Not good enough this year.
If your team doesn't win it all, they were not good enough this year.
And, how many times do both Pistons fans and Spurs fans talk about how the regular season means nothing compared to the playoffs. While it's important in order to get prepared for the playoffs and also for playoff seeding, championship caliber teams know that the playoffs is where a team proves it's mettle and worth. In 2004, the Minnesota Timberwolves were not good enough even though they had the league's best record. Same thing this year with the Pistons. When it counted, the Pistons were simply not good enough.
There is plenty of blame to go around. And, Flip shares in it. Chauncey shares it. Ben shares it. But, I will still contend that the main and overriding reason the Pistons failed to make it back to the NBA Finals is Rasheed's ankle. Some reports have said Rasheed's ankle was as bad as a twist as Tim Duncan's last year in Detroit. Timmy sat out several weeks. Rasheed did not miss a game. Heck, he returned in the game in which he twisted it. Pistons insiders said Rasheed was never better than 70% after spraining his ankle in the Cleveland series.
And, it showed.
He didn't have a standout game after that incident. He had a couple of good games. But, he was never dominating. He lost so much lateral movement that Antoine Walker was blowing by him off the dribble and when Ben collapsed to help, Shaq would get another dunk. His footing was not strong enough in the post so he could not get the strength of his base to get great post position even against the smaller Udonis Haslem. His lift on his jumper was nowhere near what it usually was and his jumpshot was off the rest of the playoffs.
There is a lot of blame to go around. There was some dissension in the lockerroom. Chauncey had a very poor playoff performance. Ben's free throw shooting made spinning on your head look easy.
But, make Rasheed 100%, and I think the Pistons make the Miami series much more compe ive. Give the Pistons a 100% Rasheed, and the Pistons finish the Cavaliers off in five games. I'm pretty sure both games 4 and 5 were two points games.
Maybe the Pistons don't beat the Miami Heat anyway. The Heat played very well and were extremely hungry. But, a completely healthy Rasheed would have made a difference. Maybe they win game 1. Or, maybe he helps them steal game 4 in Miami.
But, just like Wade's rib last year, injuries are a part of the game. It's not an excuse. It's just an explanation.