Mvp?

[monosylab1k]

And Brady has no business being in the MVP discussion. He's been inconsistent all season long.

New England's success this season is because Belichick has pretty much pushed all the right buttons. He should definitely be in the COTY running.

[vander]

Kurt Warner, as the Cardinals are crap without him... he's most valuable hahahah...

seriously

though they lost a few other good players too

[dallasmavsnfuego214]

It is most definitely homeristic of me to say that other people AT THIS MOMENT deserve the award over Rivers, as he is doing such a great job carrying a team that is ranking 1st in offense and 2nd in defense to a whopping 4-5 record.

If the season were to end right now, I would agree with you in that Rivers doesn't deserve the MVP for leading the team to a 4-5 record. That's just not good enough. However, a lot of people are looking at the Chargers' resurgence and pretty much thinking that them winning the division is inevitable. Whether that's right or wrong, I don't know, but that's what's driving a lot of the votes right now. So if I were to cast my vote right now it would definitely be for Peyton since the Colts are in 1st place.

DMac obviously isnt going to get any votes, but if he keeps playing at the pace he is, and gets the Raiders to the playoffs, then he most definitely deserves at least a little consideration in the race is all I'm saying.

I agree here. If McFadden were to carry his team to the playoffs (IMO he would have to step it up a little he's only on pace for 1400 yards) and rush at a high level then he does deserve consideration cause essentially he would be doing the same thing that Rivers, Vick, and Manning are doing. He would also get bonus points because it's the Raiders. However, as of now, he's not shouldering as big a load as the other three are doing. That's why he wouldn't get any votes if it were to end today.

[dirk4mvp]

why's Rex Ryan getting so much attention? all he does is cuss it's not like he's a good coach or anything i hate him

[dirk4mvp]

and of course the only reason mono is coming to stretch's rescue is because it's involving an arkansas player.

lmao matt jones

[RedsLakers24]

wheres Tom Brady?????????? He's leading a young team to a 7-2 record.

[Nick Manning]

Clay Matthews, tbh. He's a lock for DPOY but he could easily be MVP as well imo

[SpursFanFirst]

No way they give it to Vick just yet. He could be playing on the field alone and beating teams, and I doubt they'd give it to him.

Personally, I'm glad he's back. I've always felt like he deserved a second chance after serving his time. But I think there are still a lot of people with reservations.

Not Vick...not this year.

[SpursFanFirst]

Whoever wins the annual pats/colts will win the MVP, barring some spectacular team collapse.

This is the other thing I'm thinking...
The Colts have had a lot of major injuries this year, and they're still a very tough team, with a huge thanks going to Peyton.

BUT...I think it all comes down to the game this weekend against NE.

Peyton or Brady wins it this year.

[Phillip]

If the season were to end right now, I would agree with you in that Rivers doesn't deserve the MVP for leading the team to a 4-5 record. That's just not good enough. However, a lot of people are looking at the Chargers' resurgence and pretty much thinking that them winning the division is inevitable. Whether that's right or wrong, I don't know, but that's what's driving a lot of the votes right now. So if I were to cast my vote right now it would definitely be for Peyton since the Colts are in 1st place.





I agree here. If McFadden were to carry his team to the playoffs (IMO he would have to step it up a little he's only on pace for 1400 yards) and rush at a high level then he does deserve consideration cause essentially he would be doing the same thing that Rivers, Vick, and Manning are doing. He would also get bonus points because it's the Raiders. However, as of now, he's not shouldering as big a load as the other three are doing. That's why he wouldn't get any votes if it were to end today.

Actually McFadden is on pace for 1500+ yards. But I agree he would need to step it up a bit for serious consideration by season's end. However, the question in the thread is RIGHT NOW. And right now, he has been playing well enough to be among people being discussed, although not a serious candidate to actually win it, mainly because of Vick and Manning being so dominant.

[Phillip]

and of course the only reason mono is coming to stretch's rescue is because it's involving an arkansas player.

lmao matt jones

lmao saints
lmao tracy porter

[Phillip]

No way they give it to Vick just yet. He could be playing on the field alone and beating teams, and I doubt they'd give it to him.

Personally, I'm glad he's back. I've always felt like he deserved a second chance after serving his time. But I think there are still a lot of people with reservations.

Not Vick...not this year.

this post = proof that women have no business debating sports, tbh

[dirk4mvp]

lmao saints
lmao tracy porter

lmao bucs

lmao same playbook

[Phillip]

lmao bucs

lmao same playbook

lmao bears
lmao needing rex grossman as a 12th man on defense

[dirk4mvp]

lmao al davis

lmao det guy's fast!

[SpursFanFirst]

this post = proof that women have no business debating sports, tbh

Uh huh. so I take you have nothing constructive to add. That figures.

[dirk4mvp]

lol stretch getting regulated

[Phillip]

Uh huh. so I take you have nothing constructive to add. That figures.

lol defensive

[Phillip]

lmao al davis

lmao det guy's fast!

lmao 2 rings
lmao raiders = 3 rings
lmao 3>2
lmao 3 rings got

[monosylab1k]

[dirk4mvp]

[dirk4mvp]

lmao pickle breath bros trying to defend each other

[monosylab1k]

lmao siding with SFF just cuz she's a colts fan.

[Blake]

But I think there are still a lot of people with reservations.

Not Vick...not this year.

what people have reservations about him getting an MVP?

PETA doesn't get a vote.

[DeadlyDynasty]

lol all of you mother ers. Bills nation for life.