Joe Johnson Vs Brandon Roy

[tlongII]

ive been a blazers fan for years but easily joe johnson

Your fan card has just been revoked!

[Mr.Bottomtooth]

You're fan card has just been revoked!

He's not a fan card has just been revoked!

[Red Hawk #21]

You're fan card has just been revoked!

It got revoked because he chose not be a total homer? Damn Tlong it seems you can't handle the truth.

[lefty]

Gimme Joe Johnson any day. I like Roy but really don't get why people blow their chodes over him. He's a solid player but he's never going to be more than a 17-20 ppg guy who is best suited as a second or third option on a good team.

[bdictjames]

I'd take an all-around player over a one-dimensional scorer any day.

[Dex]

Gotta love that "I'm right and reality is wrong" logic.

[Darthkiller]

As much as i love the blazers next year( will root for them against anyteam not named spur or suns), JJ > roy. Much better shooter and much more experienced.

[tomtom]

Exactly, Tlong is being quite childish here. I still love the blazers, they have a lot of potential this year. They've done a good job starting over and getting rid of scrubs like Randolph. It hasn't exactly been easy watching them the past several years.

[Warlord23]

The Celtics, the best defensive team last year, double-teamed Joe Johnson more than they doubled Kobe. In fact they blatantly doubled JJ away from the freaking ball.

JJ is the prototypical swingman, terrific on offense and pretty good on defense, clutch, handles the ball well and has the ability to log major minutes without injury. No contest - JJ is much better than Roy

[tlongII]

There's no effing way that JJ is better than B-Roy! I'll just let this season play out and you will come to realize this fact!

[manufor3]

There's no effing way that JJ is better than B-Roy! I'll just let this season play out and you will come to realize this fact!

okay you do that

[IronMexican]

I would take Rudy Gay over both of these guys.

[monosylab1k]

I would take Rudy Gay over both of these guys.

[dirk4mvp]

I would take Rudy Gay over both of these guys.

JJ>Rudy>>>>>>>>Roy

[robbie380]

http://www.basketball-reference.com/...y.cgi?id=M9hhs

jj v roy

http://www.basketball-reference.com/...y.cgi?id=tr80c

jj v rudy

http://www.basketball-reference.com/...y.cgi?id=t5trd

roy v rudy


if someone knows how to actually post those stats please do so i can learn how to do it.

[IronMexican]

They don't even stick each other. Gay is a SF.

[robbie380]

JJ>Rudy>>>>>>>>Roy

rudy is on a much crappier team thus inflating his numbers. roy creates a ton for his teammates but gay simply just doesn't. i think rudy is a good player but overrated because of inflated points due to the crappy team around him.

edited

[Red Hawk #21]

rudy is on a much crappier team thus inflating his numbers. roy creates a ton for his teammates but roy simply just doesn't. i think rudy is a good player but overrated because of inflated points due to the crappy team around him.

??

[robbie380]

??

fixed!!

[IronMexican]

Gay is a SF, while Roy is a combo guard. What else would you expect?

[dirk4mvp]

rudy is on a much crappier team thus inflating his numbers. roy creates a ton for his teammates but gay simply just doesn't. i think rudy is a good player but overrated because of inflated points due to the crappy team around him.

edited

At the same time, he plays on a team full of guards who want to jack up shots too. Their stats are very similar. Gay is also a better athlete, and he's younger.

[nkdlunch]

Johnson is a SG. Roy too but he also can play PG.

Johnson is more talented and can take over games. Roy, not yet at least. I'd take Johnson easily.