Reply With Quote
pale face dirk have curse
Classic mouse all the way!
pale face dirk have curse
2 winners for a loser
i don't think it's a good idea
2 consumate winners for 1 consumate choker? Never.
2 guys who know how to win for 1 who can't deliver? Waste of time.
2 guys who beat up on opposing players as opposed to 1 who beats up on stationary bikes? Nope. You can keep your non clutch lil' German.
Last edited by ehz33satx; 11-06-2007 at 08:03 AM.
no
yeah I Would !! An MVP for 2 quality players like Manu and TP ? We would have Washington at the point and Brent/Ime to take Manu's minutes. It makes total sense.
Who would be able to stop us with Dirk hanging out by the 3 pt line all game ?
STUPID QUESTION deserves a STUPID ANSWER.
In other words, Are you out of your ing mind ? Manu gives more effort taking a dump than Dirk gives on the court.
I would consider it, but I think we'd lose more than we'd gain.
It seems to me that you are contradicting yourself.
two guys who were essential ingredients to 3 championship teams in exchange for what?
Nobrainer - NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2 starters that know the system, won 3 rings and contribute in two completely different positions for Dirk? 2 All Stars/ 1 Finals MVP - the other one should've won it in 2005 IMO- for 1 addmittedly regular season MVP? The intagibles that both TP and Manu bring to the game vs. Dirk? Dirk is a good player but never equal to those two.
I hope you were just playing around and not really serious about the question.
Otherwise you're in immediate need of therapy. Lots of therapy.
Would you trade Dirk for Tony and Manu?
Anyways what makes Dirk so untradeable? He has not shown he can win anything major but regular season MVP and 1 division champion banner. A stud that does not make him. Tim, Tony, Manu and Mike Finley are all studs.
Now I'm not saying it's a smart trade... but the mere thought of a duo of Dirk and Duncan is absolutely insane... Imagine how well they would play off each other. Dirk on the outside, Duncan on the inside... It might be the most unstoppable offense in the history of the NBA. And you would still have Duncan manning the middle on D, Bowen locking up the opponents best player and still hitting that corner 3... they would just need to find someone who is capable of running point without ing up, and can hit an outside jumper, like Derek Fisher, and IMO that would be another 2 les at least. Of course the Spurs would never do it, and I can't blame them either, but honestly, while the Spurs would lose some guard action and defense, the offense would be completely unstoppable, as they would have a duo of the best PF in NBA history, and the best shooting big-man in NBA history, and both guys are great at picking up fouls on their opponents. It would be a constant matchup nightmare.
On Dallas end, that would be a stupid trade, as we are already loaded at the guard positions. So whoever thought of such a dumb trade.
no, but i'd give up manu and anything else except tony and tim for kobe
If the question was worded accurately, "would you give up two all-stars with top ten ranking in their position for one all-star with top ten ranking?", I think the answer would be an obvious "No".
Then if you pile on the facts that you'd be gutting your Big 3, effectively shipping out 2/5 of your best players and add the indefinable but real qualities known as "heart" or "choking", then the answer becomes " , no!"
this would be one of those trades that actually hurts both teams
How about Manu/Parker for Durant? I know the salaries dont match, but if they were able to make them match with KT & Ridnour, would you be willing to give up Manu & TP to get Durant? To me TP & Manu for Dirk is an easy NO...but talking about Durant, it is a much tougher decision.
The mere thought of this trade is pure blasphemy.
I would trade Finley for Granger.
spurs would lose in the 1st round if this happened.
A guy they call Mouse.
Not even close.
Dirk blows.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
