Lewis or Garnett?

[traitoravery]

If your Team were to acquire a top notch free agent next year who would you prefer? Rashard Lewis or Kevin Garnett?

[dirk4mvp]

srsly?



Garnett

[What a Good Guy]

traitoravery...

what a good guy!!!

[traitoravery]

What Garnett is past his prime and Lewis hasnt even tapped into his full potential....

[dirk4mvp]

So...Lewis > Garnett?

[dallaskd]

I voted Lewis.

[traitoravery]

So...Lewis > Garnett?

Idk its too tough to call but I would prefer youth or maybe im

[Flight3107]

Is this supposed to be serious?

[TDMVPDPOY]

give me lewis

[PM5K]

From a pure talent perspective I'd choose Garnett, but I think Lewis might fit in to our current team better, and he's a little younger, of course Garnett isn't past his prime quite yet...

[Bob Lanier]

Lewis is a winner with more range on his jumpshot and a much better low post game.

Garnett is a loser, but he defends and rebounds much better.

Give me the winner.

[exstatic]

How is Lewis a winner? Are you a winner if you get the big contract, and stop rebounding and playing defense? Yeah, KG can't take a team anywhere by himself, but he'd be a of a lot better "Pippin" than Lazy Lewis.

[Bob Lanier]

He's a winner in the sense that he doesn't completely shrivel up when a game needs to be won.

[monosylab1k]

He's a winner in the sense that he doesn't completely shrivel up when a game needs to be won.

When's the last time he's been in a situation where the game needed to be won? A game that actually matters, i mean.

This is ridiculous. Might as well be a "Danny Ainge or Larry Bird" thread.

[exstatic]

I can't believe this is even a discussion.

You can't build a team around either, but as a second or third option, KG is light years ahead of Lewis in overall game. He can shoot, score, rebound supremely, block shots and dish assists. Lewis can shoot and score.

[Fillmoe]

garnett in a minute

[cornbread]

When's the last time he's been in a situation where the game needed to be won? A game that actually matters, i mean.

This is ridiculous. Might as well be a "Danny Ainge or Larry Bird" thread.

It doesn't really fit the "game that matters" criterion but didn't he bury a dagger 3 last night to win the game?

Give me KG any day of the week.

[lordswing]

Give me KG

[ro_50]

Is this really a SERIOUS poll question? Come on, you can't be serious.

[SRJ]

I don't think it's a bad question.

Garnett is the superior player, no question. However, Lewis is also long and athletic, he's younger than Garnett, and would come with a smaller price tag. Of course, you take Garnett if the money's the same, but I don't see that happening.

[ChumpDumper]

[mavsfan1000]

A lot of Garnett haters on here. lol

[JamStone]

Rashard Lewis is a winner? He's a better low post player?

Wow, I'll have some of whatever is being passed around ...

mavsfan1000, I laugh every time I see my quote in your sig. That's a good one.

[mabber]

Wow, I really can't believe a few of you picked Lewis.

[spursreport]

Lewis is an overrated player who was a joke to make the all star game 2 years ago.