Judge Orders Release of Gitmo Detainee With Ties to 9/11 Attacks

[Shastafarian]

allito's dissent
http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/05-184.ZD2.html

And?

[Shastafarian]

No focusing on one word that suits my idiotic earlier statement will do fine. Derrrr.

[Winehole23]

No focusing on the term Privilege and Right in the Cons ution will do fine.

Go ahead. Focus on that.

I don't think you know what what the language means. The privilege was much esteemed at the time, and the language that follows that word stresses that it is not to be removed, except in case of rebellion or invasion.

[spursncowboys]

Enemy combatants are given a permitable (to the situation) alternative to habeas corpus. like alito wrote, they are given an alternative that should be allowed. The idea that these guys are in gitmo with no ability to challenge their imprisonment is made of straw.

[spursncowboys]

Until the SC says otherwise, Hamdan is the law. You're just underscoring that.

Oh that's right, because it is a living and breathing do ent. Good consistency WH.

[Shastafarian]

It smells like someone doesn't understand how the Supreme Court works.

[spursncowboys]

It smells like someone doesn't understand how the Supreme Court works.

He was a cons utional law professor. So what was he teaching?? IDK.

maybe him??

[Shastafarian]

Keep guessing

[Winehole23]

Oh that's right, because it is a living and breathing do ent. Good consistency WH.

I'm not a doctrinaire "originalist" (whatever that means after Raich) but I wouldn't be too sure originalism supports you here.

[spursncowboys]

????????

[ChumpDumper]

habeas corpus isn't in the cons ution.

[spursncowboys]

[Shastafarian]

any evidence to the contrary?

[Winehole23]

[Shastafarian]

I'm pretty sure all those people have a basic understanding of it. It seems to give you some trouble though.

[Shastafarian]

Curious why you didn't post this picture:

[spursncowboys]

I'm pretty sure all those people have a basic understanding of it. It seems to give you some trouble though.

I know there is a difference between a right and a privilege. Do you?

[spursncowboys]

Do you have any evidence that a right and a privilege are the same thing?

[Shastafarian]

I know there is a difference between a right and a privilege. Do you?

Absolutely. Do you know how to differentiate between those in the statement including habeas corpus in the Cons ution? That is if you do in fact believe habeas corpus is in the Cons ution.

[Winehole23]

I know there is a difference between a right and a privilege. Do you?

Lay it out for us, profe. What's the difference?

[Shastafarian]

What's funny is that it's pretty clear he didn't think it was in the Cons ution at all. Then, after the actual words were posted here, he scanned through and noticed his ace in the hole. Problem for him is that his ace in the hole is paired with a deuce and we've all got pairs.

[Winehole23]

Like, look it up in the dictionary, is a real retort. Amazing.

[Winehole23]

The obliviousness to utter pwnage is as plain as it is amusing.

[Winehole23]

[spursncowboys]

this is pwnedge???
Now I know. Thank you WH and Shasta,we are all better off reading your well articulated comments.
Check the time of when I edited my comments.