SLAM magazine updated TOP 50 Players EVER

[carrao45]

explain why. Please...I really want to hear a good reason that puts Shaq above Duncan. Duncan has a jumpshot..Shaq never has...Duncan has a better FT percentage, is more athletic, is more clutch, has more MVPs...what, besides the fact that he could use his weight to back someone down, makes him better than Tim?

Prime Shaq was more athletic actually. And more dominant. Shaq was UNSTOPPABLE in his prime

[carrao45]

lol..ok..even if we're pretending that you're right, you still haven't said what makes Shaq a better player overall than Tim. What does Shaq have that is so much better that overrides the fact that Shaq has no jumpshot, and is a much worse FT shooter than Tim. Tim has a better skillset in the paint. Shaq just backs people down. How is Shaq better?

It doesnt matter is Duncan has great fundamentals, because Shaq was just more dominant...No matter what. In 01, Mutumbo was the DPOY, and he couldnt stop shaq for a second in the finals. Not one second. You dont see Duncan EVER being that Dominant, not for a second

[KSeal]

He'd eat Shaq!

at whoever said Mikan>Shaq

[carrao45]

Mikan wouldnt even come close to 10 points and 5 boards per game in today's NBA