Reply With Quote
We did win.
Geoff Millard and I spoke to Sen. John McCain. When Geoff introduced himself as chairman of the board of Iraq Veterans Against the War, McCain retorted, "You're too late. We already won that one."
http://www.truth-out.org/john-mccain...one61699?print
========
Seems like Repugs never met a lie they wouldn't tell, never met a chapter in history they wouldn't re-write.
We did win.
The communist Vietcong unified the country after we left in 1975 and sent a million or so of our allies in the South to reeducation camps.
That's a win in your book?
The US didn't win. That's another military/right-wing lie, history rewritten in line with the myth that Big Bad Ass America Never Loses, America Never Even Does Anything Wrong.
The US ing quit because the US citizens, through anti-war protests, had had enough with 50K dead and 250K injured.
Sidenote: McCain was clearly referring to the Iraq War in the OP. As framed by b_d the headline is misleading.
What does Vietnam have to do with Iraq?The communist Vietcong unified the country after we left in 1975 and sent a million or so of our allies in the South to reeducation camps.
That's a win in your book?
Little late, bro. For my answer to your question, please see the post just above yours.
Right, my mistake.
McLiar is still lying about Iraq. We ain't won , other than proving the US can, in another war of choice on false pretenses, invade and destroy a country, with the destruction lasting for decades.
Last edited by boutons_deux; 07-26-2010 at 07:11 PM.
Yeah but seriously where does Vietnam come into it?
It doesn't, my mistake.
but I bet McLiar says we won in VN, too.
um...last i checked vietnam was still commie. we lost. we couldn't even best the french.
b_d: thanks. I reread it, thinking I was missing something, twice.
If Iraq can operate as a democracy without our training wheels, we can say we won.
Who cares about McAmnesty anyway? He could lose in the primary!
It's basically been operating as a failed state anyway, and we're on the way out the door - it's hardly operated at all since we've been there, anyone really believe that country can pick itself up by the boot straps and clear out corruption and militant violence?
Agreed.
I think it is fair to say that we won militarily. The juries still out if it's a win politically as far as democratic nation building.
the military won when we started paying them not to kill us.
they called it the "surge".
If that wre the case then the Dems win that seat in November..you can take that one to the bank...
"we won militarily"
bull . US/Petraeus won financially by buying off the insurgents, $300/month. I don't know whether that is continuing.
The Pax Americana in Iraq is very much like Pax Romana. Devastation everywhere, infrastructure destroyed and not repaired. Shiite-Sunni bombings killing dozens occur just about every week.
How's the $1B US fort (embassy) coming along?
Iraq is a hole, Iraqi politicians are as corrupt and polarized as American politicians.
An elective war-for-oil that is a total waste of lives and $Ts.
You do know that this statement diminishes any shred of credibility you might have? Do you also think 9/11 was an inside job?
US military is accustomed to wasting 100s of $Bs, so:
Department of Defense can’t account for 96 percent of money administered in Iraq reconstruction fund.
http://thinkprogress.org/2010/07/27/...tment-96-iraq/
====
yep, we "won" Iraq.
If our goal was to depose Saddam and help create a new government that we can control, then we mostly won. We deposed Saddam, but the jury is still out on whether this new government will last a day without our presence.
You actually gave Boutons a shred of credibility?
The goal (one of many bogus goals head threw against the media wall to see what would stick) was to grab the imagined, never-found WMD, deposing Saddam was a means to that end. No WMD, bogus mission failed. However, the MIC was enriched as is sucked down taxpayer $Ts, taxpayers endebted and interest paid on deficits for decades.
I don't think Iraq being "a war for oil" is on the same level of credability as "9/11 was an inside job." More people benefitted from 9/11 in terms of expanding power and directing funds/resources than the phantom oil people believe we (the US) control in Iraq.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
