Mvp?

[Blake]

Who is the clear MVP right now?

[Phillip]

If all teams pretty much continue on course with what they have been doing so far, I'd say it would be between Vick, Manning, and McFadden.

Vick obviously has been an absolute beast, and would most likely win it. Can't even begin describe how amazing his transformation has been from an underacheiving QB, to prisoner, then to the deadliest weapon in the NFL. He turned an Eagles team that most people thought would blow ass, into Super Bowl favorites out of the NFC.

Manning constantly produces more with less help than most, if not all other QBs in the league. The guy is just amazing in how he leads teams and makes talent look great.

McFadden has been one of the biggest reasons Oakland is in contention to win the division and make the playoffs, and if they do, most definitely he will be getting a good chunk of votes. He is playing at a higher level than any RB in the NFL, and doing so with a passing game that has been inconsistent at best, although clearly improving thanks to his presence.

[Dr. Gonzo]

My vote goes to Chad Henne for being a flawless QB.

[Blake]

My vote goes to Chad Henne for being a flawless QB.

Henne had 7 flawless victories last year

[Jawlinedo Cockman]

My first thought was a three way tie between Bess, Marshall, and Henne, however you only made this one choice only.

Hmmmm....this choice is about as tough as my dream guy's jawline. I guess I'll go with Henne the quuarterback

[DisgruntledLionFan#54,927]

If you're going to have Lloyd, then you have to add Roddy.

And DMac will probably get as many MVP votes as I'm going to get.

Right now, I'd probably vote Rivers.

[Blake]

If all teams pretty much continue on course with what they have been doing so far, I'd say it would be between Vick, Manning, and McFadden.

Vick obviously has been an absolute beast, and would most likely win it. Can't even begin describe how amazing his transformation has been from an underacheiving QB, to prisoner, then to the deadliest weapon in the NFL. He turned an Eagles team that most people thought would blow ass, into Super Bowl favorites out of the NFC.

Manning constantly produces more with less help than most, if not all other QBs in the league. The guy is just amazing in how he leads teams and makes talent look great.

McFadden has been one of the biggest reasons Oakland is in contention to win the division and make the playoffs, and if they do, most definitely he will be getting a good chunk of votes. He is playing at a higher level than any RB in the NFL, and doing so with a passing game that has been inconsistent at best, although clearly improving thanks to his presence.

If Vick 5 or 6 games like he did last night, I would think he gets it, but I don't know that he can in the NFC East.

The only knock is that he's barely thrown more than half the passes of the league leaders.

I think Manning squeezes out another trophy in the end.

I forgot to add Tom Brady in there. To be fair, he's a legit candidate even if he used Beeber's stylist.

[DisgruntledLionFan#54,927]

And Foster would be my OPOY.

[Phillip]

If Vick 5 or 6 games like he did last night, I would think he gets it, but I don't know that he can in the NFC East.

The only knock is that he's barely thrown more than half the passes of the league leaders.

I think Manning squeezes out another trophy in the end.

I forgot to add Tom Brady in there. To be fair, he's a legit candidate even if he used Beeber's stylist.

I think Vick missing games in a sense could work for him, because of the fact that when he has been out, the Eagles sucked , while when he is in there, they look like monsters. But more than likely, it will work against him.

Peyton definitely has a great shot at another one though.

Brady definitely deserves to be considered as well.

[Phillip]

And DMac will probably get as many MVP votes as I'm going to get.

Right now, I'd probably vote Rivers.

D-Mac turned a team that has lost 11 games in 7 consecutive years, that has consistently had a offense, into a top 10 offense (2nd in rushing) and a possible playoff contender.

Rivers on the other hand has consistently had an extremely talented team that underachieves, and now while he is having a monster year, and definitely deserves to be considered for this honor, his team is 4-5 and behind the Raiders. Yet somehow he should be the winner, while McFadden deserves no votes?

Yeah, that makes sense . And this is coming from someone who is actually a big Rivers fan.

[DisgruntledLionFan#54,927]

Probably, as in at the end of the year.

And if you're going to go with perennial bad teams that are possible playoff contenders and attribute it to one guy, I'd go Freeman over DMac.

[Roddy Beaubois]

IM, with the goods.

[DisgruntledLionFan#54,927]

And I voted Rivers as the favorite for the rest of the way. Manning, Brady and Vick are right there with him, though.

