Vince or R-Jeff?

[JamStone]

RJ had sex with Tyson Beckford.

They both have character flaws.

(Sorry, I couldn't resist)

[clubalien]

I suspect if we had picked up VC the votes would all have been for him.

However, I still believe VC is the better player, certainly would've added much needed excitement to the team, and additionally, we would have scored the 11th pick in yesterdays draft.

Vince Carter absolutely.

As far as age, RJ was brought in to utilized Duncan's shrinking window. Once Tim is gone, all hands will be re-evalued anyway, better believe it.

I think RJ is better than vince, because in the words on knicks fans "vince sucks". I think ROn artest would have been the best 3 for the spurs. Cheaper too.

[HarlemHeat37]

Ron Artest would have been by far the worst fit..he has some of the worst shot selection in NBA history..

Vince is a much, much better player than RJ, but like everybody else has said, Jefferson is definitely the better fit..he'll also be able to play the defensive stopper role that Pop wants, while VC wouldn't have been able to do that at this age..

[rayray2k8]

Simple
Manu + Jefferson > Vince Carter