Reply With Quote
That's really not a bad list. It's sort of debatable at the end, though. Carr and Bortles are on a lower tier, and Romo and that collarbone may be disqualified.
As of this offseason:
1) Brady
2) Roethlisberger
3) Rodgers
4) Newton
5) Wilson
6) Brees
7) Luck
8) Eli Manning
9) Rivers
10) Romo
Just missed cut: Dalton, Carr, Bortles, Flacco, Stafford
That's really not a bad list. It's sort of debatable at the end, though. Carr and Bortles are on a lower tier, and Romo and that collarbone may be disqualified.
i'd put rivers ahead of eli and luck
We can just say Manning now. The dinosaur retired.
1. Newton
2. Rodgers
3. Brady
4. Roethlsiberger
5. Brees
6. Luck
7. Palmer
8. Rivers
9. Romo
10. Wilson
yeah... just realized palmer isn't on OP's list. he faceplanted in the playoffs, but he's better than some of the names there
How about some reality?
1.Brady
2.Rodgers
3.Big Ben
4.Brees
5.Romo
6.Wilson
7.Luck
8.Newton
9.Eli
10.Rivers
Last edited by Avante; 04-13-2016 at 01:17 PM.
That's a good list.
However, I'd replace Smith with Rivers, tbh.
I can see that, and will make the change. The reason being I debated Rivers there.
Don't you know that Wilson has had a better start to his career than...anyone?
And he also has some NFL firsts.
Only QB to ever post two 100 QB ratings in his first two seasons of pro football.
The best six game TD/INT span in history.
The only 4000/30/500 QB in history.
It's definitely a great list in 2012
Brady and Big Rape over Rodgers
If leadership is part of the grading, you need to drop PhilBilly to 29th in the NFL.
Ahead of Manziel, yes.
You ever actually look at just who was ranked in the previous season?
Russell Wilson's 110.1 number one in the NFL.
Flacco is done. Rodgers couldn't do without Jordy, but Newton strived with Ted Ginn
Post your list big boy.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
