Actually, this seems like a thread that needs to go at least to the end of Reg Season. I'm surprised at the variances in responses.
In a world of instant gratification and Slam Online, it would appear that a great many of posters here are easily swayed by the media outlets who inundate your mind with what they perceive you should think and do. DON'T BE A ROBOT!
Do your own research and format your own opinion.
I get that Griffin was the #1 pick overall. But really, what did he accomplish? National Player Of The Year? Big Deal, so did Sean Elliott as a Wooden Player of the year, and Danny Ferry, so did David Robinson and Tim Duncan, so does that mean that that instantly translates into greatness?
The 4-letter might want you to believe that, in fact...it used to be a decent rule, however...times change. Observe:
1983 Ralph Sampson Virginia Played with Houston but leg issues were too much.
1984 Michael Jordan North Carolina GOAT Nuff said.
1985 Patrick Ewing Georgetown A HOF Center for sure
1986 Johnny Dawkins Duke So what did he do in the NBA exactly? NOT MUCH.
1987 David Robinson Navy Best player to ever retire for the Spurs
1988 Danny Manning Kansas Did his best work as a Clipper until the curse got him.
1989 Danny Ferry Duke So, what did he do in the NBA other than become a role player?
1990 Lionel Simmons La Salle His best years were in Sacto but no All-Star or ALL-NBA Injuries did him in too.
1991 Larry Johnson UNLV There was a time when Grandmama was a force. But back issues did him in. He was fairly solid but again, not what one would build a team around.
1992 Christian Laettner Duke What did he accomplish again?
1993 Calbert Cheaney Indiana Same question
1994 Glenn Robinson Purdue Scorer who couldn't play a lick of D. Won a ring as a Spur in a low bench role.
1995 Joe Smith Maryland Greatest Claim To Fame? Responsible for Minnesota losing 3 straight #1 draft picks for collusion and tampering of Salary Cap
1996 Marcus Camby Massachusetts Good Post Player, All-NBA D Team, Solid Defensively, limited offensively.
1997 Tim Duncan Wake Forest Greatest PF To ever play the game
1998 Antawn Jamison North Carolina A scoring big too small play big 4's, too slow to cover fast 4's Has good range out to 3 but nothing more than a 3rd Team Star
1999 Elton Brand Duke Has had some shining moments in the NBA, probably best Duke player ever but is currently fighting to get back to All-Star level due to injury
2000 Kenyon Martin Cincinnati Good Defender, Okay range...Bad At ude
2001 Shane Battier Duke Good Defender, okay 3 point shooter but nothing more than that
2002 Jason Williams Duke Blame The Motorcycle
2003 T. J. Ford Texas Blame the small frame and reckless style for Neck Issues
2004 Jameer Nelson Saint Joseph's Good shooter, strong defender for his size. SOLID.
2005 Andrew Bogut Utah Finally showing potential. Will Challenge for ball on both sides. Turning into a solid Center.
2006 J. J. Re Duke Nothing more than a bonafide stretch shooter. Hasn't shown much else.
2007 Kevin Durant Texas Currently, he's the Thunder in Oklahoma City. George Gervin re-booted in a 6'10" frame.
2008 Tyler Hansbrough North Carolina Meet Eric Montross....yet again. No, Tyler's better, I think.
2009 Blake Griffin Oklahoma REMAINS TO BE SEEN
2010 Evan Turner Ohio State Same thing
So out of 27 Players of the Year, only 4 are truly HOF level players. Add 3 to 5 more players who are at least critical to their team's success and then the rest? Great College players no doubt, but have been treated like flotsam and jetsam in the NBA. Many of these college greats have bounced like NBA Journeymen. So again....study the tapes, look at the stats, don't just go by what 4-letter says or by what the Big 12 Media book tells you. I once talked to Bill Self here in LA, He was out to watch one of his guys, and he told me, this guy is going to be a very solid NBA player. He said,"When you have enough skill to be called the Big 10 player of the year, you can make waves in the NBA."
The player he came to watch? He played for the Lakers his rookie year...I give you, BRIAN COOK. Yeah, that Brian Cook. Or as I like to remember. 1 of 3 guys that Manu dunked on during a National TNT game. Yeah, I was there live. That was a fun win.