Reply With Quote
the original one...yes...
the hollywood version....won't waste my time or money...
Badass movie, has anyone else watched it?
Ronney Mara
the original one...yes...
the hollywood version....won't waste my time or money...
4cc with incredible insight on a subject like always.
How is this different from the svedish versions anyone know? I would DL it but NBC sent me a letter saying they caught me dling some of their movies so I'd rather not push my luck.
I dont know what it is, but in the Svedish version the girl has sweeter s, definitely jelqworthy
Never sat down and watched the original version but the American version was good. I own the Swedish version (sister kept a red box version too long and ended up giving it to me) but I always forget and never watched it. I'll have to watch it and compare the two.
I don't know how much they changed the story in the original but they left out some really important aspects in the American version.
If I remember correctly it was pretty faithful, but honestly the book stands out in my mind better than the movie so I couldn't say for sure.
Nobody has seen both?
Me just the Sweedish.
It was good.
Manny you won't understand it. But i will help.
what did I tell everyone the popular y opinion would be about this movie?
Fincher is only a director at the top of his game, maybe the best director in the world at the moment, but clearly his version of the movie will suck, right?
He is so great that he feels the need to make a re-make of a Swedish movie....
what did I tell everyone the popular y opinion would be about this movie?
Fincher is only a director at the top of his game, maybe the best director in the world at the moment, but clearly his version of the movie will suck, right?
amazing talent....
wait what are you guys talking about?
The new one with the James Bond guy is actually with the original actress, so how would that be a remake?
original one was bad ass, 2nd part was pretty good. I think this new one is the 3rd part, not a remake
I think Fincher made it a better movie than it otherwise would have been. Mara was good too. But the story itself was pretty meh. I haven't read the books and probably won't.
B- overall.
oh nevermind, this one is a remake.
it's gonna suck compared to the originals. That swedish chick is what made the movie
Ya the few scenes i watched of the original, the skinny lesbo punk hacker chick was more believable than the previews of this one i see. Cuz i think the swedish chick is geuinely ugly...whereas they took a hot chick and tried to make her ugly for the american version.
I've already watched the foreign one and it was great.
Any comparisons to the original one yet? I've only seen the sweedish version which was good. I didn't like the sequels though.
lol so everyone who doesn't like it hasn't even seen it?
ummm...yeah that about sums it up!
but the new one sucks...I tell ya'
hollywood remakes of international films always suck ass. why should this be any different?
here are a few:
- the vanishing remake - sucked
- femme nikita remake - sucked
- diabolique remake - sucked
- open your eyes(vanilla sky) remake - sucked
- nigh ch remake - sucked
- italian job remake - sucked
- wicker man remake - sucked
- rec(quarantine) remake - sucked donkey balls
and on and on and on
BTW I heard hollywood gona make a remake of the movie Oldboy. Starring Wil Smith
Last edited by cheguevara; 12-28-2011 at 04:59 PM.
Don't forget one of the worst of all - City of Angels, made from Wings of Desire. Not agreeing they suck universally, but this one was godawful.
Girl with the Dragon Tattoo isn't a remake of a movie. It's an American film based on a book, one which happened to have a movie made about it in another country already.
ugly?
Can't_Be_Faded
"hot chick"
dunno about that comparison.
Panel?
Last edited by Fabbs; 12-28-2011 at 05:47 PM.
I liked it, a lot. Fincher is great.
what a ed up lot of people
has no one seen both you assholes
I'll watch the Swedish version on Netflix and report back.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