And if you're going to vote MVP for the first half of the season, shouldn't a guy like Matthews get consideration? It's been pretty amazing what they've been able with the amount of injuries on the defensive side of the ball and he's a big reason why.

[vander]

If you're going to have Lloyd, then you have to add Roddy.

And DMac will probably get as many MVP votes as I'm going to get.

Right now, I'd probably vote Rivers.

shouldn't the team be good though?

and I think in all of the Chargers losses, Rivers & Co. had a chance to take the lead in the 4th quarter,

[JMarkJohns]

Kurt Warner, as the Cardinals are crap without him... he's most valuable hahahah...


Hard to argue against Vick's production thus far.

[dallasmavsnfuego214]

If Darren McFadden receives any MVP votes, I think it's time to do away with the award for good

[dallasmavsnfuego214]

D-Mac turned a team that has lost 11 games in 7 consecutive years, that has consistently had a offense, into a top 10 offense (2nd in rushing) and a possible playoff contender.

Rivers on the other hand has consistently had an extremely talented team that underachieves, and now while he is having a monster year, and definitely deserves to be considered for this honor, his team is 4-5 and behind the Raiders. Yet somehow he should be the winner, while McFadden deserves no votes?

Yeah, that makes sense . And this is coming from someone who is actually a big Rivers fan.

Huh? McFadden isn't carrying his team anywhere close to the way Rivers is.

[Cry Havoc]

The only knock is that he's barely thrown more than half the passes of the league leaders.

Maybe that's partially due to the fact that Vick is 39th in rushing in the NFL this year?

[dirk4mvp]

stretch has always been one of the biggest homers on this board, just no one really notices cuz it's the in Raiders.


tbh, Rivers is my pick for MVP so far. howeva I'll hold off on voting for a few weeks till Peyton slides into that spot, IMHO.

[DeadlyDynasty]

stretch has always been one of the biggest homers on this board, just no one really notices cuz it's the in Raiders.


tbh, Rivers is my pick for MVP so far. howeva I'll hold off on voting for a few weeks till Peyton slides into that spot, IMHO.

+1.
Dude is playing with a bunch of unknown pacific islanders at WR and he's putting up record-breaking numbers. and does anybody really think SD is not winning the West?

[DisgruntledLionFan#54,927]

Maybe that's partially due to the fact that Vick is 39th in rushing in the NFL this year?

That'd be a really, really small part considering he's only taken roughly 50% of the offensive snaps for the Eagles this season.

Though he did get dinged running the ball so I guess it depends on how you look at it.

[LnGrrrR]

Whoever wins the annual pats/colts will win the MVP, barring some spectacular team collapse.

[8FOR!3]

I picked Dez Bryant. But in reality it's Michael Vick and then that bag Philip Rivers.

[Phillip]

If Darren McFadden receives any MVP votes, I think it's time to do away with the award for good

Huh? McFadden isn't carrying his team anywhere close to the way Rivers is.

stretch has always been one of the biggest homers on this board, just no one really notices cuz it's the in Raiders.


tbh, Rivers is my pick for MVP so far. howeva I'll hold off on voting for a few weeks till Peyton slides into that spot, IMHO.

It is most definitely homeristic of me to say that other people AT THIS MOMENT deserve the award over Rivers, as he is doing such a great job carrying a team that is ranking 1st in offense and 2nd in defense to a whopping 4-5 record. Last I checked, the last time Peyton had a team that was even in the neighborhood of top 10 in both those categories, his team was 8-1 at this point (the only loss coming to the 18*-1 Pats)

Right now, Vick and Peyton should hands down be getting the majority of the votes.

DMac obviously isnt going to get any votes, but if he keeps playing at the pace he is, and gets the Raiders to the playoffs, then he most definitely deserves at least a little consideration in the race is all I'm saying.

[monosylab1k]

stretch has always been one of the biggest homers on this board, just no one really notices cuz it's the in Raiders.


tbh, Rivers is my pick for MVP so far. howeva I'll hold off on voting for a few weeks till Peyton slides into that spot, IMHO.

crofl like you're one to talk. How's Anthony Gonzalez as GOAT working out?

also

" whenever an AFC South rival does anything good I have to downplay it because i'm insecure about Manning getting his ass beat"