqualified.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
All Baathists were barred from govt office and the military after the invasion. This really hurt because a lot of them were professionals who weren't particularly Baathists politically like the Saddam and his top level ministers.
Not only did the Repugs lie themselves into Iraq, they botched every aspect.
They even botched the "surge" which greatly increased US and Iraqi deaths, which were already way down before the surge due to the ethnic cleansing/Balkanization of Bagdad.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Sec'y Gates proposed cuts to procurement. I'm guessing you'd be against that.
Are you?
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Our presence in Japan 55 years later is imperialism? I don't see how we're constructing or controlling their government at this point.
:lol
Are you serious?
We wrote their constitution and forbade them from having a real military of their own.
Quote:
I simply said that it would be good for us to maintain a military presence there from a strategic position. This is the state department's mission now.
The State Department's mission is to maintain a strategic military presence forever? Why is the plan to have all the military out in a year?
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
Do tell.
Well Chump mentioned Iran earlier...
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Good strategic position for possible future campaigns.
Like a game of Risk.
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Winehole23
Sec'y Gates proposed cuts to procurement. I'm guessing you'd be against that.
Are you?
No, I saw the proposed cuts...agree with them for the most part. Not crazy about the proposed 1.4-1.9% increase in military base pay, but you may be able to guess why...
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Well Chump mentioned Iran earlier...
Why would majority Shiite Iraq want the US to launch a military campaign from their country against Shiite Iran?
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Well Chump mentioned Iran earlier...
Whaddya think, would an attack on Iran endanger our troops and contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan?
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
Well Chump mentioned Iran earlier...
chump, did you say iran............when we're clearly discussing japan, vietnam, iraq, and possibly granada?
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
AFBlue
No, I saw the proposed cuts...agree with them for the most part.
My bad.
Quote:
Originally Posted by AFBlue
Not crazy about the proposed 1.4-1.9% increase in military base pay, but you may be able to guess why...
Fair enough. :tu
-
Re: Assessing America's 'imperial failure' in Iraq
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ChumpDumper
:lol
Are you serious?
We wrote their constitution and forbade them from having a real military of their own.
Notice I said "now". As in, we forbade members of Saddam's party who may have had allegiance to him initially, but eventually we left it to the government to decide who they let in and out of their organization.
Quote:
The State Department's mission is to maintain a strategic military presence forever? Why is the plan to have all the military out in a year?
The state departments mission is to focus on continuing to aid in the rebuilding of Iraq and strengthening its ability to defend itself from internal and external threats.