Man the honor level kills me in RDR2. I just found a gold prospector, waited for him to find some gold, once he did hogtied him, robbed him, and drowned him in the river and still my honor level is really high because I greet everyone friendly on the road. I have 3/4 a full honor bar despite murdering everyone who says anything bad to me and also robbing every house I come by (and killing everyone inside).