Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 26 to 48 of 48
  1. 01-22-2012 #26
    DeadlyDynasty
    Allenhu Joshbar DeadlyDynasty's Avatar
    My Team
    Buffalo Bills
    Post Count
    27,972
    bump
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote DeadlyDynasty is offline
  2. 01-22-2012 #27
    DeadlyDynasty
    Allenhu Joshbar DeadlyDynasty's Avatar
    My Team
    Buffalo Bills
    Post Count
    27,972
    One game away from having bragging rights over big brother--and he can get that second ring in Peyton's house too
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote DeadlyDynasty is offline
  3. 01-22-2012 #28
    resistanze
    CDs Nuts. resistanze's Avatar
    My Team
    Green Bay Packers
    Post Count
    23,869
    This SB is Peyton's worst nightmare - who does he root for?
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote resistanze is offline
  4. 01-22-2012 #29
    DAF86
    ಥ﹏ಥ DAF86's Avatar
    My Team
    Kansas City Chiefs
    Post Count
    47,238
    Untill I see Eli managing all the aspects of the QB position like Peyton does/did I'm going with the bigger brother.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote DAF86 is offline
  5. 01-22-2012 #30
    Nathan89
    Done with the NBA
    Post Count
    18,479
    2-14 says Peyton has been taking scrubs to the playoffs.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Nathan89 is offline
  6. 02-05-2012 #31
    HarlemHeat37
    Veteran
    Post Count
    42,293
    So, what's the answer, now?..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote HarlemHeat37 is offline
  7. 02-05-2012 #32
    lefty
    TheDrewShow is salty lefty's Avatar
    My Team
    Green Bay Packers
    Post Count
    101,216
    Elite !
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote lefty is offline
  8. 02-05-2012 #33
    Josepatches_
    Asturiano Josepatches_'s Avatar
    Post Count
    2,341
    Peyton.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Josepatches_ is offline
  9. 02-05-2012 #34
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    Career is Peyton but one game

    It's Eli..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  10. 02-05-2012 #35
    midnightpulp
    SeaGOAT midnightpulp's Avatar
    Post Count
    27,061
    Peyton. I don't think rings should define a player in the NFL, considering the NFL season is ostensibly the playoffs. The NFL is a league where "regular season" stats and performances actually matter.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote midnightpulp is offline
  11. 02-05-2012 #36
    TIMMYtoZO
    Heat/Phillies/NY Giants TIMMYtoZO's Avatar
    My Team
    New York Giants
    Post Count
    4,346
    As much as I love Peyton, Elite The Eliminator Manning is ahead of him now. Elite Manning is going to win at least 2 more superbowls in the next 3 years. This is the beginning of a NY Giants dynasty.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote TIMMYtoZO is offline
  12. 02-06-2012 #37
    dbreiden83080
    Veteran dbreiden83080's Avatar
    Post Count
    20,159
    With this win Eli will go down as a legend in NY forever. He is right there with Derek Jeter now.. All time Peyton will probably have him beat but Eli has been so clutch in the big games.. He is a HOF and a legend in his own right..
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dbreiden83080 is offline
  13. 02-06-2012 #38
    stretch
    we rang stretch's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    17,070
    Eli certainly has an argument for late-game clutch situations, not because Peyton is unclutch, but because Eli tends to just be amazing in the clutch.

    But Peyton still > Eli for now. Eli is more naturally gifted and talented IMO, but still doesn't exhibit the consistency that Peyton shows.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote stretch is offline
  14. 02-06-2012 #39
    dirk4mvp
    Based dirk4mvp's Avatar
    My Team
    Indianapolis Colts
    Post Count
    24,173
    Stretch does it hurt you to know what school Eli went to?
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dirk4mvp is offline
  15. 02-06-2012 #40
    stretch
    we rang stretch's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    17,070
    Quote Originally Posted by dirk4mvp
    Stretch does it hurt you to know what school Eli went to?
    The same one as the greatness we know as Jevan Snead went to?
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote stretch is offline
  16. 02-06-2012 #41
    dirk4mvp
    Based dirk4mvp's Avatar
    My Team
    Indianapolis Colts
    Post Count
    24,173
    Does it?
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dirk4mvp is offline
  17. 02-06-2012 #42
    stretch
    we rang stretch's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    17,070
    Quote Originally Posted by dirk4mvp
    Does it?
    Certainly not. I have nothing against Ole Piss.

    I just like to LMAO @ Jevan Snead.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote stretch is offline
  18. 02-06-2012 #43
    manufan10
    BOlieve manufan10's Avatar
    My Team
    Dallas Cowboys
    Post Count
    10,210
    As of now, I would still take Peyton, but the gap isn't as wide as it once once.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote manufan10 is offline
  19. 02-06-2012 #44
    Blake
    right about pizzagate Blake's Avatar
    My Team
    Baltimore Ravens
    Post Count
    83,735
    Quote Originally Posted by dirk4mvp
    Stretch does it hurt you to know what school Eli went to?
    Rofl Eli outgunned by insert Tech QB (and Welker)
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Blake is online now
  20. 02-06-2012 #45
    Blake
    right about pizzagate Blake's Avatar
    My Team
    Baltimore Ravens
    Post Count
    83,735
    Back in October, I'd have easily taken Peyton.

    Not today. Eli is easily the calmer, more clutch Manning.

    Peyton's happy feet make me nervous just watching him.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Blake is online now
  21. 02-06-2012 #46
    Trill Clinton
    Kang Trill Clinton's Avatar
    My Team
    Dallas Cowboys
    Post Count
    20,741
    Terrific Tom
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Trill Clinton is offline
  22. 02-06-2012 #47
    dirk4mvp
    Based dirk4mvp's Avatar
    My Team
    Indianapolis Colts
    Post Count
    24,173
    Quote Originally Posted by Blake
    Rofl Eli outgunned by insert Tech QB (and Welker)
    Eli: 2 sb mvps


    Tech: 0
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote dirk4mvp is offline
  23. 02-06-2012 #48
    Blake
    right about pizzagate Blake's Avatar
    My Team
    Baltimore Ravens
    Post Count
    83,735
    Rofl insert Tech QB outgunning a two-time Super Bowl MVP.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Blake is online now
« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Forum Rules