Anyone watch American Idol?

[Horry For 3!]

Noooooooooo. Ace is singing the song that I excell at

[Horry For 3!]

Except Bucky should do good as he sings country all the time

I forgot Pickler is a country singer too.

[Sonia_TX]

I didn't really like Taylors performance (I usually love him)... Mandisa sucked, Elliott was good (love Garth), Paris was really good and Ace was looking hot...I mean he sounded good. He needed it tonight or else he might have been in danger of going home. With Kellie I agree with Simon...didn't like the song but liked the performance although I think it started off slow.

[Spurminator]

Kellie has that typical nasal Nashville country voice that I can't stand but apparently sells a lot of albums.

[Horry For 3!]

Katharine

[Spurminator]

When did that become a country song? Did someone remake it?

[Sonia_TX]

I'm so freakin' glad that Chris came out of his rock comfort zone. He finally stuck w/the theme and didn't change it to rock. He actually has a nice voice when he's not screaming.

Katharine can do no wrong in my book. She's gorgeous, her voice is amazing, and I want her to win. lol I didn't like the song tonight but her voice was still great.

I didn't really pay attention to Bucky's performance since I was wrapped up in other things. What do you guys think?

I honestly don't know who I think will be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. I would put Mandisa and Kellie in the bottom along with Taylor (although he probably won't be). I haven't gotten the whole Mandisa thing so I wouldn't hate to see her leave. She does nothing for me.

[T Park]

Mandisa butchered Shania Twain's song.


Proving to these pop punks that country is a music choice you gotta take serious.

[Spurminator]

Mandisa butchered Shania Twain's song.

Meh, it was like pissing on a pile of really.

[T Park]

I haven't gotten the whole Mandisa thing so I wouldn't hate to see her leave. She does nothing for me.

haven't gotten that she has more talent in her pinkie finger, than Bucky the wonder redneck has in his entire body.

[T Park]

Meh, it was like pissing on a pile of really

I'll take Shania Twain over any of these non talented rock and pop punks any ing day.


So yeah, she did on it.

[T Park]

If tommarow never comes, prob one of the most beautifull songs ever written, while Garth Brooks, IMO, not that great a singer, made it fantastic


Elliott did a good job with it Elliottt

[T Park]

Paula passes up Bill Maher for most painfull and annoying person on TV.

[T Park]

I agree with Simon, why do the brain dead morons in the crowd have to boo everytime hes honest?

[T Park]

Paris, wow, what a fantastic rendition of "How would I live" personally one of my favorites, and on top of it, a tough song to do after Leann Rimes and Trisha Yearwood have made it platinum. She did a an amazing job, so far from what I've seen, THE BEST perforance.

[Spurminator]

I'll take Shania Twain over any of these non talented rock and pop punks any ing day.

Shania blows. She's among the worst female vocalists in Nashville's not-too-proud history.

Give her an average face and body and she's still in Canada selling handjobs for rent money.

[T Park]

Ace singing "I wanna cry" prob my favorite Keith Urban song.

And, folks, fantastic performance from Ace, his best this season.

Ace? Your in number 1 overall right now. Glad he stepped away from the whole falsetto thing too. He has a great voice, Im glad he showed it.

Bravo Ace.

[T Park]

Nashville's not-too-proud history

not too proud??

Well, I guess its too bad its not like hollywood, and all their rock and roll drugheads...

[Spurminator]

Who's comparing it to Hollywood?

They suck too.

[T Park]

I love how people like Spurminator, and at times Randy Jackson and others, who look down at country as its the underbelly of music, its just classic.


BTW, Kelly Pickler great rendition of "Fancy" by Reba.

I loved her line, and I feel that wayA when I work in California "Its good to talk to someone with a familiar accent"


AMEN SISTA!!

[T Park]

Who's comparing it to Hollywood?

Well your comparing it to something....

[T Park]

Rock on Chris. Great job with Keith Urban's "Memories of Us"

Great voice, glad he got away from the freaking SCREAMING

Way to actually SING finally Chris.

My favorite performance of his since the Bon Jovi song.

[Spurminator]

Well your comparing it to something....

Yeah, I'm comparing it to real country music.

[T Park]

ohhhhh

real country music, like what 50s??

I see....

[T Park]

Katherine McPhee, good song, but I've never heard of it...