Vote off a guy movie. (A continuation of Shoogarbear's thread)

[IceColdBrewski]

This is a continuation of Shoogarbear's "Guy movie" thread. I saw this idea on another forum and it did well, so I thought we could try it here.

I'm going to list the top 50 guy movies (according to Men's Journal in 2003), as well as a few others I think are worthy of the list. They'll each start out with 5 points. I might also add some movies early on in the voting if enough people can convince me they should be added. To keep it going at least for a little bit, you can only vote once every 4 hours.

You basically reply and add a point to one movie, and subtract a point from another one.

Example:

+Fletch
-Diner

You'll then update the list after your addition and subtraction. Fletch would now move up to 6 points, and Diner would move down with 4.

Once a Movie reaches 0 points, it's officially "voted out." The last remaining Movie left obviously wins.

You may have to do some editing, so once you have posted your vote, please make sure that no one else has posted the same time you did. If they have, edit your post to update the list.

Here is the list:

5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--The Godfather
5 points--Scarface
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Diner
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--The Searchers
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Three Stooges
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Fletch
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--The Blues Brothers
5 points--Fandango

That's our starting list for now. I'll get the voting started in the next post to give voters an idea of how it works.

[IceColdBrewski]

6 points--Fletch +
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--The Godfather
5 points--Scarface
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Diner
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--The Searchers
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Three Stooges
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--The Blues Brothers
5 points--Fandango
4 points--Diner -

[Fillmoe]

scarface........

dirty harry......

carlitos way.....

[1Parker1]

scarface........

dirty harry......

carlitos way.....

I don't think that's how the game works...

[IceColdBrewski]

scarface........

dirty harry......

carlitos way.....

Please read the rules again. You obviously don't understand.

[Marklar MM]

6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather +
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Scarface
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Diner
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Three Stooges
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--The Blues Brothers
5 points--Fandango
4 points--Diner
4 points--The Searchers -

[Spurminator]

6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club +
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Scarface
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Three Stooges
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--The Blues Brothers
5 points--Fandango
4 points--The Searchers
3 points--Diner -

[Fillmoe]

sorry i shoulda read.... both of yall.....

6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club
6 points--Scarface +
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Diner
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--The Blues Brothers
5 points--Fandango
4 points--The Searchers
4 points--The Three Stooges -
3 points--Diner

[Marklar MM]

YOu all suck

[Spurminator]

, dude, every time I post or edit, someone else posts.

+1 Fight Club, -1 Diner.

[IceColdBrewski]

Fillmoe. You also have to subtract a point from a movie as well.

[Fillmoe]

Fillmoe. You also have to subtract a point from a movie as well.

i did... u blind?

[IceColdBrewski]

i did... u blind?

Ah..Gotcha. But bring it down to the bottom of the list so it makes it easier for the rest of us. And Diner should be at 3 points. You must have posted at the same time someone else did.

Sorry. I kinda have to explain this as we go along in the beggining until people start to figure it out.

[Marklar MM]

K. Copy the newest list made, then do the +- stuff.

[IceColdBrewski]

K. Copy the newest list made, then do the +- stuff.

Exactly.

[Fillmoe]

Exactly.

it gets thrown off because while you are doing it so is someone else.....

[IceColdBrewski]

it gets thrown off because while you are doing it so is someone else.....

Yeah I know, but it's really easy to edit your post once you've noticed what happened. The "once ever 4 hours" rule should keep it from getting out of control.

[johngateswhiteley]

fillmoe-
...your list is wrong. you have 4 + and 3 -

edit: you need to adjust The Searchers

[johngateswhiteley]

6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club
6 points--Scarface
6 points--Dazed and Confused +
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--Fandango
4 points--The Searchers
4 points--The Three Stooges
4 points--The Blues Brothers -
3 points--Diner

[IceColdBrewski]

6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club
6 points--Scarface
6 points--Dazed and Confused +
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--Fandango
4 points--The Searchers
4 points--The Three Stooges
4 points--The Blues Brothers -
3 points--Diner

I can't believe you're voting against the blues brothers. That's one of the all-time classics.

[johngateswhiteley]

I can't believe you're voting against the blues brothers. That's one of the all-time classics.

i don't think there is a more overrated movie on that list...never thought it was that good.

[TheSanityAnnex]

7 points--Scarface +
6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club
6 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--Fandango
4 points--The Searchers
4 points--The Blues Brothers
3 points--Diner
3 points--The Three Stooges -

[ShoogarBear]

WTF? No Magnificient Seven? I call bull .

[IceColdBrewski]

I'm adding "First Blood" and "The Magnificent Seven" to the list. If anyone has suggestions for additions, please speak up.

7 points--Scarface
6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club
6 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--The Magnificent Seven
5 points--First Blood
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
5 points--Fandango
4 points--The Searchers
4 points--The Blues Brothers
3 points--Diner
3 points--The Three Stooges

[ShoogarBear]

7 points--Scarface
6 points--The Magnificent Seven+
6 points--Fletch
6 points--The Godfather
6 points--Fight Club
6 points--Dazed and Confused
5 points--Dirty Harry
5 points--Diehard
5 points--The Terminator
5 points--First Blood
5 points--The Road Warrior
5 points--The Dirty Dozen
5 points--The Matrix
5 points--Caddyshack
5 points--Rocky
5 points--Full Metal Jacket
5 points--Dr. No
5 points--The Killer
5 points--Raging Bull
5 points--Bullitt
5 points--Enter The Dragon
5 points--Apocalypse Now
5 points-- Goodfellas
5 points--Reservoir Dogs
5 points--Fight Club
5 points--The Usual Suspects
5 points--Blazing Saddles
5 points--The Wild Bunch
5 points--The Maltese Falcon
5 points--Unforgiven
5 points--The Seven Samurai
5 points--The Big Lebowski
5 points--Shaft
5 points--48 Hours
5 points--Platoon
5 points--Animal House
5 points--The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly
5 points--The Longest Yard
5 points--Blade
5 points--Stripes
5 points--North Dallas Forty
5 points--The Untouchables
5 points--The Great Escape
5 points--The Hustler
5 points--Slapshot
5 points--The French Connection
5 points--Office Space
5 points--Easy Rider
5 points-- The Bridge On The River Kwai
5 points--Cool Hand Luke
5 points--Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
5 points--Pulp Fiction
4 points--Fandango-
4 points--The Searchers
4 points--The Blues Brothers
3 points--Diner
3 points--The Three Stooges

Ah, good.

Fandango? That Kevin Costner BS?