Giants @ Cardinals game thread

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

any Giants fan saying he voluntarily fell is in re ed. He clearly tripped and stumbled, that wasn't intentional at all.

Still, the Cardinals deserved to lose.

[Bill_Brasky]

It's way too open for interpretation, I'll definitely say that.

He probably did fall accidentally....but most people that do that would try to get right back up and keep running. He didn't.

After he fell he made the decision to stay down and made no effort to advance the ball....which, technically, makes him down right?

I don't know. It was a weird play.

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

He didn't try to get back up because there were 3 defenders about to touch him, it wouldn't have done anything.

And no, "staying down" doesn't technically make him down, "down by contact" is the only thing that technically makes him down.

There's a reason why Eli had an, "Are you in kidding me?" look on his face when he left the ball on the ground and the Cardinals went to pick it up.

[pawe]

The only Giant fan I can imagine defending that non fumble call is timmytozo, but the others? SMH

[Bill_Brasky]

Either way Cruz is a ing idiot for not playing until the whistle and not hanging onto the ball.

[pawe]

Either way Cruz is a ing idiot for not playing until the whistle and not hanging onto the ball.

It's like a pick up game in basketball..sometimes you just pass the ball inbounds while you're still on the baseline.
That call cost me $110 bucks though.

[Vici]

He didn't try to get back up because there were 3 defenders about to touch him, it wouldn't have done anything.

And no, "staying down" doesn't technically make him down, "down by contact" is the only thing that technically makes him down.

There's a reason why Eli had an, "Are you in kidding me?" look on his face when he left the ball on the ground and the Cardinals went to pick it up.

He was about to get back up, saw the defender then went back down. As someone mentioned it's the same as the QB taking a knee or a guy kneeling in the end zone for a touch back.

Now he did fall, no question, but he was going down as soon as he saw the defender to his right and he slipped on the way down. It's what the ref saw and replay shows. Doesn't matter Giants would have won regardless.

And yes staying down does make him down, at least according to the rulebook.

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

Giants would have won regardless ? Are you in re ed? If that was ruled a fumble the Giants lose. NY homers are a special kind of stupid.

[Tradition]

He was about to get back up, saw the defender then went back down. As someone mentioned it's the same as the QB taking a knee or a guy kneeling in the end zone for a touch back.

Now he did fall, no question, but he was going down as soon as he saw the defender to his right and he slipped on the way down. It's what the ref saw and replay shows. Doesn't matter Giants would have won regardless.

And yes staying down does make him down, at least according to the rulebook.

Please shut the up you dumb son of a . You were in here crying like a little 2 years ago when the Saints beat your team 48-27. You were crying that the refs were calling it one sided then you went into hiding. Please just shut the up.

[Vici]

Please shut the up you dumb son of a . You were in here crying like a little 2 years ago when the Saints beat your team 48-27. You were crying that the refs were calling it one sided then you went into hiding. Please just shut the up.

lol I don't even remember that. Pathetic.

[Vici]

Giants would have won regardless ? Are you in re ed? If that was ruled a fumble the Giants lose. NY homers are a special kind of stupid.

Oh you're right, the Cardinals were rollin in the fourth quarter and just needed the ball back to win. Not like there was 3 minutes left in the game or anything...

[pawe]

Oh you're right, the Cardinals were rollin in the fourth quarter and just needed the ball back to win. Not like there was 3 minutes left in the game or anything...

They have a 3 point lead with 3 minutes left and the Giants cant seem to stop the Cardinals' running game all day.

[Tradition]

lol I don't even remember that. Pathetic.

Here you go...pathetic!

The Saints have been getting a ton of favorable calls today. Still can't believe they called PI on Webster.

I have been watching the game. I seen receptions taken back by ty calls on the ref to end Giants drives, including one for a touchdown. I've seen the Saints not have to do a damn thing because the refs are marching them downfield on god awful calls.

The Giants suck ass but the Saints aren't football gods like this game would make you think.

Don't get your panties in a wad because your team had help today. I don't know why I even bother posting about football on a basketball forum. Even Aikman is talking about how bad the calls were lol.