LOL Jay Bilas forcing the NCAA's hand. I love that dude.
As for the OP, I don't think they should be paid (by the schools or the NCAA)
However, they should be allowed to profit on their own likenesses and make whatever kind of money off-campus they can, as long as its legal. If a booster wants to buy a kid a car, who the cares? Basically what JoeTait75 said, only make it so that it doesn't have to be under the table.
Furthermore, the top conferences need to leave the NCAA, make their own realistic rules (to include recruiting), and implement a true playoff system (8 or more teams)