-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Why are the Spurs always on the losing end of these controversial calls?
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
StrengthAndHonor
Be that as it may, there were a lot of pulling, tugging etc, including a Spurs fan grabbing Steven Adams' arm when there's still time in the clock. The Spurs had ample opportunity to close it out but couldn't. Waiters nudge didn't decide the game.
I agree that the call didn't cost the Spurs the game. But is grabbing a jersey a foul? I mean it happens on every possession.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Darius Bieber
Doesn't matter, with the scrum down on the floor at the end, time would have run out. Non-issue.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Aggie Hoopsfan
Referee Marc Davis:
* Doesn't call the shove
* Doesn't call the travel on Waiters jumping to throw inbounds
* Starts clock as soon as ball leaves Waiters hand
Wonder what kind of bonus that sack of shit will get from the league for that.
And after Patty shot the 3, he didn't even look at the potential contact by Adams. His eyes were glued to the ball. He was in sports fan mode. Best seat in the house.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SpursFan86
They'll probably admit they missed the call, but bring up how a violation should've been called on Manu first for stepping out of bounds.
This will be their out for that no-call, drawing a moral equivalency between something that happens quite frequently, and something that basically never happens.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Clock was a non issue but man did Patty rush that three. He had 3 more seconds to fake and let Adams bump into him or put the ball on the floor and get a midrange.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Aggie Hoopsfan
Referee Marc Davis:
* Doesn't call the shove
* Doesn't call the travel on Waiters jumping to throw inbounds
* Starts clock as soon as ball leaves Waiters hand
Wonder what kind of bonus that sack of shit will get from the league for that.
Actually looking at that replay, inexcusable that he missed the traveling call on Waiters. Everything else was very minor compared to that.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Splits
Ref staring right at it and ignores it, fix was in
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
baseline bum
:lol
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
cd98
I agree that the call didn't cost the Spurs the game. But is grabbing a jersey a foul? I mean it happens on every possession.
No, they don't call a violation on those especially in the closing seconds. I'm just stating that there were a billion things going on that could've decided the game, but this one just isn't meant for the Spurs. On to game 3.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
How many fucking breaks do Spurs fans want to win the game? They blew it. Luckily OKC constantly gives games away in the fourth like they tried to tonight, so the Spurs should be fine in this series.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
So one last clarification on a few things:
O The intent of the rule about guarding an inbounds is not for what Manu did. It's why you see that happen all the time and never called. It's designed to prevent a defender from gaining an unfair advantage and/or touching the inbounder.
O Even if you wanted to go by the letter of the rule (which from my understanding is the incorrect interpretation of the rule) then Waiters, before Manu steps on the line, has the ball over the inbounds line which is a violation.
But just like that wasn't called because it's not the intent, Manu's wasn't called. The only missed call was Waiters push there and it was egregious.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SPURt
Mills should've pumped and taken the foul. Adams was not gonna be able to stop.
Thinking the same thing.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Beaverfuzz
Actually looking at that replay, inexcusable that he missed the traveling call on Waiters. Everything else was very minor compared to that.
The dude started the clock as soon as it left the hands of Waiters. Either ridiculously incompetent, or fixed.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
StrengthAndHonor
Be that as it may, there were a lot of pulling, tugging etc, including a Spurs fan grabbing Steven Adams' arm when there's still time in the clock. The Spurs had ample opportunity to close it out but couldn't. Waiters nudge didn't decide the game.
Pulling a Jersey? lol......
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DPG21920
So one last clarification on a few things:
O The intent of the rule about guarding an inbounds is not for what Manu did. It's why you see that happen all the time and never called. It's designed to prevent a defender from gaining an unfair advantage and/or touching the inbounder.
O Even if you wanted to go by the letter of the rule (which from my understanding is the incorrect interpretation of the rule) then Waiters, before Manu steps on the line, has the ball over the inbounds line which is a violation.
But just like that wasn't called because it's not the intent, Manu's wasn't called. The only missed call was Waiters push there and it was egregious.
That's a really good point about extending the ball over the line by Waiters.
Davis missed THREE violations and started the clock early. That sack of shit should have been on the podium after the game to explain himself.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Just asked in game thread; but maybe better here...Is that foul by the inbounding player supposed to be 1 FT and the ball or no?
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Spurs are going to win game 3...book it...
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
And Adams is legit mad at someone in the crowd for pulling his arm :lol Go Spurs(fans) go!
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Spurtacular
Just asked in game thread; but maybe better here...Is that foul by the inbounding player supposed to be 1 FT and the ball or no?
It's up to the referee's discretion, based on the rule book.
At a minimum, it should have been an offensive foul and Spurs ball. If the ref deems the contact excessive, they can call it a technical, which would have resulted in a technical FT and the ball.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
baseline bum
My nigga Magic with the goods. Could care less about Imam's trolling, tbh.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Aggie Hoopsfan
It's up to the referee's discretion, based on the rule book.
At a minimum, it should have been an offensive foul and Spurs ball. If the ref deems the contact excessive, they can call it a technical, which would have resulted in a technical FT and the ball.
TNT guys spouted technical; but it seems like a tech is rarely called on a basketball play. That tends to be reserved for extracaricular activities. I wasn't sure if it may also have qualified as a dead ball foul applicalbe to one shot. For instance, intentionally fouling an offensive man without the ball is a one shot and the ball foul.
-
Re: NBA will send a memo tomorrow saying Waiters fouled Gino...
Quote:
Originally Posted by
baseline bum
What the fuck was Ginobili thinking? Three from an ice cold Mills with like 8 seconds left and only down one? Fuck the no-call, your boy blew the game tonight Nono.
Spurs collectively lost the game tonight, except for the mighty Aldridge. Manu just put the icing on the sh-t cake with that bone-headed pass. IDIOT.