8 people who would be better judges than Ellen DeGeneres

[Frenzy]

i'd go with charles barkley

[Cry Havoc]

Why Ellen?

What musical qualifications does she have to judge other wanna-be stars?

[Summers]

i'd go with charles barkley

You could be onto something there!

[Kori Ellis]

I like Ellen. She is good humored and an authentic person. Between the other three judges there is more than enough music industry know how.
I think Ellen will bring a refreshing and enjoyable perspective.

It's funny that you call her authentic. From what I know from people who have worked on her show, she's a monster. They say she's beyond fake and treats everyone who works for her like trash... even telling people that they shouldn't look at her or speak unless they are spoken to. She's regarded as one of the real jerks in Hollywood.

[jaffies]

8. Pee-wee Herman
7. Vijay Singh
6. Fred Savage
5. Jim Hacksaw Duggan
4. Sleepy Floyd
3. Abe Vigoda
2. Jean-Luc Picard
1. Turtle and Drama!

[Summers]

2. Jean-Luc Picard

[jaffies]

[RuffnReadyOzStyle]

Am I the only one who despises Ellen? Her talk show is on at midnight over here, and every time it comes on and the audience gives her a standing ovation for 20 minutes I want to throw a brick through her face.

She is not:
1)funny
2)insightful
3)interesting
4)any positive adjective I can come up with.

She comes off as lame and disingenuous to me. Did she beat a life-threatening disease or something? Why the do people love her so much?

It's funny that you call her authentic. From what I know from people who have worked on her show, she's a monster. They say she's beyond fake and treats everyone who works for her like trash... even telling people that they shouldn't look at her or speak unless they are spoken to. She's regarded as one of the real jerks in Hollywood.

Patrick Stewart would be superb. Not only is he a superb actor, but he has a DRob like dignity about him as a man. He'd be the good guy on the panel.

[angel_luv]

It's funny that you call her authentic. From what I know from people who have worked on her show, she's a monster. They say she's beyond fake and treats everyone who works for her like trash... even telling people that they shouldn't look at her or speak unless they are spoken to. She's regarded as one of the real jerks in Hollywood.

Well people who work with her would know where I would not. I should have said that she appears to be genuine.
She is very nice on television, I can say that much for her.

[Cry Havoc]

Well people who work with her would know where I would not. I should have said that she appears to be genuine.
She is very nice on television, I can say that much for her.

So is Christian Bale.

[angel_luv]

So is Christian Bale.

And so are a lot of celebrities.

Hollywood is not exactly known for producing genuine people.

The character Ellen portrays on her show is likeable. And I think that character would be a good addition to American Idol.

[Soul_Patch]

It's funny that you call her authentic. From what I know from people who have worked on her show, she's a monster. They say she's beyond fake and treats everyone who works for her like trash... even telling people that they shouldn't look at her or speak unless they are spoken to. She's regarded as one of the real jerks in Hollywood.

I have a friend i used to work with at Boeing who left and took a job as the System Admin for the Dr. Phill show. He had almost the exact same thing to say about working for Phil, almost to the letter the same....wierd.