The White House is not just any building, and—when itcomes to historic preservation—Hoagland is not just any person. In failing to appreciate as much, the Court misconceives the plaintiff ’s injury, allowing the Executive’s likely infringement of the Legislature’s power of the purse andauthority to regulate federal property in the District of Columbia to continue. Today’s decision is no victory for the separation of powers.Winston Churchill once remarked that “[w]e shape ourbuildings, and afterwards our buildings shape us.” Onwards to Victory: War Speeches by the Right Hon. WinstonS. Churchill, C.H., M.P. 317 (1944). All the more reason to ensure that those responsible follow the rules in decidingwhat to tear down and what to build up at the People’sHouse.
I respectfully dissent.